« Dejavu: Windows frustration | Main | PayPal now good for iTMS »

December 10, 2004

Now I'm too pro-Apple

You can't win for trying. Last week, Apple people were all over me for being too kind to Microsoft. Now, from somebody named Moshie, comes this:
Apple suck up" because that's all you do. Way to be objective there Mikey. Way to do your job properly. Apple this, Apple that, well, why don't you talk about Apple's incompatibility? Why don't you talk about how EVERY PART in an Apple machine comes from Apple. Do you think that's a "GOOD" thing? You are so paid off it's sick...your time has LONG past. -Moshie
Sigh.
in Apple | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Well, Mike, you're going to get flak from both sides, no matter what you do/write/think/say... You're one of the few in tech-media who seriously use both platforms, and personally I think you usually have a more balanced view than most about Mac versus PC. I am a Mac-person myself, but I teach MIS and it's a very PC-heavy world so I use Wintel-stuff every day.

//Magnus

Posted by: Magnus at December 10, 2004 10:15 AM

Mike,

well Moshie could at least get his facts right!

"EVERY PART in an Apple machine comes from Apple" - err, no: ATI graphics adaptors; Hitachi/IBM et al hard drives; Pioneer DVD+R drives. The list could go on, but you get the idea.

"Apple's incompatibility" - that's a laugh! Macs network with anything out there: Netware, Windows servers, NFS on Unix etc etc. Programs? Plenty of cross-platform ones, or ones that use common file formats. For everything else, there's VPC.

I think the guy needs to stop being a Gates fanboy and have a dose of modern Mac reality :)

Keep up the good work, Mike!

Posted by: Tim at December 10, 2004 11:03 AM

Well did you answer the guy? Incompatability...Like what for instance. MS Office on the Mac works with MS Office on the PC or at least they can exchange files with ease. Same for a great many programs. Then there is Virtual PC. However granted there is stil some compatability issues I will grant however I'm not sure it's all that big and issue to most. Then the parts things. one can put hard drives into their system NOT from Apple, and in many models cases video cards and other PCI devices. Memory does not have to come from Apple and I often reccomend to my friends that they DO NOT purchase from Apple when it comes to memory..too costly. Now again while NOT being able to build one's own Mac not upgrade it in terms of swapping out the logic board and or proccesor is annying to a sub-set of users...stil for the vast majority of users this is not an issue

Myself I would have like to have heard this fellow flush out his complaints in greater detail. Perhaps he is unaware of the Mac's progress over the years in both the compatability and parts area's. After all there was a time long ago that Mac's did NOT use standard memory or hard drives and thier expansion porst and slots where also not standard..that has changed however.

Pagan jim

Posted by: Laff at December 10, 2004 11:06 AM

Like Magnus, I too work in a Windows environment-- the XP lab I inherited with this teaching job. I have HAD to learn more about XP than I have ever HAD to learn about all my Macs.

I may not accept a contract for next year, because I am so sick of all my spare time being used up trying to get and keep this lab of two year old Compaqs to work properly, and I am the only one. I pity my successor.

I think that Mac users in general know a lot more about Windows than Windows users know about Macs-- and that alone makes me trust your opinion a lot more than Windows-only journalists. You're in the trenches with us, Mike.

Posted by: ToeKnee at December 10, 2004 11:21 AM

Well, you absolutely *are* an Apple suckup, so what's the point in even mentioning it? It's pretty freaking obvious.

Posted by: Donut at December 10, 2004 12:14 PM

it's pretty freaking obvious that Mr. Donut doesn't know Mike's history - how he was known as "PC Mike" until about two years ago, if anything, more of a MS suckup. http://pcmike.com now re-directs to this journal.

The posts about Mike's recent 'affair' with the tablet PC was anything but an Apple suckup event. You notice he bought one after his initial eval went so well.

Apple suckup indeed... you anti-Apple people seem to recognize just two states: Apple-hater or Apple lover extremist, which in the case of a journalist becomes "suckup." Well, most of us are in the middle somewhere, somewhat increasingly leaning towards Apple. Try it, you might see why.

Posted by: ToeKnee at December 10, 2004 12:27 PM

Isn't it interesting that there is an established pattern that those who decide to take the plunge and 'get into Macs' suddenly are quite supportive of the platform?

I wonder why..?

Posted by: Patrick at December 10, 2004 02:09 PM

Yep, most mac users are familiar to very familar with PC's and have made a choice based on actual evidence and usage. 99% of Windows users have just seen an unplugged Mac at CompUSA or since they buy PC's on specs alone - just read the specs on the Mac and think they know it all. Ignorant will only get you so far in life - ignorant and proud of it is another matter :-)

Posted by: jbelkin at December 10, 2004 04:02 PM

I'm a Microsoft-certified IT consultant who manages Windows networks for clients, and I do a bit of Mac support as well. In my experience, people who only know Windows are afraid of the Mac, and I try not to be too condescending when I plug my Mac into their infection-ravaged Windows network to bring worms under control. I'm typing this on an iBook G4 that's wirelessly connected via RDP into a Windows domain controller, through which I can manage and administer a fleet of PCs remotely. As for the ignoramuses who accuse you of being an Apple suckup, they would make fine candidates for retroactive birth control.

Posted by: Bias Alert at December 10, 2004 08:56 PM

Hi Mike,

You know what? I don't know about you but I'm sick of this "my platform is better than your platform crap", whether it's Windows, Linux, Mac, BSD, Amiga, Atari, XBox, Playstation 2, BeOS, PocketPC, Newton or Palm.

Everyone has their own opinions of what "the best" platform is. If you're comfortable switching between OS X and Windows XP Tablet Edition in the same week, then more power to you. If it makes you happy and more productive, then who am I to complain?

Personally, I've run OS X, Linux and XP - and switch between them when I need to. My preference is OS X for a number of technical reasons - but I realize that other people are entitled to run whatever they want.

I appreciate that you take the time to share your experiences on each platform with us. When you cover a platform that I don't normally use, I take it as an opportunity to learn something new.

Thanks again,
- Mike K.

Posted by: Mike K. at December 11, 2004 02:53 AM

It's one thing to be ignorant but quiet another to wish to share that view with the world.

Guys like this will never learn since they have already made up their minds (such as they are).

Their are things to like and dislike about both platforms. But to dismiss one with blanket statements that are not even correct, then the only thing that needs to be dismissed from consideration is anything this guy has to say.

Put simply: He's an idiot.

Posted by: Paul R at December 11, 2004 10:52 AM

AutoDesk.

I'll be upgrading to a G5 soon, and upgrading my Virtual PC as well. But does anyone have any experience working with any of the AutoDesk apps in that environment?

Especially AutoCAD 2004 and Electrical. (Don't bother pointing me to TurboCAD, etc. It's my company's decision, not mine.)

That's my main compatability issue, which won't stop my personal machine from being a Mac.

Posted by: Anita P. at December 13, 2004 09:42 PM

I switched within the same month that Mike did in December of 2002. I've found that the time I spent fighting spam, blue screens and viruses has been substituted with some really creative computing. I've done a bunch of personal home movies, web sites, and even got a magazine advertisement published for another company just for the heck of it. None of these things I ever wanted to attempt on a PC because I just didn't enjoy spending the time with them. I was too exhausted from being the PC tech support for all of my friends and family.

I'm so much more 'relaxed' now that I made the switch!

Kent W.

Posted by: Kent W. at December 14, 2004 02:31 PM

Post a comment




Remember me?


Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits