« Phisher fraud targets cable customers | Main | New Tablet PC »

November 20, 2004

My Honey Pot catches first spam harvester

It's been a week since I installed a hidden software trap for those who illegally harvest Web sites for e-mail addresses that are then used by spammers.
Here's the original post describing it, part of Project Honey Pot, an ambitious new weapon in the war against spam spearheaded by Matt Prince, CEO of an anti-spam organization called Unspam and an adjunct law professor at Chicago's John Marshal Law School.
Prince tells me my first harvester visited from the IP address: 69.6.66.17. Here's the page that describes the harvester visit and its details.
It happened Tuesday, at 7:02 pm. The harvester moved through my site, looking for e-mail addresses. That's where the Honey Pot came in. It gave the harvester a control address that Prince set up. When spam is received at that address, it links directly back to the harvester.
Whoever is doing the harvesting at this site appears to be running the software on a machine in New Jersey on a connection provided by Comcast. You can find the whois information on the IP here.
Prince says it could be that this is a compromised zombie machine. But the fact that the same IP has acted as a harvester over a 3 week period - he's recorded visits from that IP address to other Project Honey Pot sites - makes him suspicious that there's a real user behind that Comcast connection who is doing the harvesting. It's worth noting that this IP is not listed in most of the big spammer-tracking databases and doesn't appear to be sending ANY spam itself. For example, Spamhaus, SenderBase or dnsstuff.
More evidence that the harvester is not a zombie machine comes from the fact that it is associated with a single mail server (69.6.66.17). Details on that mail server can be found here:
It looks like the spam messages being sent regard a tax deduction scheme involving donated cars and a prescription drug seller.
Here's where it gets interesting.
Unlike the harvester, there's lots of information about the outfit behind the spam. The whois information points to an Illinois-based direct marketing company, Expedite Marketing Corporation.
Expedite has a reputation and, in fact, is alleged to be working with Scott Richter and a number of other high-profile spammers.
However, their corporate presence makes them out to be a legitimate direct email marketer, honoring opt-outs, complying with CAN-SPAM, and, of course, not harvesting. More information is available on the company's website.
According to their site, they do marketing for a major Chicago-area car dealer and a local bank, Prince wonders what the reaction would from their legitimate customers if they knew of some of the other sites of the business. For example, run off the same server, Expedite also hosts Xxxpedite, Adultdesignwebsite and Adult-design-website.
There's also evidence, from the other sites they run, of their very active interest in collecting e-mail addresses - Expedite-email-collector, Buy-email-list and Bulkemailbroadcasting.
Just by sending to a harvested email address Expedite could be violating the law, says Prince. Here is information on the Federal CAN-SPAM Act's prohibitions on harvesting.
I'll follow up as we identify more of these harvesters.
WIth more than 1,000 sites now working with Project Honey Pot, this promises to be an interesting weapon in the fight against spammers. So far, harvesters have grabbed 1,986 Honey Pot e-mail addresses from the participating sites. Seventy-four of those control addresses have already received spam messages. That's led to the identification of 25 harvesters and 51 different spam servers.
Not bad for a start.
You can learn more about Project Honey Pot here.


in Spam | TrackBack (0)

Comments

When I'm doin spam research, my favorite site is SamSpade.org:

http://www.samspade.org/t/lookat?a=69.6.66.17

Pretty amazing set of tools to help track these guys down. Or at least its makes you feel like your tracking them... :)

Take a look at the tools, you won't be disappointed.

Posted by: Kevin at November 20, 2004 09:40 AM

That's nothing.

One of my honeypot email addresses has received several trojan horse messages from the spamhausen.

Posted by: w.h. at November 21, 2004 03:08 AM

Brilliant work. Please continue your relentless hunt of those American spammer cunts.

Posted by: Emm at November 21, 2004 04:46 AM

Would this hold up as incriminating evidence in court, or at least as reason to persecute?

Posted by: KJH at November 21, 2004 04:58 AM

... ummm, reason __prosecute__ maybe? ;)

Posted by: BGJ at November 21, 2004 06:27 AM

Cool, but this deals with the weakest part of CAN-SPAM: "Machine harvested addresses".

Spammer in court: "I swear to you judge, I harvested every address I spam to by hand". "Oh? Why yes, I look at ever page's source code, yep, sure do!"

What? A spammer lying under oath? Well of course, there's yet to be a trial where a spammer has not perjured himself. Sadly, most judges are still figuring out this new "telephone device", and the internet is like magic from the future, they have no idea how it works and who's lying.

Good luck though, at worst this may help fix the law.

Posted by: Anonymousme at November 21, 2004 07:10 AM

Good work, Mike. I'm glad you made the connection to Richter, however I believe you need to spend more time exposing the upstream from Expedite Marketing, the entity known as Wholesale Bandwidth. Wholesale Bandwidth is believed to be one of the few ISPs still providing a connection to Richter and is likely run by a very spammy group of individuals itself. Being located in Adrian, it should be an easy task to take a drive out and ask a few pointed questions. I've thought of doing the same but after making my trek out to AlRal's place two Xmas's ago, I've decided it's probably a better idea to keep my distance.

Posted by: Rich Clark at November 21, 2004 08:00 AM

Oh, this link may also prove interesting, the corporate records from the secretary of state of IL on Expedite:

http://www.cyberdriveillinois.com/CorpSearchWeb/CorporationSearchServlet?fileNumber=62015373&sysId=CD&nameType=MST

Posted by: Rich Clark at November 21, 2004 08:13 AM

It's widely known, for various degrees of certainty, that Wholesale Bandwidth IS Scott Richter. If so, Mike just caught Mr. Richter violating the CAN-SPAM act despite him agreeing to not do so with NY Attorney General. This could land Richter in a whole lot of trouble, if pursued till the end.

Posted by: wholesale bandwidth at November 21, 2004 10:53 AM

I tried to sign up to Operation Honeypot but none of the three browsers I used would let me sign on. So I ran the page through a validator (http://validator.w3.org) and got about a dozen errors. Also, I was going to point out to them that their CAPTCHA images can be stolen. Now I know my browsers suck, but due to the validation errors I don't really know if it's a page bug stopping me gettting on, or a browser deficiency. And no, Firefox don't work on my platform. Nor does IE, Mozilla or Netscape.

Posted by: Simon Smith at November 21, 2004 04:52 PM

I tried to sign up to Operation Honeypot but none of the three browsers I used would let me sign on. So I ran the page through a validator (http://validator.w3.org) and got about a dozen errors. Also, I was going to point out to them that their CAPTCHA images can be stolen. Now I know my browsers suck, but due to the validation errors I don't really know if it's a page bug stopping me gettting on, or a browser deficiency. And no, Firefox don't work on my platform. Nor does IE, Mozilla or Netscape.

Posted by: Simon Smith at November 21, 2004 04:52 PM

I tried to sign up to Operation Honeypot but none of the three browsers I used would let me sign on. So I ran the page through a validator (http://validator.w3.org) and got about a dozen errors. Also, I was going to point out to them that their CAPTCHA images can be stolen. Now I know my browsers suck, but due to the validation errors I don't really know if it's a page bug stopping me gettting on, or a browser deficiency. And no, Firefox don't work on my platform. Nor does IE, Mozilla or Netscape.

Posted by: Simon Smith at November 21, 2004 04:55 PM

I tried to sign up to Operation Honeypot but none of the three browsers I used would let me sign on. So I ran the page through a validator (http://validator.w3.org) and got about a dozen errors. Also, I was going to point out to them that their CAPTCHA images can be stolen. Now I know my browsers suck, but due to the validation errors I don't really know if it's a page bug stopping me gettting on, or a browser deficiency. And no, Firefox don't work on my platform. Nor does IE, Mozilla or Netscape.

Posted by: Simon Smith at November 21, 2004 04:56 PM

Maybe that's because your browser sends posted forms several times posted forms several times posted forms several times posted forms several times.

Posted by: John Q Person at November 21, 2004 05:06 PM

Keep up the good work... We spend so much money on stopping spam, let's take the fight to them

Posted by: phoric at November 21, 2004 08:07 PM

Thanks for getting the honeypot service in front of a lot more eyeballs. Had you not written this up on your blog, and had it not been picked up on SlashDot, I wouldn't have heard about it yet.

Right now I'm in the process of donating some MX's from one of my domains to use in honeypots.

Thanks again!

Posted by: Tomas at November 21, 2004 09:19 PM

Actually yes, Expedite, Wholesale Bandwidth, and ALL of that block are owned by Scott Richter. optinrealbig.com. I have been tracking him for months bc of the harvested addresses from my sites.

List of Phone numbers:
OptinRealBig.com: (303) 464-8164
Richter's Extention is: 742
Scott Richter's Cell phone number: 1.303.550.9828

Posted by: Richter Hater at November 21, 2004 10:30 PM

Another one of Expidite's legit "e-mail / fax" operations is in the Detroit Metro area (southfield, MI) Adval.com which runs messageconnex.com and several other domains. Thought it'd be a nice touch to drop that one there to you Mike.

Posted by: Anonymous at November 22, 2004 11:10 AM

The kind folks at 69.6.66.0/24 are also performing dictionary attacks against mail servers. I've gotten over a hundred probes with local-part addresses of the form three letters, three digits, like [email protected]. I have preserved the logs and filed a complaint with the FTC, for whatever good that will do. (Go to http://www.ftc.gov and click "file a complaint" in the upper nav bar.)

Posted by: Bob Brown at November 30, 2004 03:11 PM

Probably just as well for Mark's christ blood pressure that American Idol isn't tattoo being shown in the UK. What is it with bible this absolute obsession with correct bible pitch? I'm fairly sensitive to things jerusalem being sung out of tune myself, but honestly, jesus some of the stuff that Randy Jackson holly

Posted by: cross at December 3, 2004 08:24 AM

Not only is WholesaleBandwidth owned Scott Richter but I had reported dozens of spam complaints to [email protected] and guess what happened?

Nothing: I was NOT removed from their spam list.

Another violation of the CAN SPAM act and something he agreed to uphold in his settlement with the NY Attorney General.

I just sent these details to the NY Attorney General's Office.

Posted by: Steve at December 3, 2004 03:06 PM

I like pie!

Posted by: Me at January 14, 2005 05:14 PM

another great tool is the linux search at http://www.alllinuxinfo.com

Posted by: Linux Search at January 15, 2005 12:43 PM

Assuming that Expedite Media Corporation is the same as Expedite Media Group ... which I think they are ... they're responsible for sending large quantities of stock spam. The SEC ([email protected]) might be interested in hearing anything you could tell them about the identities of those behind that particular operation.

Posted by: Woody at January 19, 2005 11:23 PM

http://pole.kulu-best.com/9pkraiajr/ glancepuppyrotation

Posted by: ont at August 7, 2005 11:35 AM

Post a comment




Remember me?


Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits