« Time Shifting on the Mac | Main | Charging your Cellphone - With your Computer »

March 31, 2004

Hard to find a reason to upgrade my PowerBook

I've been following all the anticipation about the new faster and more powerful Powerbooks that Apple supposedly plans to release this week and find myself stumped.
Try as I might, I can't rationalize an upgrade to my 14-month old 867MHz 12-inch G4.
It's been such a workhorse for me and I can't imagine replacing it. I remember saying at the time that it was the best laptop i ever used. I still say the same today. I tried the 15-inch and 17-inch models but the size and the weight of the 12-incher has me hooked.
Best of all, it's paid for.


in Apple | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Mike,

I would hold off until the G5's come out.. you KNOW you are going to want one of those. Start putting your spare change into the pickle jar now...

Posted by: Omni at March 31, 2004 12:23 PM

Mike,

I agree with you. I bought the 12-incher shortly after you did, and I love mine, too. It does everything I throw at it. My only problem is the size of the hard drive, since I've not gotten into video editing and the files are so big that a 40GB hard drive just isn't big enough.

I have an external firewire 180GB drive, but it's actually bigger than my PowerBook!!!

Posted by: Seth at March 31, 2004 12:56 PM

I wouldn't hold my breath for G5 laptops. They've had enough problems with heat dissapation with the G5-based Xserve units that I think a G5-based PowerBook is still at least a year away.

White a Dual G4 Powerbook isn't impossible, I think they'll use too much battery to be practical at this point.

My bet: We'll see speed-bumped Powerbooks with minor video upgrades. More ram by default would be nice, but Apple has ALWAYS been cheap about that sort of thing for some unknown reason.

I'm guessing we'll see the following..
12" bumped to 1.25ghz (and finally get backlit keys)
15.2" bumped to 1.33 or 1.42ghz
17" bumped to 1.42ghz single and maybe dual 1.25ghz cpu's

Posted by: Mike at March 31, 2004 12:58 PM

Oh, sure. If you have a Power Mac G5, why would you need more than a 12" PB? Espeically if you have a 23" Cinema Display and a 17" Studio Display.

But, for those of us who like to use one computer only and therefore choose a notebook as a desktop replacement, buying a 12" Powerbook is like wearing sandals in Antarctica or snow boots in the Mojave. A 15" PB maxed in every area is the PERFECT tool for the job.

Posted by: Brian at March 31, 2004 01:33 PM

I'd agree with you mike, I almost bought a 12" PB, but went with the 12" ibook for battery runtime considerations, but I don't see anything (even on the rumor mill) that makes me want to buy a new machine. I'll be sticking with the ibook until something much better comes along (hopefully still in the 12"'s form-factor.

And some of us do use the 12" as a full-time machine. While the 15" PB is nice as well, it is not nearly as portable as the 12" for those who do a lot of travelling, the weight & space savings of the 12 are something to be considered.

Posted by: Mark at March 31, 2004 01:51 PM

I've got the lastest revision of the 17" loaded except for RAM.. only have a Gig instead of 2 Gig.

I definitely think that there will be some bumps to the current G4 powerbook lineup before the G5's come out Mike.. and you are right, they are a year off at least. But wont your 12" last you another year?

Posted by: Omni at March 31, 2004 01:54 PM

mike,

but that's also apple's main problem: i have now been using an ibook (dual usb w/ 500mhz!!) for almost 3 years (granted i'm not using it for any processor intensive video editing but it's running all iApps, Office, Keynote, Lotus Notes (sucks but that's not the ibook's fault), etc. etc. And when i will put it away (sooner rather than later) it will still work for two or three more years as my wife's computer (who is currently using a powerbook wallstreet (running 10.2.6) from 1998 (!!!) for surfing, emailing, word docs, simple spreadsheets, chatting etc.).

try that on the wintel platform! i would have had to go through at least two more laptops/desktops to keep using a current OS!!!

my dilemma: if i buy a g4 powerbook now, i'm going to want a g5 when it comes out (at the end of the year or later as i assume...).

Posted by: jw at March 31, 2004 01:56 PM

I do agree. Eventhough I just ordered my 12" Powerbook last week. Doh! Oh well. :)

Posted by: Alvin at March 31, 2004 02:37 PM

I agree with those who defend the 12" PowerBook as a "real" machine. I love mine; it has never balked at anything except Halo, and I didn't really even want to do that... I just wanted to see if it could.

I don't play games very often, and the 12" handles iMovie (except for storage space, as I mentioned above). I want to be clear: I LOVE this machine.

I've gotten more satisfaction out of my 12" PowerBook than any other piece of tech I've ever owned. It's with me - literally - 24 hours/day. I check things with it from bed before I fall asleep, and I open it up before I get out of bed in the morning. My wife may not like it... but I do. :)

Posted by: Seth at March 31, 2004 05:22 PM

I suspect that they are going to shuffle their portable range quite soon. There is currently a special at our university computer store on the 12 inch iBook/G4 800MHz - I bet the updated 12 inch PowerBook will be differentiated enough (faster/more features) that they can bump the small iBook to 933 MHz or 1GHz. There are also deals on the 12 inch and 15 inch Powerbooks.

Posted by: Jon Graves at March 31, 2004 08:37 PM

I have a rev B (1 ghz) 12-inch PB and love it to death. Thing is, it replaced a 12-inch g3 iBook that I loved, too, and had only had for 8 months! Why'd I upgrade so soon, and from a machine I was content with? Well, I realized I could sell the iBook for pretty close to what I paid for it, which wouldn't have been the case a year or so later, especially as upgraded iBooks came out. So I say it actually makes sense to upgrade every few months, while your Mac is still holding so much of its value. Or just wait 3 years or so and get a really significant upgrade. (I don't have the discipline for that!)

Posted by: scott at March 31, 2004 09:08 PM

You will be run over by a beer truck.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 23, 2004 05:59 PM

Cheit's Lament:
If you help a friend in need, he is sure to remember you--
the next time he's in need.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 06:58 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne at June 12, 2004 11:36 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits