
I have the same problem when I have it on my belt in my Marware case -- a slight brush with my arm will change songs, volume, etc. I liked the old design better, wish I could get that with a 40GB hard drive.
Posted by: DC at November 21, 2003 03:41 PMIt's all about the Hold switch Mike. Use it whenever you are going to not be using the controls. Once you are in the habit of setting the hold switch, you'll be golden.
Took me a bit to get used to it, but now it's second nature to set the hold switch once I've made my choice. I've heard some iPod "skinz" actually make it a bit harder to hit a button by accident.
Hold Switch = iPod Satisfaction
Posted by: Howrad Wright at November 21, 2003 05:03 PMThe sizes are nice, but the whole redesign of the ipod puzzles me. I'm on my 2nd older iPod, had a 5 gig, now 10. I prefer the layout of the buttons in the up-down-left-right layout oriented around the scroll wheel- they're easily distinguished by feel, and I have to intend to press them, not just inadvertantly glance them as Mike discusses.
Every 3rd gen iPod I've met has been too touchy for me too.
Posted by: Steve Y at November 21, 2003 06:03 PMI have both the old style and the 30G 3rd generation version. I find myself using my old iPod most of the time. It seems more functional -- and the battery life is significantly longer. I think Apple might have laid an egg with this. I agree that the buttons of the new iPod are far to sensitive. I miss my first iPod that had no touch wheel -- it was mechanical -- not touch sensitive -- and that seemed to work the best -- whether jogging or riding the tractor.
Posted by: Sean O'Bryan at November 22, 2003 08:18 AMMy 15GB 3G iPod is the first I've had, but I agree that the buttons are too sensitive. But, as others have said, the magical solution is in the hold switch. After awhile it simply becomes second nature to flip the switch on-and-off whenever you need to make a control adjustment. These days it's not unheard of for me to flip the hold switch to "off," change the volume (or skip to the next song, etc), and then flip the switch back to "on" ... all while running. Yes, the buttons might be sensitive, but it's a heck of a lot better than my old Iomega HipZip.
Posted by: Jim Collison at November 22, 2003 11:06 AMThe best solution is the PodSleev $20 from RadTech which makes the buttons and controls less sensitive and protects the ipod at the same time. You don't even have to remove the case to use it with the the belt case.
Posted by: Dick Lampe at November 22, 2003 11:18 AMMike,
You posted this exact same comment (i-pod too sensitive) months ago. Did you just copy and paste this in, having nothing else to write? It's word for word.
Either way, I check-in on your blog occasionally. Keep it up.
get the 3rd generation ipod... it has buttons u can only press with your fingers or skin.
Posted by: adam at December 26, 2003 04:36 PM
It bothers me occasionally, normally only in the car when i have it sitting in the seat and try to reach over to find it, only to hit a button.
But as far as your pocket goes, turn on the hold switch to avoid that problem.
Posted by: Derek at November 21, 2003 02:47 PM