« Back to paper | Main | Another way to stay connected »

May 10, 2004

Apple's PowerBooks are still too much money

I use my PowerBook a lot more these days and have been really smitten with the new 1.5Ghz 15-inch G4's sold by Apple.
Until, after specing out the one I wanted at my local Apple store, it ended up costing $3,000 with the 1 GB of RAM and SuperDrive that I need.
That is a lot of money.
I love my 867 MHz 12-inch machine but the extra screen real estate and speed on the new models would be much appreciated when I take it on the road and use for presentations.
Nevertheless, I have new PowerBook lust.


in PowerBook | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Apple RAM is alwaya a ripoff. You can purchase aftermarket ram for a fraction of the cost of Apples. for future reference, www.ramseeker.com is a comparison site that lists the ram costs for just about every known ram vendor.

Posted by: Mark at May 10, 2004 07:40 AM

Mark is right, what are you doing buying RAM from Apple?

Posted by: me at May 10, 2004 08:37 AM

Agreed. Apple often uses Micron/Crucial RAM, which can be purchased directly for far less.

Posted by: Dave Nanian at May 10, 2004 08:48 AM

I would disagree-- I used to think Apple's RAM was a ripoff, but I have had so many clients who bought their Macs from resellers and bought third-party RAM then have freezeups and apparent disk problems, only to find out eventually, after wasting many hours of aggravation on freezeups (which otherwise are extremely rare with OS X) and disk utilities, that it's bad RAM. I have read that Apple justifies the cost by doing extra testing of their RAM, and I think my experiences concur. My brother and sister have both also had issues with their new iBook and iMac in the past year which was traced back to a bad memory chip from a third party.

The problematic manufacturer does replace the chip with some hoops to jump through when you call, but you've already gone through hours and hours of troubleshooting to get to that point. And the CD Hardware Test will often not spot bad RAM unless you do extended tests over and over, because the flaws are very minute, but big enough to screw up a complicated OS.

And another benefit-- if you buy your RAM through Apple, it's covered under Applecare. That means if you have trouble so bad you have to send your Mac in for service and they find out it's a bad third-party chip, they might send you the bill for the repair. Not if you bought it from Apple.

So, in short, because I already pay a little more for good Mac hardware from Apple, which gives me peace of mind and an almost trouble-free computing experience at least 12 hours per day, seven days a week, I am also willing to pay a little more for the manufacturer's approved memory. It's not much of a stretch.

But to keep it on topic-- I believe one can see Powerbooks as overpriced compared to low- to middle-end Windows-based machines, but to most users, it's worth every penny for the experience. My Ti-Bk 1Ghz (DVI) I purchased in Jan '03 for $2799 can be had for a lot less money now, (in fact the iBook G4 1Ghz I just bought for my fiancee 2 weeks ago is also 1Ghz and nearly as fast for half the money), but it has served me well and earned its keep. I wish I could say I am easy on a computer, but I am constantly on the go, and this baby is always with me, performing like a pro. When I am not at school teaching computers (Windows XP lab), I am out fixing computers, and by far and away, the Windows machines are much more troublesome per capita. I am going to make a mint this summer fixing Windows virus and spyware problems.

If I had to buy a PC laptop, I'd probably go for a Sony VAIO, which in my experience is higher quality than your average Dell from Hell, but guess what, it costs about the same as Mac.

T

Posted by: ToeKnee at May 10, 2004 09:08 AM

As mentioned above, you get a "quality" PC even an Alienware laptop and they cost thge same as a PBG4.
That's because bit for bit, part for part it's tops all the way.
non the less, if you want Samsung Ram (OEM) OWC sells a 1gig dimm for $359 (exact same ram Apple uses in the PB)
Other than ram, the 1.5/SD PB is complete.
Well, the $50 ATI ipgrade is a good thing, but forget the 5400rpm drive unless video is a primary use for the PB.
Even then the 4500rpm drive is fine.

Posted by: mark at May 10, 2004 09:27 AM

Yep. Top of the line Apple PB's and top of the line Dell laptops cost pretty much the same.

Vaio's too

Posted by: Daniel at May 10, 2004 12:42 PM

I ordered the new 15" PB the morning they were announced and received it the following Monday. I saved $150 buying 1GB RAM from Smalldog and it's been running great, no problems. The screen is wonderful and quickly spoils you if you've been used to the 12" PB.

Total cost with 128MB video memory, faster HD and $100 charge for a 512MB RAM module instead of 2 256MB modules (the only part of this sale that I don't care for) was just over $3000 with tax (and that includes the 1GB RAM module from Smalldog).

Posted by: Larry at May 10, 2004 12:48 PM

I posted on my site the prices that Apple's computers SHOULD be. Check out my table, and compare it to your own way of thinking. Macs are too darned expensive. My revised prices aren't fantasy prices, just what I think they OUGHT to be.
My rule is to get a new computer when processor speeds have quadrupled. So my 450 MHz cube is due for replacing. The Mac G5 does that and more, but it's a tower, and I want another CUBE - silent, elegant, small, fast, powerful.

Posted by: John C at May 10, 2004 04:57 PM

John C:
sorry, you're going to be waiting a long time for a G5 cube. Apple learned its lesson on that one. Other than the fact that they could not sell enough of them to break even, the G5 chiprequires so much cooling, a G5 cube could probably literally be used as a toaster (or to keep your coffee cup hot).

As for your prices, Apple sets its price points to earn profits which will please its investors-- that's what a business is in business to do. In addition, it gives nice discounts to schools and educators, which its prices to the general public supports. While I have no doubt that Apple would sell a lot more Macs if its prices were lower, the strength and profitability of the company is also important.

I personally think Macs are not too expensive; I don't drive the cheapest cars, and I don't live in the cheapest house on the block, and I don't buy the cheapest computers... quality is worth more, especially with something as potentially time-consuming as computers.

I'd love to see them drop the education prices even lower and regain dominance in the education markets-- it's a foot in the door to family purchases and later openness to Apple in the workplace.

T

Posted by: ToeKnee at May 10, 2004 11:42 PM

I priced Alienware laptops one day. I know they are top of the line but I was still shocked to find that their stuff was so much more expensive than Apple's, especially when realizing that Apple no longer has a $3200 laptop, or a $3000 laptop, or even a $2900 laptop. You have to buy the 17" and pump it up to even get to $3000. This is such an improvment over years past when you could not get the PowerBook you wanted without spending well over $3000 (like my old PowerBook G3). I was so pleased when I bought this 15" and the only thing I needed to buy was RAM from Crucial.

Posted by: doug at May 11, 2004 03:30 AM

Nice to see that Apple are not the only ones who delete posts from their forums ... If you are ripping off other websites then you should just come clean and admit it ...

http://www.macmove.com/mt/archives/000072.html

Posted by: Pete at May 11, 2004 09:01 AM

Mike announced some sort of cooperation with MacMove a few weeks ago, but I now cannot find the announcement now. I suspect that is the reason this was cross-posted, but I do not know why different names were used.

T

Posted by: ToeKnee at May 11, 2004 09:53 AM

One way to save a nich chunk of change it to regularly check the Special Deals section on Store.Apple.Com, as well as the refurb listing on smalldog.com

Depending on the model, you can save anywhere from $200-600 if you get one that's refurbished.

I saved a nice chunk of change on my 12" 1ghz PowerBook that way.

Posted by: Mike at May 11, 2004 12:40 PM

Save yourself a bundle and buy a refurb unit from Apple. I did that with my 17" AlumiBook, and I couldn't be happier. Saved several hundred dollars, got the same warranty, and could still get AppleCare for the same price. What's not to like?

Posted by: Rich at May 11, 2004 02:51 PM

Check out this page ... you can find much better deals

http://macreviewzone.com/html/reviews/guides/hardware/2004-powerbook-04.shtml

Posted by: David at May 21, 2004 11:27 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits