
I can't wait until ebay successfully bans creeps like those that
use these programs against other people just trying to have some fun and
enjoyment on ebay. There are many people who sell on ebay who dislike
these people.
As far as his success rate, if I factor out the auctions I
missed because I wasn't there at the end to up my bid (I like to bid
low...no point getting carried away), my success rate is more like
80-90% or better. topping the last bid by 50 cents or a dollar sometimes
isn't worth it. You have postage and/or shipping & handling to pay also,
and many of the sellers over charge for that. So you might have great
success with one of these sniping programs, but you'll end up paying
more than the item is worth or could be had from some other source...so
this guy's business isn't as great as he thinks. I guess there's a lot
of people with money to blow, and a few extra dollars for his service is
no big deal. Their loss, I guess.
This question comes up in my classes all the time. The point is to study an auction and all costs, evaluate how much you're willing to pay without kicking yourself later for overpaying (or not paying enough and losing it), then place your proxy bid and walk away. If somebody wants to play the game of bidding at the last minute, let them have their fun... if you have a good proxy bid in, you have the last laugh!
Posted by: Donna Klein at November 26, 2003 10:12 PMHmm, this service is completely worthless, why would anyone use it? I definitely can't believe anyone would pay for this. Do people not understand how proxy bidding works? You enter the most you are willing to pay, and it bids the item up ultil the limit is reached. If you don't really know how much you're willing to pay for something, you should ask yourself why you are bidding on it at all. And if you just, gotta have that porcelein hummel or whatever, just enter a ridiculously high proxy bid and hope no one bids it up too high. The proxy bidder will outbid any 'sniper' if you enter a high enough bid. I guess I might see some minor value in bidding on multiple identical auctions, but not much.
Nice blog Mike, Freep rules!
Posted by: Doug Santos at November 27, 2003 12:23 AMDonna -
You've hit the nail on the head. For the vast majority of auctions, bidders do NOT understand how proxy bidding works. This is why last minute bidding continues to be so effective.
Last minute bidding is especially effective in dutch auctions where there *is* no proxy bidding. All bids are disclosed throughout the auction and it is easy to knock bidders out of the winning zone with a last minute bid (and no recourse).
A large number of bidders at eBay are novices. Without regard to whether or not they understand "proxy bidding," they still get emotional about the items for which they place bids. The earlier you place your proxy bid, the more likely some other novice bidder will start chipping away at your high bid - causing you to pay more than you needed to for your auction item. Last minute bidding will place you in a battle with ONLY the current high bidder's proxy bid and other last minute bidders. It removes the ability for other bidders to spend 5, 7 or 10 days shooting at your high bid.
I encourage you to just try last minute bidding a few times. You don't have to pay for a service since you can do it with a browser and a wristwatch. See how it affects the dynamics with the other bidders. I think you'll be convinced can help you win more auctions and pay less for the items you win.
Posted by: Chuck Eglinton at November 29, 2003 07:33 AMI really loved buying on eBay, but recently I have decided that many items just aren't bargains--not after shipping (often ridiculously high) is included. Proxy bidding doesn't bother me at all, but I absolutely abhore the whole idea of using sniping software or a sniping service. I emailed eBay several times to ask for a response to my question: WHY does eBay allow bidders to snipe? (And I made it clear that I had no problem with their own eBay "maximum bid" proxy system.) Three times my only response from them was a standard email explaining proxy bidding. Forbes magazine recently had an article about such bidding, in which they said that eBay's corporate response to sniping was that, basically, they wanted to stay out of it; if people wanted to use it--fine. Ebay is losing me as a customer as a result of my disagreement with their stand on sniping, but I am sure it makes no difference to them. They are making millions and millions of dollars by allowing snipers to outbid legitimate bidders at the last second. Their unwillingness to address this issue, and their refusal to take a stand, really shouldn't surprise me... we all know that in today's society, making money is ALL that counts.
Posted by: Dawn McElroy at December 16, 2003 01:37 PMHi, I work for the sniping service http://www.snipeswipe.com . While proxy bidding sounds good in theory, it actually does not work with ebay. Our users save millions of dollars and don't have to worry about sitting by a computer all day till the auction closes.
Snipe Swipe is absoultely free to try, with no required sign up process.
Posted by: Snipe Swipe Ebay Sniper at December 24, 2003 10:04 AM
I'm always amazed at the number of people who will wait until the last minute to bid on something that has been up for bid from 3 to 9 days. I've seen items sell for more used, then what they would cost new, because people get into a bidding war during the last couple of hours. I determine what the item is worth to me, how bad do I want it, how rare it is, and then place my best bid and surf away. If I win, I get what I wanted. If someone out-bids me at the last minute, it's because I didn't want to spend that much for the item. Not because I waited until the last minute to bid.
Posted by: Frederick Kincaid at November 24, 2003 10:20 AM