« Apple's new mouse is inefficient | Main | Don't fall for phony Microsoft e-mail »

September 19, 2003

Couple helps diagnose Comcast outage problems

They and the neighbors called tech Comcast's new $20 million high speed Internet support phone center to complain about frequent disruptions but didn't get much success. "We couldn't convince them that this was a real problem, not just with us, but all our neighbors," said Comcast subscriber Carol Shulman, of Ann Arbor, MI. Her husband, Mike Clark said Comcast techs were also clueless when he called. So the couple who also happen to run an IT consulting business wrote their own program that logged and documented the problems in their neighborhood. It proved there indeed was something wrong on Comcast's end, recording 8 outages over 20 minutes long and more than 50 of shorter duration over a two-day period. They also took their complaints directly to Comcast corporate headquarters in Philadelphia, reaching the office of president Brian Roberts. The result: Vindication. Engineers verified there indeed was a problem with the software that controlled a Comcast router to their neighborhood. It's now been fixed. You can read the whole story in my newspaper column today.
in Internet | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I have had the same problems up in Rochester. Do you think that Comcast will be troubleshooting their entire system with what they found in Ann Arbor? And/or there may be a market for this monitor!

Posted by: Mike Koehler at September 19, 2003 08:56 AM

I should buy Carol Shulman and Mike Clark a lunch. And Comcast owes its customers an apology (and perhaps a refund). My friends in Ann Arbor had the same problem and Comcast told all of us we had to disconnect our routers. I use mine for protection. So as soon as I disconnected it, I started downloading the Windows XP patch to prevent the attack of the MSBlaster worm. However, while I was downloading the patch, the worm made a successful attack. There were many computer crashes before it was cleansed of the worm.

Bruce Laidlaw
Ann Arbor

Posted by: Bruce Laidlaw at September 19, 2003 09:07 AM

Dear Mr. Wendland:

Thank you for that article in this morning's paper. It precisely describes our experience with Comcast service. We were ready to cancel our Comcast contract because of the very poor and intermittent service we were getting for our $62 per month. Perhaps, in the future, this kind of poor service and poor response to customer complaints will result in weak providers going out of business. Too bad - we are also stockholders in Comcast.

Kudos to Shulman and Clark!

Posted by: Steven Levine at September 19, 2003 09:28 AM

I'd like to get a copy of that monitoring software and install it at my house. I live in Berkley, and lately I've been having quite a few intermittent problems. I don't trust Comcast to check for the Ann Arbor issue here.

Anybody know of any monitoring tools that would work? I'd like to get the Clark program, but unless he reads this board, he might not be aware of the demand.

Ted

Posted by: Ted Sajbel at September 19, 2003 11:43 AM

I will be happy to share my program as soon as a few details are worked out. Will post more here.

Specifically, I'd like to talk to the Comcast engineers with whom I've been working to make sure that I don't help unleash a ping flood that would complicate more than it would help.

I might add that having gotten to the right people, they have been great about keeping in touch and letting me call and email them. They really care about getting it right.

Posted by: Mike Clark at September 19, 2003 03:29 PM

I'm having the same problems in Hazel Park. Only recently, after expressing my anger on www.commentsoncomast.com have I got the attention of the people in Customer Service. (Although, the problem has not yet been fixed.) Hopefully the Freep article will begin generating some action.

Posted by: Shawn Polito at September 20, 2003 05:51 PM

Since Mr. Wendland's story appeared, I have received email and phone calls from people who are experiencing similar problems in other cities.

From what I've come to understand about the topology of the Comcast network and of the nature of the problem that was afflicting Ann Arbor, it is conceivable that the same issues could be affecting a *much* broader area. Some of the people who have contacted me could be having similar problems.

I have created a new discussion thread in dslreports.com at http://www.dslreports.com/forum/remark,8061052~root=comcast~mode=flat and am encourage people to make their voice heard by contacting Comcast and posting at dslreports and here.

Comcast pays attention to Mr. Wendland's columns and he knows how to open some doors that aren't available to everyone.

Exhort your friends, neighbors and acquaintances to make a voice to be heard that cannot be denied.

Posted by: Mike Clark at September 25, 2003 09:22 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits