« Macs stirring major interest | Main | Couple helps diagnose Comcast outage problems »

September 19, 2003

Apple's new mouse is inefficient

I love Apple and Macs. You know that. But for the life of me, I simply cannot understand why Apple refuses to give us a mouse with more than one function. Their new wireless mouse released this week looks cool. But the mouse is still a one-button affair. The right-click function that third party makers build into their pointing devices provides huge efficiency gains. I can't help but think Apple is stubbornly keeping the one-button function as a sort of cult thing. Like the old Windows users used to cling to 3.1 or UNIX users refuse anything that simplifies the typing of arcane commands, Apple's new old-style mouse remains firmly mired in the 70's. I know it has Bluetooth. But with one button, it's still old in the tooth.


in Hardware | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I saw this mouse in a store. I agree, It is no different than older versions. I will not use Apple's keyboard or mouse. The keyboard's too small. I use Logitech's cordless natural keyboard and a Microsoft cordless optical mouse. Logitech's mice are too large for my hand.

Posted by: Carol at September 19, 2003 08:42 AM

The reason is from what I understand that macintosh computers are supposed to be easy to use and research prove that one button mouse are less confusing than two. So Apple ship them with one button, while they give u the option of third party two-button mouse

Posted by: King at September 19, 2003 08:58 AM

Confusing for those who are starting to use computers that is

Posted by: King at September 19, 2003 09:10 AM

I would have to agree. As much as I love Apple products and would love to use a Bluetooth mouse, I couldn't see going back to ONE Button and having to hold the Control-Key everytime I wanted a contextual menu. I'm not convinced that I need a wireless keyboard either. I'm also wondering why Apple didn't build some type of battery recharging function into these new devices? It would have been typical Apple "coolness" to do so.

Posted by: Terry at September 19, 2003 09:30 AM

I don't mind the one button mouse so much. I use a Windows machine all day at work that has multi buttons and a scroll wheel. The switch to the one button at home is painless. I do however miss the scroll wheel on the Mac mouse. My personal preference would be to push for a scroll wheel ahead of the second button.

Posted by: Scott at September 19, 2003 11:19 AM

I think a "click and hold" cue for the contextual menu would be better than a two button mouse. Seems like this would have been easy to include in Panther.

Posted by: Mike at September 19, 2003 12:56 PM

You may want to check out this As the Apple Turns article — http://www.appleturns.com/scene/?id=4210

While it's written somewhat tongue-in-cheek (par for the course at AtAT), there's a good argument buried in there. For novice computer users, one button really is much easier. Advanced users have the option of picking up a different mouse — and they're not exactly terribly expensive these days.

Admittedly, I do wish that Apple offered a fancier mouse as an option, but I also don't have a major issue with their leaving the single-button mouse as the default.

Posted by: Michael Hanscom at September 19, 2003 01:18 PM

What amazes me is that Apple, a company known for asthetics, has yet to even attempt an ergonmic keyboard.

Their plain jane keyboard, though made out of high quality materials, is still basically the same one they've been making for over a decade.

C'mon... how about something similar to Microsoft's Natural Keyboard.

While Bluetooth is great, I won't be spending $150 for such basic peripherals.

Apple needs to offer a REAL Pro mouse and keyboard for us techies who demand more than the average user.

Posted by: Mike at September 19, 2003 02:18 PM

Apple *has* made an ergonomic keyboard in the past; it just wasn't a very good one. Remember the Apple Adjustable Keyboard?

http://mail.apple.com.pl/download/_PDFLibrary/Peryferia_i_karty/Keyboard_Adjustable.pdf

Posted by: Bob Studer at September 19, 2003 03:27 PM

Actually, I think Apple should continue making one-button mice. What would happen if Apple began to ship multi-button mice? The same thing that happened after Apple shipped all Macs with USB ports - developers started developing new products and apps for USB, knowing that USB would be there.

While I use a multi-button mouse for my WinXP machine and PowerBook, it's a bad idea for Apple to ship a multi-button mouse with Macs. That would only encourage developers to add complex contextual menus and pretty soon, it will become very difficult to use a Mac app with only one button! Who wants to see that happen? I would say a large reason why Windows apps are always so much more complicated to use is precisely BECAUSE of the contextual menus (I just tried the other day over IM to talk a friend of mine on how to change the resolution of her screen - it took 20 minutes, all because of having to use contextual menus and such, and the contextual menus were confusing her).

So, let's not all get hysterical over the one button thing because in the end, it's good for users...it forces developers to design their app interfaces intelligently because they can't necessarily rely on the fact that a user may have a multi-button mouse. This is a GOOD THING.

Posted by: Paul at September 19, 2003 04:48 PM

What's a mouse and why would you want a button on it?
Oh yeah that's that outmoded thing that moves the cursor and such. My keyboard does all that now and so much better. Try FingerWorks.com if you want to see the future now...

seeya
dxtr

Posted by: dxtr at September 19, 2003 09:06 PM

I would completely agree with Bob Studer
I am sure it has a deeper meaning that the company understands than we, the average consumers, do......

Posted by: king at September 20, 2003 04:11 PM

I really don't see the difference between using a finger to click on a PC mouse's second button and using a finger to click on a Mac's control key (i.e. the second button). This "debate" has seemed so moot for so long. . . .

Posted by: J Lehrer at September 21, 2003 11:37 AM

[Quote]I really don't see the difference between using a finger to click on a PC mouse's second button and using a finger to click on a Mac's control key (i.e. the second button). This "debate" has seemed so moot for so long. . . .[/Quote]

The difference is that with the Control Key it takes TWO hands, one to click the mouse button and one to hold down the Control Key. With a 2 button mouse, it still only takes one finger. That's the difference.

While I see the merits of a single button mouse to remain the default for what's in the box and for new users, I don't see the reason why Apple can't offer an "OPTIONAL" 2 button mouse with scroll wheel that is wireless via Bluetooth for the Pros?

Yes, there are 3rd party mice. However, if it comes from Apple it will just work! It would also match the rest of the system. Don't get me wrong, I'm a strong advocate for Apple leaving room for 3rd party developers. Apple can't and shouldn't do it all, however, I think this one should come from Apple "too". 3rd Parties can make 2 button, 4 button mice (like the M$ Wireless Intellimouse Explorer that I'm using right now) and tablets, etc. etc.

Posted by: Terry at September 21, 2003 12:39 PM

What I'd like to know is why journalists *never* do so much as a web search before asking "why doesn't Apple do this" or "why don't they do this?"

These have been debated to _death_. Restating the talking points _yet_ again:

* Windows' menus are slow to access because they're not at the top of the screen.

* So Windows applications provide contextual menus as a shortcut.

* Windows is also very inconsistent in keeping windows in the same place where you left them.

* So Windows users tend to maximize everything. (Defeating the purpose of a windowed GUI...)

* So drag and drop is almost completely useless on Windows. (Unless you know the "drag to taskbar" trick... you know that, right?)

* So Windows apps have to provide equivalent functionality through contextual menus...

* Mac menus, because they're effectively infinitely tall, are much faster. You just bang the mouse, move a little left or right, and choose your command.

* So the Mac relies far less on contextual menus.

* The Mac lets you have many windows arranged in a haphazard fashion, but they stay where you put them. Also, the Mac Finder has spring-loaded folders.

* So Mac users use drag and drop quite heavily.

Note that Windows also has keyboard shortcuts for everything you can possibly do with the mouse. Standard Windows keyboards even have a key for clicking the right-mouse button! (it's next to the Windows logo key and looks like a menu)

Why doesn't the Mac have all that? Because it's all completely useless. And for 95% of users, the right-mouse button is completely useless. So for those 5% of us who need it, we can choose the perfect mouse from dozens of vendors.

Posted by: Ben at September 21, 2003 01:41 PM

Also, has anyone ever seen any empirical evidence that ergonomic keyboards are actually better than standard keyboards?

I mean evidence as in peer-reviewed studies by independent labs, not, "well, that's what the manufacturer's press kit said!"

Lately I've been reading that RSI is mostly bunk anyway...

Posted by: Ben at September 21, 2003 01:57 PM

>>The difference is that with the Control Key it takes TWO hands, one to click the mouse button and one to hold down the Control Key.<<

Indeed---and TYPING takes two hands, too, yet no one complains about that. The physical effort to extend a baby finger of one hand onto the Control key while mousing with the other is what, maybe .037 on a scale of 1-100?

Still, I agree that Apple should go ahead and offer a two-button mouse as an option for those who think they need it. If the difference between a second button press or a key press is enough to potentially send users over to Windows, then it just makes good business sense to pacify and placate those users before they defect.

But when you look at this issue, you see how strong an ideological appeal to "majority use" can be. Most people have two buttons, so everyone should have two buttons---where is the logic here? As our parents used to say, "If all your friends jumped off a cliff, would you?"

It seems that Apple's infamous '1984' ad was sadly ironic: instead of the Mac releasing the robotic masses into freedom, the masses continue to pressure the Mac to conform.

Posted by: J Lehrer at September 22, 2003 10:31 AM

Cultists.... they are blind believers... there's no suggesting that their 100% Mac way could be improved.

Posted by: Mike Wendland at September 22, 2003 11:13 AM

LOL...yeah, when Apple does finally get around to introducing a multi-button mouse, the cultists will bow down and proclaim it to be the greatest thing since...well, since the single-button mouse.

I have the distinct feeling that most folks who think a single-button mouse is just fine, thank you very much, have never _used_ a multi-button mouse with a scroll wheel. The efficiency gains are incredible.

Y'all have it slightly wrong, though. Apple does not produce a single-button mouse. More to the point, after years of requests for a multifunction rodent, Apple gave us a revolutionary NO BUTTON MOUSE!

What are they smoking in Cupertino?

Thanks goodness for third-party vendors. I'm with you on this one, Mike: I'd love a bluetooth mouse/keyboard combo, but until Apple quits standing in the corner and holding their breath on this issue, I'll be spending my money elsewhere.

Posted by: Rich at September 22, 2003 11:58 AM

I figured that my mention of 'robotic masses' would generate a response, but I didn't think that Boss Mike himself would make a personal appearance to label me a 'cultist.' This is a rare honor. But to be clear: Every day at work I use (or endure) a PC with Windows 2000 and yes, that scroll wheel is mighty handy for reading long web pages, especially. But again, when I get home to my Mac, I find that the same finger that operates the PC scroll wheel can operate the Mac keyboard's down-arrow key for the identical effect.

Also, Rich is right: technically the Apple optical mouse has no buttons at all---making it truly revolutionary! Not that there's anything *wrong* with multibutton mice; they're just. . . more complicated than a mouse needs to be.

Of course, this entire debate will end when computer makers finally deliver on the promise of holographic, voice-activated operating systems, right?

Posted by: J Lehrer at September 22, 2003 03:26 PM

I have to point out that the finger with which J Lehrer uses his scroll wheel at work and his down arrow at home is attached to his hand. The difference is, his hand, when at the keyboard, is NOT on his mouse.

How is moving your finger 1/2" from the scroll wheel to the mouse button more complicated than moving your whole hand between mouse and keyboard?

My one comment on the new Apple Bluetooth mouse is AT LEAST they got rid of the most poorly designed aspect of its wired predecessor--the wire. I've had more of those mice fail (where I work) at the point where the wire enters the mouse...

Posted by: Pete at September 23, 2003 12:33 PM

"Cultists.... they are blind believers... there's no suggesting that their 100% Mac way could be improved."

Is that the actual Mike Wendland? If so, you ought to be ashamed of yourself. (If not, please disregard, below comments, though my above remarks hold.)

Where did I say the Mac is perfect? How is it "blind" belief when I've actually read the human factors literature, not to mention studying it as part of a computer science degree? If anyone's a damned cultist, it's *you* who reject a reasoned point of view without even attempting to form a counter argument.

This is just the standard pathetic excuse for what passes as journalism nowadays: you just mindlessly repeat hype and press releases, when your Jayson Blair colleagues aren't just making crap up wholesale.

Posted by: Ben at September 25, 2003 06:22 PM

"Not that there's anything *wrong* with multibutton mice; they're just. . . more complicated than a mouse needs to be."

There's similarly nothing *wrong* with a floppy drive, or zip drive.

It's just not a good standard configuration that offers critical functionality for the vast majority of users.

Similarly, you'll find that the two-button / scrollwheel, when you speak with a large number of users, makes the standard configuration overly complicated.

The reason my iBook is 99% perfect for me is that it is a 95% perfect to start with, and I was able to configure the last 4% to my liking. Yes, there are some issues, but the point is that when you configure a Mac, you make it go from "extremely good" to "close to perfect."

That's why I support Apple's (and every other computer manufacture's) use of commodity parts. For those small changes that suit just me, I can get whatever parts my very particular needs demand.

But this debate is about the critical default configuration, which is often a person's first experience. We don't always buy a computer with weeks to get it up to speed. Often times we buy a new computer when a crisis has erupted... our old machine died, for example.

The Windows default configuration is "barely usable" for most people. Yes, nerds love two-button scrollwheel mice, and I agree with them, speaking as a nerd. But speaking as a software developer, and as someone who teaches basic computer skills to adult learners, it is nothing but frustrating. The stupid Windows toolbars are just frustrating.

*If* I was prepared to spend weeks teaching them nothing but how to fix Window's interface, they could make Windows go from "barely usable" to "fairly tolerable." Instead, half of the class is taken up warning them about all the insane crap Office can do... One time we were doing web email and one woman was stuck because an ad had taken over the entire screen and put a fake close box in there. If it had been her home computer, and she had been doing some work, she probably would have had to turn off the machine because from her perspective, it had "taken over."

Why, in God's name, does MS allow that kind of crap?

Don't they ever sit down with people and actually *use* their own horrible crap and realize that people don't want to move toolbars around? Why do I have to spend so much time rescuing people who mislay the taskbar? People don't want 3 ways of closing a window that are subtly different, they want one that works!

The second mouse button does not offer additional functionality to the vast majority of users. Second, it adds complexity and prevents people from getting their work done.

Thus, it should not be shipped standard with computers. If you don't understand this reasoning, it's because you have never sat down with people, who, are desperate to get the computer skills they need for a job, and *used* these machines and seen why they have such a tough time.

Usability must not be an optional accessory, and I will always strongly defend Apple for their commitment to it.

Posted by: Ben at September 25, 2003 06:46 PM

Umm... just for the record, I'd like to distance myself from Ben and his lengthy screeds. When I cited the 1984 ad, I was kidding---and I think Mike realized that (and kidded back). But these shrill lectures and railings against MS are the kinds of arch sermonizing that makes Windoze users think of Mac users as joyless Rainmen.

I mean come on, it's just a light debate about a little MOUSE. . . .

Posted by: J Lehrer at September 25, 2003 10:46 PM

>>* Windows' menus are slow to access because they're not at the top of the screen.

This BS it's actually faster; I don't have to move all the way to the top - I move it to where my windowed app toolbar is.. smaller distance to move.

* So Windows applications provide contextual menus as a shortcut.

irrelavent, contextual menus are there for shortcuts not a make-up for something deprived.

* Windows is also very inconsistent in keeping windows in the same place where you left them.

Set up a unique user profile to remember your settings so ppl don't relocate your windows under the default user.

* So Windows users tend to maximize everything. (Defeating the purpose of a windowed GUI...)

No fact on this.. depending on app I run it maximed or not whether on Win, OSX, Xwindows.. or just any gui interface I see.

* So drag and drop is almost completely useless on Windows. (Unless you know the "drag to taskbar" trick... you know that, right?)

window+D = expose's F11 key

* So Windows apps have to provide equivalent functionality through contextual menus...

nope.. it's not a based on lack off.. it's adding onto

* Mac menus, because they're effectively infinitely tall, are much faster. You just bang the mouse, move a little left or right, and choose your command.

????

* So the Mac relies far less on contextual menus.

irrelavent..

* The Mac lets you have many windows arranged in a haphazard fashion, but they stay where you put them. Also, the Mac Finder has spring-loaded folders.

So does Windows XP

* So Mac users use drag and drop quite heavily.

can do this in XP also

--

The fact of the matter is .. Apple is being stubborn.. Studies are BS. It's 2003 kiddies know how to use two button mouse's before they can walk - this is not the 80's. Fact of the matter is MOST ppl whether win/apple/ or whatever flavor of OS would prefer a two button setup with a mousewheel over one FRIGGIN old school interface style.

Posted by: Phatness at December 3, 2003 02:51 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits