« PC-less for 12th day in a row | Main | iPod too sensitive »

November 21, 2003

Cell phone number portability pitfalls

in a last minute effort, the phone industry is trying to get the federal mandate to allow cell phone number portability lifted. But that doesn[t seem likely, given previous statements from the FCC. Meanwhile, all the hype over the new rules allowing customers to keep the same phone number if they change cell phone providers misses a crucial point.
While it's great that we will soon be able to keep the same number, the fact remains most cell phone customers are on long-term contracts. So even though number portability takes effect Monday, you are still responsible for the contract you have with your provider.
That means switching carriers simply is not an easy option for most of us.,br> Here's another problem: You'll probably need a new phone. Different wireless carriers usually have incompatible network technologies. And most cell phones are programmed to work only on the network of the carrier that supplied the phone.
A site called MobileWireFly evaluates different cell phone plans and portability issues.
in Mobile lifestyle | TrackBack (0)

Comments

"Here's another problem: You'll probably need a new phone. Different wireless carriers usually have incompatible network technologies. And most cell phones are programmed to work only on the network of the carrier that supplied the phone."

The only carriers that have incompatible handsets are Nextel and Sprint. They use iDen and CDMA, respectively.

The rest, however, are all either switching or have switched to GSM, which is the global standard.

Most GSM carriers will give you the code to unlock your SIM if you've been with them for 6months to a year... you just have to call and ask. :)

It's also possible to get your phone unlocked if you find the right tools. Unlocking your phone is in no way illegal since you own it.

I wouldn't be surprised if the next big uproar from consumers involves locked handsets. Some people will probably be in for a big shock when they try to switch carriers with the same phone.

Posted by: Mike at November 21, 2003 02:45 PM

Mike #2-
you are right except that many many people have older phones-- I know several people still with analog cellular phones, and those were usually customized for each carrier and not transferable. Sure, we can force them to upgrade to switch carriers, but many people are satisfied with the simple functionality and confused by all the gizmos of modern phones. That aspect, if nothing else, will keep them from switching.

Mike W:
I was looking for a new carrier right before this mandate was announced, and you could still find one-year agreements pretty plentifully-- now all I see advertised are two-year agreements for obvious reasons. I will not switch from T-mobile unless I can get a one year contract, even if it means I have to pay more.
I'd hate to miss some of the cool wi-fi enabled phones coming out which will offer VoIP calling when you're in a wifi hotspot.

Another thing to keep in mind, even if you don't want to switch-- if you like your carrier-- you may be able to negotiate a better deal once your contract is expired to keep you on the network. I understand some of the technological hurdles and problems this law may cause, but I think it's ultimately better for the consumer. The inability to change carriers while keeping your number was a disruption to the free market competition (gosh, I wish I could remember the term in economics for that).

T

Posted by: Toeknee at November 21, 2003 04:17 PM

Actually, a lot of cell companies are not GSM. Sprint & Nextel come to mind, as do Verizon (#1 wireless company in the US), Alltel, US Cellular. I"m sure there are more, but those are the ones that come to mind.

Posted by: mark at November 21, 2003 10:46 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits