
Yeah, it'd be even funnier if it were true. Which it's not. You have several options for a dead iPod battery:
* An AppleCare agreement at $99
* A do-it-yourself replacement at $49 (find it here: http://www.ipodbattery.com/ )
* An extended warranty from the place of purchase. I bought a three-year replacement warranty for $49 when I picked the iPod up at my local Best Buy. That, my friends, is the best deal of all, because that battery is certain to die within three years.
The bottom line: this "protest" is based on a lie. An iPod battery does NOT cost over $250 to replace. I'll give the guy his due, though...he's running a heckuva fine FUD campaign.
Posted by: Rich at November 25, 2003 01:46 PMI think he made the video before Apple released the $99 battery replacement plan a few days ago. It must've taken him at least 2-3 weeks to do all that graffiti and then edit the iMovie. What a waste of time, IMHO.
Now, he's a rebel without a cause.
If he had any integrity (and didn't just want his 14 minutes of Internet fame) -- he'd modify his site to reflect the current state of affairs.
Posted by: Josh at November 25, 2003 01:54 PMI don't know, isn't $99 a bit high for a battery replacement? Wouldn't you expect this battery to last longer than 18 months?
Posted by: Frank McPherson at November 25, 2003 06:05 PMI have had my iPod since June 2002 and the battery today while at work has lasted about close to 5 hours. So, less than the original time but still fine for when I use it. If I get really desperate while at work, I can just plug it in and listen while charging (not the wisest thing). If all you are doing is listening to music, where are you that you need 8 hours of continuous battery time? Turn off the backlighting is one big way to save juice. Neat video but based on a lie...if that Applecare guy is real, Apple needs to train their folks better.
Posted by: diego at November 25, 2003 07:14 PMOne would think that you would have checked the facts about this "dirty little secret" before smearing Apple! Apple charges $99 to replace a battery, and they now offer AppleCare for the iPod, which is $59, and covers everything for two years, including the battery.
Posted by: Karl Groeger at November 26, 2003 12:11 AMMy wife has my old iPod, one of the originals I purchased in November of 2001, 24 months ago for those who don't want to do the math. It's still running fine. It may not hold as much of a charge as it used to but it holds enough that she's never found out.
You can get a replacement battery and install it yourself for $49. It's not really any harder than installing RAM and I don't hear people griping about the scourge of having to install RAM.
Posted by: John Moltz at November 26, 2003 04:43 PMYou blind Apple Die Hards! Think just that cuz your iPod is still going that all other iPods are the same. Listen to the Phone call, the Apple Representative said that it would cost 255$ (at that time). So how is the video's message a lie? I went out and did some home work. The model of battery apple(sony in reality) used in the first run of Ipods had a manufacturers life time charge count of 350 (100% discharges). That is 2800 hours of use, factoring 8hrs/charge. Factor that with the way the ipod is charged, on and off during use, and it will extend the battery life to Approximately 3000 hours. Apple's projected moderate use time was 42 hours per week, or 3024 hour in 18 months. Look how close that comes to the Approximate battery life of 3000 hours. That to me is the most likely reason Apple would not warranty the battery after 18 months. To an objective PC/Mac user this will make sense. (Thanks to John, my apple insider, for getting me some general marketing stats and part numbers)
Posted by: Danny at December 5, 2003 07:29 PMIn addition, I think it was a suspicious move on Apple's part to lower that battery replacemnt charge just as the public at large was starting to realize the nonsensical price. Especially when they had the numbers and stats to know after 18 months a good number of ipods should have started to need new batteries. During the introduction of the Ipod the cost of such a Hitech battery might have substantiated some of that high price, however, as battery technology increased and costs went down Apple should have been on the ball and lowered customer charges.
Posted by: Danny at December 5, 2003 07:45 PMI had purchased a 20GB ipod (holds about 5000 songs) about 20 months ago and i have not actually experienced (so far) any problems. But i have to say i know two people who purchased an ipod around the same tme as me one being my girlfriend buying a 20GB and a friend buying a 40GB ipod both of which have experienced problems but both purchased a replacement battery rather than paying $250 to send in for "refurbishment". All in all if you are considering buying an ipod, they are an amazing piece of technology and are very much so worth splahing out. But i would reccomend buying a 20GB ipod rather than a 40GB (which not many people would fill) or a 10GB because a 20GB ipod is only about $50 more than a 10GB (and it is well worth it!).
Posted by: Kevin at December 22, 2003 05:40 AM
I am not sure i understand the crux of his complaint if all it needed was a new battery--
Apple will replace a battery for $99 (plus shipping etc.).
See http://www.info.apple.com/support/applecare_products/service/ipod_service.html for details.
But it's a fun video anyway.
Posted by: Toeknee at November 25, 2003 12:43 PM