« Additional authors | Main | Hard to find a reason to upgrade my PowerBook »

March 31, 2004

Time Shifting on the Mac

I love my ReplayTV.
It's totally changed the way my family watches television. I bought it at Best Buy as an off-the-shelf, open-box special, and it's awesome. If you're unfamiliar with the concept, ReplayTV (as well as Tivo and the DVR your cable provider offers), provides a service known as Time Shifting, which is, in the simplest terms, the ability to record a TV show and watch it at another time.
Of course, people have been doing that with their VCR's forever. But Digital Video Recorders make it easier than ever. And now (to finally get to the point of this post!), your Mac makes it easy to time shift all sorts of content, including radio, streaming audio and a surprise you won't believe!

Video

You may have already heard of the EyeTV from elgato Systems, which is the closest thing you can get to a Tivo on your Mac (or Windows Home Media Edition, for that matter). The product includes a USB box that you connect your TV signal to and some software that lives on your Mac. It knows what's on and records your shows to your Mac. There are some drawbacks, but it's an essentially good product; there's a nice review here. There are different flavors of this product and they cost somewhere around $200 and go up from there.

Radio

Another option is the radioSHARK, which is a neat toy from Griffin Technologies. It's a shark-fin-shaped AM/FM radio that attaches to your computer so you can record radio. It also comes with software that allows you to schedule recordings and save them, archive them, put them on an iPod, etc. It retails for around $70.

Streaming Audio

A common question asked on tech support message boards concerns recording streaming audio from the web. Everyone knows that you can listen to Car Talk, Your Mac Life, and other radio shows via the web. Or maybe your local station plays things worth recording. The problem is that most streaming audio – which you listen to in Quicktime or Windows Media Player or Real Player – can't be saved to your hard drive... or can it?

The high school I teach at recently played in a nation basketball tournament and the games were broadcast live via the net. I searched a little and eventually recorded the broadcasts using the excellent shareware application, Audio Hijack, which allows you to, "quickly and easily save audio from almost any application to an AIFF file."

It's a cool piece of software. Not only can you record things, but the Pro version lets you modify the audio quality in real time. Also, you can set recordings up in advance, just like using a VCR. It's very cool... and reasonably priced at $16, or $30 for the more powerful Pro Version.

Comic Strips

Yup. Comic strips.

I have to thank the inimitable Andy Ihnatko for pointing out Comictastic. It's a simple little application that fetches comic strips from the internet for you. It downloads them on a schedule you set and saves them, by strip, in order. The complexities of the business-side of comics keeps the developer from including pre-created links to most well-known strips, but the app is powerful enough to find just about any comic strip that is published online. Basically, if you can read the comic in a web browser, Comicatastic can find it for you and download it.

It costs only $15 and it's worth it, especially if you don't yet know about the UF Gang.

So, there you have it: enough software to time shift yourself back into Middle Earth. Shift responsibly!


in Apple | TrackBack (0)

Comments

What are the advantages of this vs. TiVO

can you burn episodes of say Sopranos to a DVD for storage

can this connect to a Airport?

Posted by: Jan Prusinowski at March 31, 2004 08:13 AM

ReplayTV is probably the best component in our home theatre. My wife hates most everything electronic, except for her iBook and now the Replay.

Replay is far superior to TiVo which manages to get much more positive press. Replay had a lot of financial problems when owned by SonicBlue, about a year ago now they were sold to the company that owns Denon (and Marantz?) -- this new holding company seems to have the cash flow to support this product, and has resolved all litigation against the Replay unit with little loss of service to end users.

There are also utilities for Windows and Mac's to pull your Replay movies and burn to DVD. You will need to record at medium quality or higher, and do some compression - but a fairly easy task.

jra

Posted by: jra at March 31, 2004 09:21 AM

Funny you should write this now Seth. Last week I was at Novell's Brainshare conference in Salt Lake City where I won a 15G iPod from a vendor contest. They were gracious enough to give me the gift recipt from Best Buy so I could return it ( as I already have 2 iPods ). My intention was to take the cash and purchase the brand new elGato EyeTV200 ( $350 ). My wife and I both have Mac Portables and wanted to be able to watch the video on the go.

Best Buy refused to give me cash back, only an in-store credit ( go figure ). I went back and looked around the computer section and decided to give the ATI Radeon9600XT All-In-Wonder a try. I'm running it on an Athlon 2500+ with a gig of RAM, 120G HDD, and Windows XP Pro. I've had it for a few days, and the card works about 95%. The application that runs the remote control crashes periodically, and the menu system doesnt seem to work like it should ( up is down on the control sometimes, things can't always be easily deleted, etc ). The recordings work well, files can be recorded in Mpeg 1, 2, or 4 format depending on the desired final quality.

I havent been thrilled with the unit ( usability issues primarily ), and have 30 days to return it. I was considering getting a ReplayTV but Best Buy seems to only carry Tivo.. I'd really like the ElGato unit.. but i don't see that happening right now...

Posted by: Omni at March 31, 2004 10:22 AM

What about Alchemy TV from Miglia. I would love to read a review of this product, which supports the G5 towers.

http://www.miglia.com/products/index.html

Posted by: ctolgc at March 31, 2004 10:38 AM

Other than not being able to easily move files to my laptop, I can't see how anything is better than my combined, DirectTV/Tivo box with dual tuners. It's perfect, the TiVo software is great, the customer service was great the one time I had to use it. Being able to watch something from disk and record two live shows all at once is amazing. If I has more spare time, I would investigate the hacks to get the box onto my wireless network so I could grab files from it to watch on my Macs, but I just haven't taken the time.

I have friends that have made that work, but its a lot of Linux hacking, and a hassle to restore when new software is pushed down via the satellite.

Posted by: JackR at March 31, 2004 11:09 AM

I don't know much about Replay TV. Do you have to connect it to a phone line like TiVo? For some reason, doing that doesn't appeal to me--maybe it seems too Big-Brotherish or something. The Mac-based system sounds good, but I'd really prefer a stand-alone unit. Anything out there that doesn't require the phone hookup?

Posted by: Joe at March 31, 2004 11:48 AM

Omni,
Am I to understand you've actually touched and played around with the new EyeTV 200? I'm considering getting one (trying to decide if I can swing it/what would the fiancee say), but I'm a bit weary of the utter lack of reviews (Macworld had a little blurb about it following MacWorld '04, but that's all I've seen) in addition to the seemingly long lead times (30+ days from El Gato's site). Any information you have would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks.

Posted by: Matt at March 31, 2004 12:08 PM

Matt,

I've not actually touched it. I' have read the Macworld review and one other ( can't remember where off the top of my head ). ElGato does offer money back guarantees though, so I figured I had nothing to lose.

Their older model was reviewed well except for the size of video captured. That was due to its USB interface. With the firewire interface, that problem should go away. The full screen Quicktime capture with MPEG-4 compression sounds very appealing to me.

I'll post if I find out any more information....

Posted by: Omni at March 31, 2004 12:22 PM

Omni,

Well, I found a few user reviews for the new EyeTV units here: http://www.xlr8yourmac.com/feedback/eye_tv_review.html and things don't look good. Seems a lot of people are having problems (software seems a bit unstable, among other things). The good news is El Gato is actively working to try to fix the problems.

Matt

Posted by: Matt at March 31, 2004 12:58 PM

Nothing (IMO) beats the combo of a ReplayTV and a Mac (Or Wintel) machine running DVArchive - http://www.DVArchive.org/.

My G4 desktop now holds 600+ Hours of Video, video that I can access from any of the systems in the house locally, or copy to my 5Gb firewire drive that I carry in my pocket or my 20GB ipod or any of our laptops, or simply watch it from the ReplayTV in the living room.

You do have to have a phone or network connection (Wireless or wired) but man, is it worth it. Especially since the Replay automatically skips over commercials, if you have an older unit (which I do). And ReplayTV does not have anything like the ads that Tivo pushes out, so it feels at least, a little less "Big Brother"-ish.

The extra-nice thing about the Replay and DVArchive is that DVArchive will automate much of the tasks you'd want to do, copying files from the ReplayTV to your Mac at night when you're not using it, and then clearing up space on your ReplayTV for more shows. Running out of space? Plug in another firewire drive on your Mac and keep going!

When you want to watch something out of your archive of shows, it's waiting there on your Mac, available to the ReplayTV, at the flick of a button.

Like one of the earlier posters, the ReplayTV is one of the few components that my wife likes. Kudos for mentioning this great unit!

Posted by: W. Ian Blanton at March 31, 2004 08:58 PM

Wiretap is a free tool for recording streaming audio. It can evern be scripted. A gift from ambrosiasw.com .

Posted by: George Papanicolaou at April 1, 2004 01:03 AM

Wiretap can be scripted. So can RealAudio and iCal, and a guy named Christian Turner brought them all together in an app called Streamers: http://homepage.mac.com/christianturner/

I've been using this to make archives of This American Life, since I'd rather hear them on my iPod than at my desk. I just feed a series of URL's for the .ra files into Streamers and hit Record Now before I go to bed, and in the morning, there's a group of new recordings in iTunes, they only need the ID3 tags tweaked to identify them properly.

It's not the most polished app, but it's a great demo of what AppleScript Studio can do.

As for video, I'm very pleased with my Toshiba DVD player/Tivo combo, for 2 reasons: 1- I'm not willing to pay a monthly fee for programming, so I use it more like a digital VCR. That's fine with me, I only record 8 shows/week, and probably watch 5. 2)- I now have 1 remote to control live TV, recorded TV and DVDs. I love that simplicity, and don't miss a basket of remotes.

Posted by: Steve Y at April 1, 2004 10:35 AM

Mitchell's Law of Committees:
Any simple problem can be made insoluble if enough meetings are
held to discuss it.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 23, 2004 06:02 PM

Anyone can make an omelet with eggs. The trick is to make one with none.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 23, 2004 07:38 PM

Microsoft ActivePromo Campaign: "Windows Competitive Upgrade Offer"

Microsoft's PR masterminds are planning a massive marketing campaign,
code-named "ActivePromo 2000", to promote the upcoming release of Windows
2000 (scheduled for February 2001). This marketing campaign will include a
"Windows Competitive Upgrade Offer" promotion.

Users of non-Microsoft operating systems (Linux in particular) will be given
the opportunity to trade-in their present OS for a free copy of Windows 98
(or NT 4.0) and Office 97. People (all three of them) who want to
participate in this program will have to:

1. Mail their operating system's floppy disks or CD-ROMs to Microsoft

2. Agree to a two year contract with the Microsoft Network.

3. Agree (in writing) to the Competitive Upgrade License Agreement; one of
the terms of which is that the user may not install, copy, or otherwise use
a non-Microsoft OS for five years.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 05:41 PM

The sooner you make your first 5000 mistakes, the sooner you will be
able to correct them.
-- Nicolaides
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 07:47 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne nokia at June 11, 2004 08:29 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits