
I'm having serious second thoughts about my dissing of the Tablet PC the other day. Yesterday, I had a demo from a friend who uses one and came away seriously impressed.
I think my initial lack of interest can be attributed to the choice of the Tablet I reviewed - a combination or convertable laptop/slate model that weighed in at a wrist-straining 6.2 pounds.
But the slate models are something else. For note taking, audio recording and mobile computing, they seem hard to beat. I see lots of potential for me in using one as a journalist and I'm disappointed that Apple hasn't come out with one.
I'm going to revisit the Tablet and have narrowed by sights on three trim slate models to review: The Motion Computing M1400, the Fujitsu Stylistic ST5000 and the HP TC1100 .
There's lots of info on Tablets at TablePCBuzz.com, where they've been discussing my Tuesday review and an even more negative one from John Dvorak of PC Magazine, who references mine and then picks up where I left off.
Bottom line is I think I could use one of these big-time. The downside is the Tablet is totally incompatible with my all-Mac system.
But I think I could still be talked into buying one.
Stay tuned.
Great news that you were able to get your hands on a slate. When most people experiment with a slate, they begin to get a grasp of this new way of computing. They begin to see the possibilities of how tablet pc technology can make computing much more personal.
Keep us up to date...
Posted by: Rob Bushway (Tablet PC MVP) at November 18, 2004 10:22 AMThis fall I was at a crossroads... return to a path I had left around 1998 with Apple, and the other - a serious look at a Tablet PC.
I had decided on an PowerBook or the HP Tablet PC (one of the best tablets in my book).
I'm a full-time graduate student, and I work full-time as an Information Technology manager.
I could have easily justified the Tablet PC. It did everything I wanted. Two things kept me away... price and a feeling that it wasn't built for durability.
I ended up going down the PowerBook path, and haven't regretted it.
Now... I agree with Mike... Apple is the perfect OS, better than Windows for that matter for a Tablet. Let Steve Jobs see the wisdom... only he and his Apple creative team can build an elegant and functional tablet.
Posted by: jra at November 18, 2004 11:07 AMNo doubt there have been many prototypes floating through the halls of Apple, but they won't release one until it's really good- they have had a few product failures over the years, and they learned their lessons from them. They can't afford to absorb massive warranty repairs like some of the larger PC makers. And they can't afford the bad publicity a tablet failure would bring.
T
Posted by: ToeKnee at November 18, 2004 11:30 AMTablet PCs are yet another of the plethora of niche market devices out there. If one is part of the 0.01% of the US Population that actually has a practical use for one, it very could well be the greatest thing since sliced bread. For the other 99.99%, well, they probably just don't understand...
Posted by: Mr Attitude at November 18, 2004 05:09 PMI'm a dedicated Mac fanatic with a cool 1.5 ghz Powerbook. Love it. But am keeping my eye on the tablet phenomenon. Hoping for an OS X tablet that isn't priced out of sight. Hoping that will happen in the next year. Actually wouldn't mind it being smaller and lighter than 8-1/2 by 11. Maybe a 10" screen with 1024x768 for instance...
Posted by: Janet Tokerud at November 18, 2004 07:34 PMWhenever I read about Tablets people never talk about the artists that could use these devices. Sure people can take hand written notes, but I think the traditional drawing capabilities this brings to artists and animators is going to be revolutionary. I for one have been waiting for the Mac version for so long I am almost ready to purchase a PC Tablet.
But I think it may almost be time for Mr. Jobs version. Think about the past January Mac Expos:
Jan 01: intros TiBooks.
Jan 03 intros Aluminum Books.
Jan 05 intro Mac Tablet? I hope so.
Plus check this patent out:
Here is the link for last comment.
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/08/13/apple_tablet_mac/
Mike,
I suggest you try out the Acer C112 and give convertibles another shot. I've been using it over the past 8 months to write for and develop www.tabletpc.it and works well for me.
It's also true that tablets will remain a niche product. The way I see it is that tablet functionality is an extra set of features of I have access to on a bog standard XP machine. So by buying a tablet the user isn't compromising anything.
And tablet PCs are not only about handwriting recognition. I use OneNote as a personal organiser and don't need to convert my handwriting to text - I just refer to what I have written as if I were using pen and paper. If I do need to write long documents then I just use the keyboard.
Ciao from Italy.
Posted by: Lawrence at November 19, 2004 04:37 AMThere isn't a snowball's chance of Apple launching a Tablet-format computer. Given how they've hardly taken the Windows world by the scruff of the neck, why should Apple tool up and design for something which would be a niche product *among its own users*, who are already a niche?
I've tried Tablets. I type a lot faster on a keyboard. Agreed, they might be good for taking notes - but I can write a hell of a lot faster than any handwriting recognition system can recognise. (And as a journalist, I use shorthand, or I record. Where does the Tablet figure in that?)
Though there seems no end of Apple users who close their eyes tightly and wish very hard as though Cupertino was some sort of subsidiary of Santa's North Pole factory.
Posted by: Charles at November 19, 2004 12:30 PM"There isn't a snowball's chance of Apple"...
A lot of people predicted that Apple was supposed to have folded in the 80's and 90's and on and on... When will everyone realize that Apple is the exception and not the rule? A lot of people also said the iPod was going to be a bust but look at it's success today.
Apple's software is already there. They have a beautiful OS, past experiences of the Newton and also have the handwritten software to back it up: Inkwell. They now need the killer hardware to put it all together.
"I've tried Tablets. I type a lot faster on a keyboard."
Sometimes it's not about speed. It's about form, convenience and accessibility. Imagine walking and have to look up something on your laptop. You would have to find a table or try to open and balance it on one hand and try to use the track pad/mouse with the other hand and then type with one hand to access information.
The beauty of a using a tablet form device is the ability to access, manipulate and record information with only one hand. As a physician, I find that ability invaluable. Physicians and journalists perform similar tasks: we interview people and observe their behavior and body language. Sometimes you can't do that when you are keeping both eyes on the screen. Even though I can touch type about 60 wpm, you can easily scribble something down to review it later.
"I can write a hell of a lot faster than any handwriting recognition system can recognize. (And as a journalist, I use shorthand, or I record. Where does the Tablet figure in that?)"
I think the misunderstanding here is that you have to enter your handwriting for the computer to translate into text. This is no longer the case. If you use applications like Journal or OneNote, you can keep your shorthand notes WITHOUT having to translate them. You can also make drawings and organize your handwritten notes without having to convert it into text or have the option to convert it into text later on.
What you should be excited about is the ability of a tablet pc to coordinate both recording and text/writing at the SAME TIME. You can be audio recording an interview and jot down notes and your notes will actually correspond to the time of the recording! For example if during an interview you wanted to verify an information that was provided, you could simply write "verify this" on your notes and later on go back and simply click the words "verify this" and the audio recording will automatically jump to that spot!
As for shorthand interpretation, graffiti is a kind of shorthand (ala Palm devices) but it would be really cool if someone wrote an interpreter for real shorthand. If they can recognize Japanese, Chinese or Korean, I’m sure they can make one for real shorthand!
Posted by: Steven L at November 19, 2004 03:13 PMGlad you're revisiting the Tablet, Mike. I too am a writer and have an article about how I research and write using OneNote and a Tablet if you're interested.
http://jkontherun.blogs.com/jkontherun/2004/11/writing_with_on.html
Posted by: James Kendrick at November 19, 2004 05:36 PM"As a physician..."
Ding! I had a feeling you'd be in one of the very small minority who would actually benefit from using a tablet PC. I don't argue that they have a benefit in certain situations but most people will never be in those situations.
As far as journalism goes, wouldn't you just love native recording capabilities in your iPod, Mike?
-Dan
Posted by: Dan at November 19, 2004 07:37 PMDan,
I agree that Tablet PC format still needs streamling and improvement (weight, size, etc), it's still for a smaller group of people. Probably why Apple hasn't made one for "the rest of us".
Then again, someone probably argued "why would you want to lug a computer around" when the first heavy and expensive laptops first came out.
Steven
Posted by: Steven L at November 19, 2004 08:30 PMPoint taken Steven but the idea of a portable computer was a pretty radical departure compared to the tablet. The major benefit to using a tablet is that it's possible to use while standing. I just don't see that being tremendously alluring to the average person.
-Dan
Posted by: Dan at November 21, 2004 01:14 PMI am a Mac user and have a current 17" PowerBook. I also had purchased a Fujitsu 4120 when they first appeared on the market. As a primary Mac person, running Windows proved to be a problem, especially in a Mac environement. I have configured Cisco routers, and for the life of me, was unable to secure Windows over the multiple connnections used—cell card, wireless, ethernet... The tablets attract me like a moth, and I am actually trying to not buy another Fujitsu (5000), but I truly wish that Apple would make a dockable tablet of some hi-power sort. In my view, the tablets and pens are for away tasks—notes, sketches—and the keyboard and mouse, with the addition of a pen are for base tasks—refining sketches, typing related. Ultimately, I expect tablets to function in the mac environment like a processor node, not as a primary machine—think clusters—where directories are shared, processing power is distributed, and networking is transitional. Windows is not suited to this environment in the near term.
They are cool machines, but Windows is very much a drag on the concept. My favorite applications were Tablet Planner, and Alias Sketchbook Pro. The most frequently used applications are/were communications related—email, web—and design tools—Macromedia, Adobe—are used intermittently. Thanks.
Posted by: Nicholas Paredes at November 23, 2004 12:00 PM
Mike, You were right in your first assessment of the tablet pc. They, like Cellphones, Blackberrys & PDA's, these devices might have some limited value to certin applications, but in the end, most people want them to be-all, do-all and the manufactures sell them as such. Reliability? Just about everyone i know who HAD one, had it in for service for one reason or another..... And for the price I could get 2 i-book G4's. Same weight, more power. One for home and one for the road (or a i-book and a emac).
Posted by: Chris at November 18, 2004 08:50 AM