
As for the Applecare upsell, I am glad I took the bait. Most people just think about using Applecare when hardware goes wrong. I have never had anything go wrong with my iBook but boy have I used Applecare. I call for ANY reason/question/et al I may have about my computer. I figure I paid all that money and it falls into the guidelines...so why not call with questions about how to do something. Applecare is great for people like me who are new to Macs. It can even help people who just don't want to screw something up by guessing what to do.
Posted by: diego at November 23, 2003 05:45 PMApplecare is a given, as far as I am concerned, on portables, because they have to endure so much more abuse - Applecare on my Powerbook 3400 was never used in three years, but I had to send my PB G3 in *five times* for the same issue before it was fixed, and Applecare pays for overnight there and back on Powerbooks, so some repairs were completed in three days (only to be needed again within a few months).
If they're not busy and fully staffed, I am sure Apple Store folks would install your memory for you-- but there is probably a policy about it. After all, it's not just a matter of opening the computer-- it's first unpacking the computer, opening the computer, installing the memory, and then repacking the computer (and really, I'd want to boot it to ensure proper installation before leaving with it)-- that all takes time away from helping other customers-- so I don't fault Apple too much.
In addition, Apple has taken a lot of criticism from its dealers since starting to open Apple stores, so if they can have a policy which favors the dealers, I am sure that takes some of the heat off of them. As long as you buy the Mac from someone, they win. Apple Stores are primarily marketing tools anyway, not intended to be major retail traffic outlets, as is evidenced by their layout and relative sparse peripheral selections. They'd rather have more room to move around up front than warehouse space in the back to stock systems.
On the other subject, a little known fact about Applecare is that you can buy it up to one year after computer purchase-- no need to shell out before necessary-- I never do-- just don't forget... one year and one day is too late.
And a question, Mike: what did you do about the financing? You didn't get six months, but 90 days. Did you apply for a second account?
T
Posted by: Toeknee at November 23, 2003 05:48 PMWell, for $60 on a machine worth $4000, to have peace of mind (they make sure it works before I leave) that I can walk right back in there and hand it back to them. That is not a problem. I enjoy my Applecare. I can call them 8am-8pm (central) 7 days per week with any problems I might have. I have in the past only gotten an extended on my laptop. This time I got it on the G5. I think it was a sound decision. All-in-all Applecare is good.
Posted by: KC at November 23, 2003 06:03 PMWouldn't be amazing if a company like Apple just included their extended warranty from the beginning?
Posted by: KF at November 23, 2003 06:12 PMI have been lucky and not had to use my Applecare yet on my PB but I have worked in an evnrionment where we used applecare almost once a week, and because I have seen how sound the service is, Im probably going to get it on my 2 month old iPod. I know people who have had their problems, and I personally believe that the $249 is well worth it.
Posted by: Jordan at November 23, 2003 06:14 PM"Wouldn't be amazing if a company like Apple just included their extended warranty from the beginning?"
Apple did something very similar before Steve Jobs came back, and it was burning right through Apple's funds. It was one of the things that felt the knife.
Posted by: cgriego at November 23, 2003 08:19 PMC'mon, Mike...
I'm willing to pay for good service... and the Apple stores have given me some of the best service around.
Cough up the $60 secure in the knowledge that if something goes wrong with the G5, one of the Mac Geniuses will dedicate a goodly chunk of time to get to the bottom of the problem.
Posted by: Steve Chamraz at November 23, 2003 08:23 PMYou're right on here. It takes a complete idiot salsperson to qualbble about $60 for memory when he in fact could have snapped it in himself. Hopefully after your article, he will either improve at this job or find better luck at a job that requires that he ask if fries are to be included with the meal. We're talking total idiot here.
Posted by: supportTEX at November 23, 2003 09:36 PMAs an Apple Employee who works in sales and service in one of Apple's retail stores, I have a few things to clue you folks into: Our Apple Care numbers are tracked more closely than even our CPU sales, and it's important, as employees, that we sell it. There is, in fact, product in the back that we need to sell to make our company profit, and every little bit helps. If it were a product, which it is, that was included in the price of the machines, the price of the machines would go up (rather like an acceptable failure rate on LCD screens keeps prices on them relatively low) and would hurt Apple's bottom line, my job, and the company that I love so much. That being said, I own four Macs and have Apple Care on all of them, and now own it on my two iPods. Apple does make incredible gear, and I've never once needed a repair, but as someone who checks machines in for unbelievably expensive repairs day in and day out, I'll be damned if I'm going to pay up to $1000 dollars for a repair that could have been free if I'd just gotten the warranty. Also, most Mac Specialists (those kids out on the sales floor) are not allowed to set foot in the room where RAM is installed and machines are repaired, let alone pop it into a $3000 box, now matter how qualified that specialist may be. Also, the $60 is what we charge and it's totally something you could do yourself, but it's something we "throw in" with the purchase of Apple Care. As far as "quibling" about it, I'd no sooner give a free install for no reason than I'd let you walk out the door with $60 worth of merchandise you hadn't paid for.
By the way, were you purchasing an LCD display? Your not purchasing Apple Care at the time of purchase in order to cover your LCD is a really foolish idea, akin to purcasing a used car at a dealership without a warranty, and then driving that car without insurance. Just get it. We'll all be glad you did.
Posted by: anonymous at November 24, 2003 01:35 AMBy the way, unknown.com is not my url. My website validates ;)
Posted by: anonymous at November 24, 2003 01:41 AMMike:
There's no way I'd pay anyone 60 bucks to pop in some RAM chips (heck, the G5's have the instructions printed on the case, for cryin' out loud), but I disagree with you on the value of AppleCare. I've had two graphite AirPort base stations that were out of warranty--replaced for free under AppleCare when they inexplicably failed. In addition, the tech support you get with an AppleCare agreement is worth its weight in gold. Initally, I hemmed and hawed before ponying up the bucks, but it's worth every penny. As others have pointed out, it's not just for hardware problems.
As an aside, I see that AppleCare is now available for iPods, but for the same price as Apple's two-year agreement, I was able to purchase a three-year extended warranty when I bought mine at Circuit City. When my batter fails (and it *will fail* in that three-year period; you can bet on it), I'll get a nice shiny new one. Mmmmm.
Posted by: Rich at November 24, 2003 09:06 AMI served as a moslty Mac geek several times in my life and I can tell you that - prior to Aple moving all manufacturing offshore (Taiwan) it was a complete waste of money to purchase an extended warranty - Macs never failed.
The later Macs however are often shipped in a failed mode sometimes without a proper software installation and sometimes with hardware problems. My current flat screen Imac (now headed for 2 years old) was shipped without a proper software install and had amotherboard fail within a week. I had similar troubles with sa number of machines under my support over the past several years. Quality control is siply not the same priority since Apple sent productions offshore and outsourced manufacturing (as far as I know wnayway).
So - I have extended warranty on my Imac and my next machine will also have it - a necessary eveil - unfortunately in this day and age of Apple.
BTW - i love my iMac and i LOVE 10.3
Posted by: Dennis Grittner at November 24, 2003 09:56 AMMike, I have to agree that I HATE paying for memory installations on Macs that I could EASILY do it myself. I got a Dual G5 from my employer and we ordered the RAM on the same invoice. The G5 arrived a week before the RAM. However, when the RAM arrived, it was in and working within 3 minutes. Most of that 3 minutes was just being very careful not put the RAM in at an angle. It's very easy to install RAM, AirPort cards and Hard Drives in a G5. Don't pay extra for this. I also installed a 250GB SATA drive with no problems whatsoever. My G5 is humming along.
As far as AppleCare is concerned, I have never bought AppleCare for a desktop Mac. The only reason why, is that they are SO REALIABLE and my experience has been that if something goes wrong it does so within the first year. HOWEVER, if it's a portable, AppleCare is a MUST HAVE! AppleCare on portables also covers the AirPort Base Station and the LCD displays connected to them. My various AppleCare agreements on PowerBooks and iBooks have more than paid for themselves. When I buy a portable Mac, AppleCare is an automatic thing. I don't even think about it.
Posted by: Terry White at November 24, 2003 09:58 AMI bought my wife's 12" PowerBook at CompUSA and the salesman practically pleaded with me to get the AppleCare warranty. When I balked, he said it would cost me $200 to bring the thing back in for repair, even during the first year, which I know is incorrect. You have anytime within the first year to buy AppleCare. Maybe you decided a couple months down the road (after seeing if the machine might be a lemon), before you decide. Your choice. I've done that with my last couple purchases and it has worked out great for me.
Posted by: Howard Wright at November 24, 2003 10:30 AMI had the same experience a week ago. I bought a new 12 inch ibook and a wireless card. They wouldn't install it unless I bought the extended warranty. I installed it myself, no problem.
I've never bought an extended warranty in my life. I've saved thousands of dollars by not buying them. So if something does go wrong, I'm still WAY ahead of the game.
Posted by: mike at November 24, 2003 10:36 AMI for one will buy the Applecare, my original Dual 800 kept blowing firewire ports and it did it 3 times in a year so I asked them to replace the whole thing, instead of just the mobo. They agreed and got me a dual 1 Gig. That peace of mind for the 3 years that Applecare covers my problems is worht every bit of $250. Besides if you have never inquired about mac parts, they are EXPENSIVE.
Posted by: Irv at November 24, 2003 10:49 AMHmmm. Is AppleCare transferrable is you sell the machine during your coverage? That seems like a pretty strong selling point.
Posted by: Mike Wendland at November 24, 2003 11:03 AMIf you know unix, then you don't need applecare - at worst, you can look inside and rip out what has stopped working but unless you live a few minutes from an Apple store, Applecare is worthy insurance that you can pick up the phone and get an answer - and not hope hat someone knows the answer at Apple Discussion forums.
Hardware problems are easier to resolve if you're familair with the mac (as you obviously are) but the software is pretty tricky these days. Plus, it's kind of hard to lug in a desktop.
I woke up one day and was locked out of OSX - OS9 worked okay but not OSX - only a call to Applecare resolved it - had to admin my way back into my mac by re-setting it completely.
Posted by: jbelkin at November 24, 2003 11:10 AMBe smart. Wait until your first year of warranty is almost through, then buy Applecare. That way you get four years of protection for the price of three. They'll try to talk you out of doing it, but you can see why.
Posted by: Hurrt Brammer at November 24, 2003 11:15 AMHurrt is incorrect. If you add Applecare at the end of the first year, your coverage is extended for an additional two years, not three. The total coverage of the warranty is three years from date of hardware purchase, regardless of when Applecare was purchased.
Posted by: Matt at November 24, 2003 11:19 AMsupportTex said Apple tracks AppleCare, well its true. To maintain your Apple reseller status, and get co-op advertising, and a 1% kickback on your sales for the year, AppleCare must have a 40% attach rate on new outgoing products. Apple dealers were never burdened with this in the past, and now it is a requirement to sell the products.
That said, Apple care is great. No hassle to get service, and even 1 repair will cover the cost. Be aware, that AppleCare isn't an insurance policy. If you crack your LCD, that isn't failure or narmal wear and tear, its abuse, and isn't covered.
Anyway Mike, get AppleCare, but buy your RAM third party and install it your self. You'll get more ram for the money, maybe even be able to get 1.5 gig.
One last aside on RAM, if you buy Apple Ram (from the online store, and I would assume from the brick and mortar as well) it is an Apple product. Its more expensive, and only covered against failure for the term of your warranty. 1 year normal, 3 year AppleCare. Buy additional third party ram, its less expensive and has a lifetime warranty.
(aw crap, sorry for the long post) same with hard drives, if you want a second drive, buy at Costco or Sams, or even a sale at CompUSA, its cheaper per gig, and the manufacture warranty is better than on an Apple drive purchased at an Apple store
Posted by: darknite at November 24, 2003 11:21 AMIt's amusing to me that someone who calls himself 'MacMike' as well as 'PCMike' cannot even install RAM on a machine that's one of the easiest in which to install RAM.
Poser.
Posted by: Bongo at November 24, 2003 11:44 AMDuhhh... Bongo... can't you read? I said I know it was easy. That wasn't the point.
Posted by: Mike Wendland at November 24, 2003 11:47 AMMike, you might be interested to know that Apple Retail employees are NOT commissioned. Further, there are no "spiffs" (or per-item bonuses) available. Sales are certainly tracked, and there are important goals for various metrics, but none of it is backed up with a concrete compensation structure. So when the Mac Specialist "refused" to throw in free installs, it wasn't because he was trying to drive a hard bargain or preserve his commission. He was simply following his store's policy. Free installations is one of the perks customers get for buying AppleCare at an Apple Store (this is not something you necessarily get at resellers).
Also, regarding a couple other comments: a $30 install at an Apple Store gets you professional installation, a run through the extended Apple Hardware Test, and documentation of the install in Apple's tracking system so there's never any question that you fried your motherboard while trying to install new hardware. :-)
Posted by: anonymous Apple Retail employee at November 24, 2003 12:05 PMHey Mike,
if you plan on purchasing a monitor at the same time, get the Apple Care when you buy. It will cover both the G5 and the Monitor... this deal is only valid if the monitor appears on the same invoice. Will save you from having to get AppleCare twice.
"No problem! Don't worry about it!" Those are the two most common statements our sales staff use when they are checking out customers. Being in the gift industry with the economy the way it is, we must make extra concessions and give little freebies to keep customers happy and coming back. People come into our store and spend a hundred dollars, we make sure that they get a free designer bag, gift wrapping, gift cards, and an additional free gift just for them. If someone wanted to spend $4,000 in our store all at once, wow, we'd probably just tell them to pick a shelf of merchandise free or something! LOL. Seriously though, we have given away items with a $60 value for purchases of less than $200. Of course, we didn't pay $60 for the item, but we did pay something. In your situation we are talking about a few minutes worth of time from an employee who can't be making more than $20/hour. I don't think it's out of line to expect that service for a $4,000 purchase.
Posted by: LD at November 24, 2003 01:39 PMI haven't seen anyone make the comment yet that AppleCare is only an extended warranty which will cover things that break because of Apple's design flaws or component failures. If your machine get zapped because of a lightning strike, or flys off the roof of your car, because you left it there, you're NOT COVERED. Keep that in mind. It's well worth it, but just be aware of what they will cover, and NOT cover.
Posted by: Brian at November 24, 2003 03:15 PMI don't believe anyone answered your question about whether applecare can move machines if you sell it.
The answer I have gotten from both the store and from applecare phone support is No, applecare cannot move from computer to computer. It is assigned to that one machine not the owner. So, if I sell my ibook and buy a new one, applecare is not going to move to the new one. I would have to buy applecare for the new ibook.
Posted by: diego at November 24, 2003 03:39 PMBrian, Darknite did mention that, though I am not surprised you missed it in this long thread, and it bears repeating.
Darknite-
I was not aware that Apple dealers are required to average 40% Applecare sales. Are they allowed to discount it like online retailers? I have always purchased (and recommended to friends and clients) my Applecare enrollments kits online. Today I found one for my Powerbook for $262 vs $349 at the Apple Store.
If the brick and mortar dealers are not allowed to sweeten the pot by discounting Applecare, they are at a tremendous disadvantage - even if they need to blow them out at or below cost for a week to get their averages in line.
More info on this would be good, especially from some of the Apple employee lurkers.
T
Posted by: Toeknee at November 24, 2003 03:39 PMDiego,
The 40% rate I mentioned wasn't a profit margin that goes with the contract, it was a percentage that dealers needed to sell. If an Apple specialist sells 100 computers, 40 of them need to be sold with AppleCare. The specialist I used to work for gave a 10% discount if AppleCare was purchased at the same time as the computer. If they came back later, or did the 1 week before the warranty expired stratagy, it was full price.
I was slightly misinformed about the 40%, to be an Apple Specialist, you need to have a minimum 30% AppleCare attach rate. (The rate seems to raise by a few percent every year) But make no mistake, if you go 2 years in a row without hitting the goal, you lose the Specialist designation. (the first year puts you on probation)
Selling 40% of the computers with AppleCare will qualify dealers for a 1-1.5% kickback of their total yearly sales, plus the ability to have ads co-payed by Apple.
(BS alert, my info is a few months old, the requirements to be a specialist or any other type of Apple reseller changed 6 weeks ago, so the 30% may be a little low, and new restrictions on advertising co-op and dealer percentage kickback may have changed) If any current dealers/ employees could offer a clearer picture, I would like to know as well.
Posted by: darknite at November 24, 2003 04:52 PMBongo was right that you should install your own memory. No one who writes about Macintoshes should ever forego the opportunity to do so. It's the best way to find out how easy and simple installing memory on a G5 is. Furthermore, at $60 for what is literally a two minute job (I know because I've installed memory on my two G5s) that translate to an hourly rate of $1800 per hour, a ridiculous fee. Even for five minutes (for first timers) that's $720 per hour. And please, only if the memory is really bad will the G5 hardware diagnostic find the bad memory right after installation. Bad memory often takes a while to show itself, in strange crashes and kernel panics. Indeed, often you have no idea the memory is bad until you take it out and the problems disappear. But GROUND YOURSELF first.
I just checked OWC (www.mac-sales.com) and they don't sell 256MB DIMMs for G5s (you need to install the DIMMs in pairs, so 2 X 256MB will bring you up to your 1 GB total). OWC sells 512 MB DIMMs with lifetime warranty for about $100. Two of them and an Airport card is $300. Total cost for a dual 2.0 GHz with 1.5 GB memory is therefore $3300. With a 6% sales and use tax (Michigan) that's a $3500 purchase.
Lastly, I didn't appreciate the hard sales pitch from the Apple employee. AppleCare is a product, an extended warranty, and Apple undoubtedly (as with most extended warranties) makes a huge profit from AppleCare. That profit comes from people who don't use the warranty after purchasing it. Right off the bat, that tells you that the probability is that you will not need as much service the two years after your regular warranty as you would be paying in AppleCare. If you are unsure of yourself on a Mac, perhaps the free telephone service would be worthwhile. If you are a klutzy sort of person who drops laptops (not covered, but most people lie), then AppleCare might be worthwhile. If you worry about things like this, then AppleCare might be worthwhile. Otherwise, for most people, it is just throwing money away. Probabilistically.
Posted by: Bob Collins at November 24, 2003 06:07 PMseems as if someone wanted to be pampered and made to believe they're the highlight of the day.
Posted by: greye at November 24, 2003 06:23 PMGreye get a life. Mike shares something that has drawn a lot of interesting comment and like some immature little 1st grader you come and start name-calling. Mike, I'm sorry that idiots like Greye live and breathe. I appreciate the interesting dialogue you started and I think you have some valid points... as, obviously, most of the people posting here do also. Don't pay attention to Greye's mean-spirited sarcasm.
By the way, DID you go back today? Are you getting the G5?
I don't think anyone answered the question about Applecare transfers...
From AppleCare Protection Plan Terms and Conditions
www.apple.com/education/products/pdf/TsCsfinal2001.pdf
---
Transfer of Plan
You may transfer this Plan to a new owner of the Covered Equipment. If you purchased the Plan in the U.S. or Canada, transfer by sending written notice to AppleCare Administration, P.O. Box 149125, Austin, TX 78714-9125, U.S. You must provide the Plan’s enrollment or agreement number, the serial numbers of the Covered Equipment being transferred, proof of purchase of the Plan, and the name and address of the new owner.
---
T
Posted by: Toeknee at November 24, 2003 07:02 PMI would do it myself even if it was free. It is 5 minutes to plug that stuff in yourself vs. waiting for at least an hour for them to open your box, take everything out to get to your machine, plug the pieces in put everything back in neat and tidy in the box tape it up, then they will verify that it works. plus they are not going to jump right to it, like you said they were swamped. you could be home online with everything installed by yourself before you would even leave the apple store if they installed it.
Posted by: Lou at November 24, 2003 07:36 PMWell?????? Did you go back and get one??? Fess uip Mike. We're waiting!!!!!
Posted by: Bobby T at November 24, 2003 10:17 PMWere you buying the RAM from the store? If you were, then the store should have put it in for free just because the price is SO much higher than anywhere else. And since the box would be open for that procedure they could have put in the Airport card as well.
Applecare is a joke. First they mislead most people into thinking it is an ADDITIONAL 3 years when it really is an additional 2 years. Use a credit card that doubles the warranty so you can add an additional year. Second if Dell can offer longer warranties why can't Apple? Jobs needs to improve on the Wintel box model by doing the following, 1 year Apple OS support, Windows is 90 days and 3 years on the boxes. While I'm at it, Apple get on the ball. Build in the damn Airport and Bluetooth already. Or aren't you seeing those Centrino ads? And put appropriate amounts of starter RAM in ALL your boxes.
--
Shaun, aka "Glad I waited on the 1.8 G5 Purchase"
Always knew Dennis was smart
Posted by: Addie at January 24, 2004 08:52 PM
Hmmm...
Mike, I'm with you up on the "The Customer is Always Right" High Horse, but I'm not sure I understand. On the new G5 Tower, installing an AE card and RAM is - literally - as easy as snapping LEGO's together. From what you've written about in the past, I'm *certain* you could do it; In fact, I'm surprised that you haven't.
So, yeah, I'd say to go ahead and buy it, save the $60 and install them yourself.
Regarding the AppleCare, I share your mixed feelings. I usually don't buy extended warranties, but I did on my last Apple Purchase, a 12" PowerBook. I'm glad I did; it's already paid for itself in a new Power Adapter plug-in thingie and a brand new case bottom and battery because a silly little rubber foot fell off.
But for a desktop? Doesn't make much sense to me. The Apple Discussion Boards are full of people who know just as much as the Support Tech's and the chances of a desktop needing hardware repair are small.
Just my $0.02.
Posted by: Seth Dimbert at November 23, 2003 05:11 PM