« G5 fan noise drowns out iTunes! | Main | G5 fan problem is common »

November 25, 2003

More on G5 fan problem

Thanks to all who tried to help me troubleshoot the noise problem with my brand new G5.
Here's a recap:
I bought the unit at my local Apple Store this afternoon and, following the advice of many, I also bought AppleCare. In doing so, the store offered to install my extra memory - to give me 1GB or RAM - and my APple Extreme card. They did so and I bought the machine home.
But when I turned it on... man, it sounds like a 747. All the fans are roaring at startup, then it backs down a bit but is still way too loud.
Following suggestions several of you made, I checked the clear plastic deflector and the tape on the bottom of right that apparently signals when the fans should run. All are properly installed.
I called AppleCare and they had me reset PRAM, with no results. Then they told me to run a hardware test and, before hanging up, said to let them know if it found anything. Well, I just ran the test and it returns an error code of "post/2176/0."
What that is - I haven't a clue. AppleCare is now closed and the G5 is still much too noisy.

in G5 | TrackBack (2)

Comments

Sounds to me like they should have put the Genius of the genius bar in quotes. I'll bet they knocked loose a wire. I'll make a bigger bet that they didn't turn the machine on to test the ram after installing it. Really stupid move. something like this should not have left the store.

My favorite term comes to mind again.

slop!

I do hope you enjoy the machine once it's going quitely. It is supposed to be much quieter than you're getting. It would be great if you video tape it and then we can videotape the front fan of a Cessna 172 (airplane propeller) and see which makes more noise.:)

Posted by: supportTEX at November 25, 2003 11:33 PM

The only thing I was able to find is that POST=power on self test--
There is not a lot of data on G5 error codes out there yet.

I don't know how far the Apple Store is, but if I were you, I wouldn't waste time with Apple Support-- you just bought this today. I would take it in and request a new one. If they want to hear the fans, let them fire them up, but if they can't quiet them immediately, I would insist on a new product, or demand a refund.

T

Posted by: Toeknee at November 26, 2003 12:30 AM

Return the machine, ask for an appeasement of some kind, because they've clearly wasted your time. A POST error is power-on self test, and it should have come up when they ran the hardware test after they installed the RAM.

Posted by: Nobody at November 26, 2003 09:57 AM

Hi Mike,

I feel your pain. I am working on my 4th G5, because of this fan issue. I have been troubleshooting since last October. Once my fans kick on it sounds like a jet, I have to shut the machine down and then when I go to restart, my display fails to come back on. I guess the 3 questions I have for you are.

1. What kind of monitor are you using and how old is it?
2. Are you using and airport card?
3. Do you have the G5 plugged into any type of Battery BackUp device?

I feel very confident that my Apple Cinema display (one of the first Cinema displays released years ago) is the culprit in
frying all the machines.

Do you have any thoughts on it??? I really can't take it anymore...

Thanks, e

Posted by: Elise Donoghue at January 16, 2004 07:44 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits