« Phishing gets more insidious | Main | Microsoft adds a blogging service »

December 01, 2004

Voice Speech recognition is no substitute for mouse and keyboard

I've had lots of e-mail from readers since I wrote about the very proficient SR technology built into my new Tablet PC. I described how, at breakfast, I eat my cereal and say things like "Go to Free Press" to open Freep.com. "Scroll down" moves the page down. "Open Outlook" brings up my e-mail.
That's cool and fun and allows hands free use while spooning in the shredded wheat. But that's only a limited use. I don't want readers to get the impression that I'm using speech exclusively.
I dictated the top few graphs of my column with SR and the software that came with my Tablet and it did an astounding job. But it still took longer to say it than write it. For me, writing is a tactile exercise, not verbal.
Many of those who e-mailed me want to know SR is reliable enough to be used as the main way to input text.
While the technology has dramatically improved since the last time I experimented with it, I just don't see it replacing a mouse and keyboard. You need to master all the voice commands, be prepared for background noise to sometimes drown out you words and be patient with the inevitable lag between your voice command and the opening and closing and execution of files and programs. A keyboard and a mouse or stylus is just a lot quicker.
And when I write, I need to see the words and then tinker with them, rearrange them, rewrite them. With SR, that's awkward.
Maybe that's me and the way I'm used to doing things. But for the average user, I'd never recommend buying a machine just for its SR capabilities.
It's nice but, truthfully, more of a novelty than necessity.


in Cool Gizmos and Gadgets | TrackBack (0)

Comments

it would be nice if people used the correct terminology. recognizing your voice and understanding verbal commands are 2 entirely different things.

voice recognition is a form of biometric authentication. speech recognition is a system for controling a computer with verbal commands

Posted by: kurt at December 1, 2004 12:20 PM

Right you are Phil... thanks for the clarification!

Posted by: Mike Wendland at December 1, 2004 12:32 PM

Post a comment




Remember me?


Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits