« More info on Wardrivers Wi-Fi hacking bust | Main | iPod's dirty little secret video »

November 24, 2003

Apple loses out on Michigan laptop buy

While Michigan's new laptop computer program for sixth-grade students now looks like it will be cancelled because of a massive budget deficit, if it does go forward, officials have decided the laptops won't be Apples.
They'll be HP's.
Hewlett-Packard was announced this afternoon as the vendor of choice of the Michigan State Department of Management and Budget. It was one of five companies vying for what would have been a $32 million deal - the most lucrative such computers-in-the-classroom program in the country. Michigan Gov. Jennifer Granholm has recently said she will reluctantly recommend that the plan be scrapped in light of a $900 million state deficit. The state legislature approved the plan last summer.
in Apple | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Success stories from school districts who've done this need to be compiled in an easy-to-read, factual manner - anyone know of any sites tracking this topic, Mac or PC?

Reports like today's on Macintouch (http://www.macintouch.com/eduproj.html) must be out there, maybe even compiled already.

Presented with the facts (which hopefully make the iBook programs look good!), it seems to me it would be a no-brainer. Presented with emotion ("Macs RULE!" vs. "we need our children to learn what they'll be strapped to at their work desk in 10 years"), the Macs will unfortunately lose.

T

Posted by: Toeknee at November 24, 2003 07:15 PM

Hi, it's me again-- this topic has me upset-- reading the story at this link:
http://www.mlive.com/newsflash/michigan/index.ssf?/newsflash/get_story.ssf?/cgi-free/getstory_ssf.cgi?g9304_BC_MI--SchoolLaptops&&news&newsflash-michigan -

Apple needs to get these contracts even if they don't make any money on it-- this is advertising, and I am damn sure HP is not making money on it-- Apple could be getting their product in the hands of potentially 130,000 kids and families, maybe breaking even, maybe losing a little money, but either way, it's the cheapest form advertising they could do, because the product sells itself. Those iBooks would change a lot of minds about Apple products and would lead to many more future sales.

Fight, Apple, Fight!

T

Posted by: Toeknee at November 24, 2003 07:35 PM

Maybe they can sell their laptops and use the cash for an iBook. If I was a parent in the area that would be my first (biased) question.

Posted by: Aaron Miller at November 25, 2003 12:52 AM

Mike and Toeknee (is it Tony IRL?),

While I wouldn't mind seeing the pork barrel rolled Apple's way, I wonder about these comptuer giveaways. Glenn Fleishman, a Mac guy, has frequently questioned the wisdom of this, citing a lack of hard evidence that they do any educational good. See one example here:

http://blog.glennf.com/mtarchives/001783.html

I believe Michigan was wise to kill this new entitlement, even though they were forced to do so. Too bad the feds aren't likewise constrained to balance the budget.

Posted by: Brian at November 25, 2003 12:59 AM

It'll cost them much, much more IT-wise in the long-run...

Posted by: cgriego at November 25, 2003 01:41 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits