
I wrote about this last weekend when the first images of soldiers being humiliated by American soldiers made their way to the Net and the world.
I said then that those images will forever alter the public perspective of the war. And that has certainly happened. It will continue. For those pictures, and many more, are everywhere on the Net.
This piece from AP today underscores my original point, quoting an international photographic expert as saying:
"The iconic images coming out of this war may be the amateur photographs of Iraqi prisoners."Thie piece goes on to say how easy Internet connections in Iraq and the widespread use of laptops and digital cameras have made it impossible to keep a lid on military operations.
I love how everyone thinks this is NEW news. Photos were taken in 2003. The military announced back in January that there was a prisoner abuse investigation in progress. And the media just now is reporting this? Good ol media bias.
Now mistreating prisoners is not a good thing. However, where was the uproar when the Iraqis captured our troops and KILLED them? Why are we apologizing for the mistakes of 12 people?
This situation is blown completely out of proportion.
Posted by: baw at May 7, 2004 03:59 PMHere is the release from January;
"Release Number: 04-01-43
"FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
"DETAINEE TREATMENT INVESTIGATION BAGHDAD, Iraq An investigation has been initiated into reported incidents of detainee abuse at a Coalition Forces detention facility. The release of specific information concerning the incidents could hinder the investigation, which is in its early stages. The investigation will be conducted in a thorough and professional manner. The Coalition is committed to treating all persons under its control with dignity, respect and humanity. Lt. Gen. Ricardo S. Sanchez, the Commanding General, has reiterated this requirement to all members of CJTF-7." News release, U.S. Central Command, Jan. 16, 2004.
Posted by: baw at May 7, 2004 04:11 PM"Now mistreating prisoners is not a good thing. However, where was the uproar when the Iraqis captured our troops and KILLED them? Why are we apologizing for the mistakes of 12 people?"
1. As more and more evidence pours out, it's becoming blatantly clear that this was *not* just "12 people" but a wide-ranging, systematic culture of humiliation and degredation. Rumsfeld himself stated today that there's a LOT more worms to come out of this can.
2. We're supposed to be BETTER than our enemy when it comes to human rights. That's one of the cornerstones of Democracy. Once we start treating POWs as horribly as those we're fighting, we instantly lose *any* moral high ground, and become, instead, the same kind of thugs that we're supposedly fighting against.
3. It now appears that in addition to torturing, raping and humiliating the prisoners, coalition forces may have also murdered a few along the way as well.
4. The first justification given for invading Iraq was WMDs and a supposed Iraq-9/11 connection. Once it became clear that there weren't any WMDs, there was no clear evidence of ANY connection between Iraq and 9/11, and virtually every bit of intelligence we had was flat-out wrong, the Bush admin changed tracks and started claiming that the justification for invading was humanitarian--freeing the people of Iraq from torture, rape and murder.
Guess what? We've just lost that justification as well. Do you think Iraqi citizens feel any better knowing that the person sodomizing and urinating on them is an American or British soldier instead of one of Hussein's men?
And the "at least we feel bad about it afterwards and prosecute the ones we catch" response doesn't do much good for those who've already gone through it.
Finally, even if you *were* somehow justified in your thinking, the fact remains that we've somehow managed to become even more hated worldwide than we were a few months ago, if that's possible, and MAJOR damage control (ie, WIDESPREAD prosecution of EVERYONE involved in this travesty) *must* follow, swiftly and with no BS along the way.
Somehow I doubt this will be forthcoming.
Posted by: Charles Gaba at May 7, 2004 07:12 PMA democraticaly elected leadership wages aggresive war (Against international law) and delays prosperety by spending absurd amounts of money doing so.
It happens that warriors go overboard in treating there captives it cant be avoided but war can be avoided in the first place. Now every totalitarian goverment need wepons of mass destruction to defend them selfes.
And what does iraq have to do with terrorist ?
Posted by: erik Ahrsjo at May 7, 2004 08:29 PM
I find it ironic that ANY kind of photography has ALWAYS been prohibited on virtually ALL military bases (and other defense related contractor sites) *in the US* but the Pentagon has been slow to establish any kind of restrictions for soldiers and cameras *on the front lines of an active combat zone*!
I'm not saying good or bad, just inconsistent...
Posted by: Robert at May 7, 2004 09:02 AM