« Digital pictures and the Web tilt Iraq attitudes | Main | Apple's PowerBooks are still too much money »

May 08, 2004

Back to paper

I've gone back to paper.
The charm of the PDA has passed.
Don't get me wrong. I love my Treo 600 and it has all my phone contacts. I couldn't stand being without them. But I've grown weary of maintaining electronic calendars on my Treo and on my computer, even though syncing them up every day is pretty painless.
The problem is, sometimes you just don't want to have to turn on a gizmo to search for an appointment.
So this week, I went back to a FranklinCovey planner.
Anthony, the friendly salesman I encountered at my local store, remembered me from my previous visits a few years ago, before I switched to all electronic records. He wasn't surprised to see me.
"A lot of people are coming back," he said. "Or at least they're combining the PDA and paper planners. Too much hassle, they say about the PDAs." Now FranklinCovey has it covered both ways. They sell a lot of Palms and have designed their binders and organizing systems around them.
But I wanted a plain old paper calendar and planning system.
I bought a large Monarch binder because it allows me to punch holes in printouts of e-mail and the documents that I need and then to then put them full-sized in tabbed sections devoted to various projects. It didn't take long to appreciate the ease of my "new" system.
A paper appointment book can be seen by just opening it up, instead of booting it up.
I feel organized again.


in Mobile lifestyle | TrackBack (0)

Comments

"...instead of booting it up"?

My Treo doesn't need to boot up either. I just hit a key.
This is a a site about "tech:knowledge"-y and you've gone back to PAPER?

Heresy! ;-)

For me, it's less about the convenience and ease of a digital PDA than it is the peace-of-mind inherent in the synchronizing/backup paradigm. The next time you MISPLACE that paper binder and realize it's your only copy... and all of your scribbled notes/appointments are lost forever... you'll come rushing back to the digital world, and pronto.

Don't you backup your computer? So why wouldn't you desire a backup of your appointment data? Or are you going to be photocopying that binder once a week?

Posted by: Josh at May 8, 2004 10:25 AM

Regarding: Was there life before PDA's

Rumor has it that paper recordkeeping has been around for a few thousand years. This suggests a very mature technology. Even in the electronic age this quaint method still has some utility.

Posted by: Tracer at May 8, 2004 12:13 PM

Mike, I guess it's a little difficult for me to figure why you think paper is less hassle than a PDA. I have a Palm Tungsten that I sync to my iBook using Bluetooth, and it couldn't be simpler. I do notice that since I've used Bluetooth, I sync more often than when I used to have to dig out a cable to do it. Also, when I travel, the PDA has a heck of a lot of functionality in a very small volume (including e-books and FreeCell to help pass the time in airports!).

But I can also understand your antigizmoitis attack. I have them occasionally, too.

Posted by: Garry at May 8, 2004 04:14 PM

Mike, I have gone back and forth on this one myself over the years. It's funny that each time I switch I feel more oganized. I think that the truth is that I am just plain disorganized and no "system", electronic or paper, is going to change that. The only thing that saves me is that I always tell my students that they have to assume that I have forgotten our appointments and they should hunt me down.

Of all the things I have tried the only one that has helped at all is automatic email notification of appointments. I once carried a pager for several years and I had a chron job page me to take my medicine every 4 hours. These days my calendar is lying around here somewhere, my contacts are in my iPod and I am in a constant state of wondering what I'm forgetting now.

If you find something to keep you organized then more power to you!

Posted by: Eric at May 8, 2004 04:51 PM

WOW!

So I'm not the only one?

One thing about paper vs. he electronic screen is the wide-view take everything in a once glance you can do. I actually have a folder with printed calendars that I write my appointments on. I have a list of to-dos for each situation I regularly find myself in (work, home, in front of computer) that I maintain in Excel, and again, I love the everything at once glance you simply can't get with the small screen of a PDA.

But for reminders, contacts, mp3's and articles and email I want to read later...the PDA rocks.

Both have their place.

Posted by: Tachbay at May 8, 2004 05:04 PM

I just switched back to paper too for my phone and addresses - after 10 years with various electronic and pda organizers. The type was too small on my pdsa and the battery required too much attention. Sometimes paper is just better.

Posted by: di at May 8, 2004 06:09 PM

i loved all the feedback on this article. very interesting. sincerly

Posted by: rick at May 8, 2004 07:41 PM

I don't know if anyone else will admit feeling this way, but--does anyone feel just a bit. . .dare I say it. . .n-e-r-d-y when you pull out your PDA in public? There's something kind of refined and civilized about writing with a pen on paper that's missing when using an electronic gadget, even though they are handy. Could this be behind some of the "switching" that's happening? Just curious.

Posted by: Tom at May 8, 2004 11:24 PM

Interesting article. Several of my friends vowed they would never give up their filofaxes - However since getting the Treo600 they havent looked back! Just the ability to have the data backed up at home, office and in your hand and ALL synched together switched them.
Wonder if you have ever lost your filofax / franklin!

Posted by: Geoff at May 9, 2004 06:41 AM

I still have my contacts in eelctronic form... and SOME of my appointments. Think of the paper as a third back-up, if you will.

Posted by: Mike Wendland at May 9, 2004 07:04 AM

I've done the same thing. Too many crashes, and WAITING for the program to load. It's easier to write. Also, I seem to remember it better when I've written it down.

Look at Planner Pads. www.plannerpad.com. Alternative to covey and I seem to like them so far.

Posted by: Daniel at May 9, 2004 06:34 PM

Whether you use electronic or paper or stone tablets to store data, you gotta have a system for having only ONE address list, calendar, todo list, etc., to maintain or you'll go bananas trying to keep things straight and find data when you need it.

Posted by: pat at May 9, 2004 07:28 PM

Indeed. Paper is cheaper, easy to use and provides a way to view EVERYTHING at once in a reasonable font-size. Palms are overrated. To each his own. To me, it's all about the pen and paper... Graffiti is a pain to use day in and day out.

Posted by: Noel D. Jackson at May 10, 2004 02:17 AM

I have never liked the concept of Graffiti input and tiny screens either. That is why I still use my Newton MessagePad 120.

It may be large compared to Palms, but it is no larger than most Filofax notebooks. After 9 years, it has learned my handwriting style very well.

With NewtSync, I can keep it synced with Address Book and iCal.

Posted by: Bob Studer at May 10, 2004 01:57 PM

I have gone back to a paper planner simply because I found with a PDA I did not capture notes of conversations or ideas that occur to me when not in front of a keyboard. I find having all this in one place is great.

Posted by: BC at July 8, 2004 12:10 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits