

There it is... my new dual-processor 1.8GB PowerMac G5. Just plugged it in and the first thing I notice is the fan noise. It's way too loud. Is this a problem on the G5's? I thought that was licked with the G4. It's too distracting to work and even drowns out low iTunes music. I'll share more on the system later (and, yes, I did buy AppleCare) but this fan noise needs to be fixed. I hope and pray there's an easy solution here. I don't remember the evaluation unit Apple sent me being this noisy.
Congrats on the New G5 purchase. My Dual 2GHz G5 runs extremely quiet. The only time I've ever heard the fans was when I first got it and booted it in Firewire Target Disk Mode to copy some files to it. My guess is that in that mode of operation that the cooling system management is not on and ALL the fans just run at full blast. It sounded like an airplane the whole time. Once it was rebooted back into normal mode, it was whisper quiet.
Posted by: Terry White at November 25, 2003 04:21 PMFound the reference to the baffle:
"...The aluminum chassis and mesh front keep the machine cool enough that the fans normally turn slowly and silently. Interestingly, when you remove the clear air baffle with the power on, a red light comes on in the G5's case and all of the fans throttle up to full -- and sound a lot more like an Intel or AMD machine."
from
http://www.newsforge.com/hardware/03/11/21/2021241.shtml?tid=73&tid=81
No... they installed the extra memory. I just called Apple support and they first had me reset the PRAM... that didn't help. Now they have me doing an extended hardware test to "see if the fans are okay." Good grief, it sounds like a 747!!! The tech support gal had me start the test and then hung up, saying if the test shows the fans are bad to call back.
THIS is AppleCare???
I have owned this machine for all of an hour now.
We'll see.
do you notice the red light referred to in the Newsforge article?
After installing the memory, did they boot it up to test?
Posted by: Toeknee at November 25, 2003 04:41 PMI dont know if they booted it up to test after installing the memory... I have to teach a class tonight. I'll check when I get back. Otherise... it's back to Apple. The fan noise is laughable it is so loud! My wife hears it in the next room.
I'll open the case and look for the baffle and red light... though the reference in the review you linked to isn't very clear on where that may be.
Later...
It was cursed by your G4. :D
Posted by: baw at November 25, 2003 05:16 PMThe loud noise is normal. The fans are trying to blow you through the wall into your back yard. :)
Posted by: chimpee at November 25, 2003 05:18 PMI think I found what was meant by baffle-- it's the clear "deflector" inside the case which must be in the proper position when reinserted - see:
http://www.info.apple.com/usen/cip/pdf/g5/073-0810.pdf
Also found this on the Apple discussions site:
"Check the plastic air deflector. There should be a small piece of silver reflective tape on the rightmost of the three tabs at the bottom - that's what tells the G5 to turn the fans off. If it's missing, try covering that tab with something equivalent (e.g. black masking tape) "
T
Posted by: Toeknee at November 25, 2003 05:21 PMmy friend just bought a g5 and it definately is not loud...i didn't even notice the fan while we were watching some streaming video
Posted by: diego at November 25, 2003 07:19 PMJust be sure to bring your spray paint can and stencils to the Apple Store in case they won't fix the fans.
Posted by: davis at November 25, 2003 08:46 PMThanks all for this great advice. it was the little strip of white tape on the rightmost tab of the Plastic Baffle inside that solved my problem. My G5 was so noisy in use I had to keep putting it to sleep. Now as quiet as a mouse. GREAT!
Simon
Posted by: at December 10, 2003 02:01 PMThanks to Terry for letting us know about the fan noise on the G5 when in Firewire Target Disk Mode.
The first thing I did out of the box was try to CCC my old hard drive and I thought this thing was going to hit takeoff velocity.
Your posting reassured me before the CCC finished that this full-on fan noise would cease!
Posted by: Blaise at January 6, 2004 11:46 PM
Congrats-- and definitely NO-- the G5 is supposed to be quieter than the iMac G4s from the accounts I have read.
I suppose since you got Applecare they could have put in your RAM and fired up the beast to test it, but the pics looks like it's still sealed-- so you opted to install the RAM yourself?
Supposedly if some baffle is removed, the fans rev up to compensate-- perhaps check the baffles? *grin*
Otherwise, a call to Apple and a trip back to the store pronto is advised before installing anything on the G5.
T
Posted by: Toeknee at November 25, 2003 04:19 PM