« Wi-Fi at the airport | Main | Preoccupied with family blog »

May 01, 2004

The power of images

I'm in Green Bay, WI (at Lambeau Field, home of the Gren Bay Packers, no less) teaching a day-long seminar for the Wisconsin Broadcasters Association.
One of the sessions I teach deals with the power of images.
Unfortunately, I have new and powerful examples to show this morning.
There is nothing - nothing - I have ever seen in 30-years as a journalist as powerful as these photos of Iraqi prisoners being abused and tortured by U.S. soldiers.
They will, I believe, change the course of the war, the presidential election in the U.S. and the way the U.S. and Americans are seen by the rest of the world for generations to come.
The action of six sicko soldiers has tarnished us all.
These pictures will be historic. The Web will keep them forever before the eyes of the world and, I fear, America's growing list of enemies.
We all have been hurt by these pictures. They will be a scandal that never dies and set in motion far-reaching and negative effects in the war against terror, fueling Iraqi insurgency and Arab and Muslim rage against the U.S. across the globe.
No matter what punishment is exacted on the soldiers who did this and their commanders who allowed it, no matter how decent and fair are the 150,000 other U.S. soldiers in Iraq, no matter the disgust of the American public and its leaders over such inhumane action by a handful of sadistic soldiers, these photos will speak louder and be remembered... forever.


in News | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Seems it's not just the Americans... The Daily Mirror has a story (with pictures) of British soldiers doing it too.
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/allnews/tm_objectid=14199634%26method=full%26siteid=50143%26headline=shame%2dof%2dabuse%2dby%2dbrit%2dtroops-name_page.html

Posted by: Magnus at May 1, 2004 10:52 AM

I think you are wrong about it affecting the outcome of the election, Mike. Certainly the most strident opponents of Bush will try to pin it back on him, but I don't think the charge will stick. If it were Bush and Rice doing the thumbs up in the photos, or if there were orders from the White House to mistreat prisoners, then this administration would certainly lose the election.

But short of that, I'm skeptical that anybody would believe that the commander-in-chief was responsible for the actions of officers he probably never met and whose training and careers were in progress (probably) long before he ever took office.

May the full might of United States military justice fall on the officers who committed these atrocities. They must be punished without mercy for their incomprehensible cruelty.

Posted by: Brian at May 1, 2004 12:51 PM

I can't believe this either. It's sick what some will do and yes, the actions of these few will affect the rest of us. The problem here (and the reason this WILL affect Bush and his re-election) is that Bush and the U.S. Government were the ones to send these troops over there. By doing that, they pretty much need to accept all the actions of every U.S. military personnel there. When these morons did this, it did and will continue to hurt our nation. It will have a lasting effect. Think about all the times you hear how cops are bad. How they are racist and how they profile. Yes, some do this but most don't. You don't hear about that because of the FEW that made it look bad for the rest of them.

Those that are guilty of this should face full justice at the hands of International law. Kicking them out of the military or sending them to a plush prison in the states won't be enough.

Posted by: Realist at May 1, 2004 01:44 PM

Really, in the big scheme of things, who cares? This will be just a blip in history. I looked a the pictures and was appalled. The people who took part and their supervisors should be sent to Leavenworth to break big rocks into smaller rocks for a long time. But, I don't think this can be pinned on Bush or even America as a whole. Any Islamic nation that uses this isolated incident to justify killing more Americans was going to do it anyway. I remember right after 9/11 people would say how we needed to eliminate "Islamic extremists" and then in the same breath would say that "Muslims aren't our enemy, the terrorists are. It is a peaceful religion". Intelligent people will be able to make a distinction between regular Americans and criminals who made it into the armed forces. If they can't and the decide to act against Americans that same armed forces will bury them. I think, and I hope the Islamic nations are tinking this too, that so far the US has been reining in the troops, stopping them from using everything at their disposal to win, protecting the "sort-of" innocent. There may come a time, when we are backed into a corner, that the US will do everything to destroy those nations. I'm sure Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Iran, etc. still remember the embarrassment of having the largest army in the midddle east (Iraq's) fall so quickly to our forces. We could own a huge swath of the region in a few weekends time and they better remember that when they think about what happened to a few criminals who had been cowardly assassinating American soldiers.

Posted by: Who cares at May 1, 2004 05:32 PM

Who cares, you seem to have a rather distorted view of our military strength, when you make statements that we can "bury them," or that "We could own a huge swath of the region in a few weekends (sic) time...." We have mostly reservists in Iraq, and, with our regular forces in places like South Korea, Germany, etc., we are stretched quite thin. Your statements illustrate quite well why we aren't as popular over the world as you would like to think. It's this arrogant, everybody else be damned attitude, that shows why we all should care.

Posted by: Karl at May 1, 2004 07:45 PM

I meant "weekends time". Our troops could take the week days off and just work on the weekends.

I didn't mean "tinking" though.

Posted by: Who cares at May 1, 2004 11:58 PM

Aside from the completely revolting (in more ways than one) news of these atrocities commited by U.S. (and British) soldiers--who are supposed to STAND FOR SOMETHING BETTER, DAMMIT--most of our country may be finally, hopefully, waking up to the dirty little secret about our military: it's made up of people, just like every other military.

In other words, yes, we have the ability to nuke the planet, but *short* of that, we are NOT invincible. Our troops get hungry, tired, wounded and die just like any other soldier, which means that we CAN be defeated in battle, something which a great number of Americans seem to be in complete denial about. Being the big dog doesn't mean the dog can't be taken down; it just means different strategies, and those who hate us (which just went up tenfold this week) are quickly learning this.

Did we really think we could just decide to invade any nation on the planet we desired, knock out their government (no matter how deserving they were of their fate), set up our own puppet government and not face the consequences? Yeah, we've done it before, but never on such a large scale, never so blatantly, and never with as much ineptitude as this invasion has proven.

Bottom line is that unless we're prepared to wipe out EVERY SINGLE GOVERNMENT that we don't like, we're in big trouble--and we are most certainly NOT prepared for doing so...

...that is, unless we want to nuke the planet, of course.

Most disturbingly, there seem to be some folks who want to do just that.

Posted by: Charles Gaba at May 2, 2004 12:35 AM

That these photo's exist is interesting in itself.

If the American military experience running prisons cannot be relied upon for fair and humane treatment of Iraqi prisoners of war 100 percent of the time, then perhaps we should look to the examples set by Iraqi's themselves for what constitutes fair and humane treatment of prisoners. I'm sure there must be plenty of ex-prisoners from Iraq, Kuwait that "60 Minutes" can dig up for interviews, all anxious to attest to the fair benevolent and treatment they received at the hnds of their Iraqi captors.

I think America should endeavor to treat all the prisoners humanely, whether they're here or abroad, and make corrections as required when they are not. I'd also like to know some examples of prisons that never have these types of problems so they may be emulated.

Posted by: Tracer at May 2, 2004 05:08 PM

I don't condone these pictures or the 'soldiers' actions.

But where was the outcry from the entire world when the contractors bodies were burned then hung from that bridge and beaten to shreds by a mob of Iraquis?

Apparently pictures of those atrocities just don't register or make as good press as these type of pictures do.

Posted by: vic at May 5, 2004 10:26 AM

I was watching today the case of the tortured people in IRAQ and problably nobody notice that the Secretary of State Donald.R.
says he and he's staff reunite with the president twice a week and he never take notes of what thet talg or say well by using or commong sence if he don't no what he talk over there those mind or country is in great"RISK"he don;t remenber nothing well if he is like that can you imaging how can be the rest of people with the same power then hin .
GOD BLESS YOU AMERICA AND THE WHOLE PLANET

Posted by: TITO CAS at May 7, 2004 04:03 PM

When a Navy ship runs aground, the Captain usually faces a court-martial, even if he was asleep in his cabin at the time. This is the principle of responsibility. The rank and file did the deeds, but the chain of command has to take responsibility. In the case of the MPs, at the very least that means responsibility for failures in training and supervision, while for the MI personnel who apparently instigated the mistreatment in the belief that it would somehow aid their interrogation and intelligence-gathering process it propably means a greater degree of responsibility. And interestingly there have been several interviews in both the British and US media from intelligence and interrogation specialists saying emphatically that this kind of 'softening up' is counter-productive.

Posted by: Ken W at May 10, 2004 09:00 AM

PLEEEEASE....do you think is ONLY 6 sickos doing all this abuse?
GEEZ! Some Americans are ISOLATED and brainless.
Of course, is not "Just 6 sickos" the whole darn
CIA and intelligence officers involved .
In war atrocities are not done by just"6" people.
The top guys are commanding the abuses though the "6 sickos" that thus have gotten caught are the ones who going to get all the blame.
they're small ranking soldiers and STUPID human
beings for following such orders.
And don't give me the excuse that they had no idea of the Geneva Convention Laws.
There is ONE law that they knew:
"DO UNTO OTHERS WHAT YOU WOULD HAVE THEM DO UNTO YOU".
Follow that clear and very simple law and you don't need to be an attorney of Geneva conventions laws.

Posted by: Victoria at May 11, 2004 11:49 AM

Every country has the government it deserves.
-- Joseph De Maistre
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 23, 2004 05:32 PM

Fats Loves Madelyn.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 23, 2004 07:54 PM

Twenty of the suckiest minutes of my life.

-- Homer Simpson
Burns, Baby Burns
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 03:54 PM

Never use "etc." -- it makes people think there is more where there is not
or that there is not space to list it all, etc.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 05:44 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne at June 11, 2004 08:30 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits