
Has Google gotten too big for its virtual britches?
That's my question in today's Free Press column.
Besides its amazingly fast and relevant search engine -- which now searches for books, news, images and products as well as Web sites -- its subtle little AdSense text ads are ubiquitous on the Net.
And now, thanks to a new downloadable Desktop Search tool, it can search everything on your computer's hard drive, too, keeping a copy of every file, every e-mail and even every America Online instant message conversation you've ever had -- even if you delete or erase them.
Google clearly has no illusions of grandeur. It really is the single biggest and most influential player in cyberspace.
But it is not the only one. And as Google has gotten bigger and better, so have some of its rivals. One of them, Microsoft, is getting very close to releasing its own answer to Google.
Microsoft was going to give a not-for-publication briefing to tech journalists this week. An apologetic public relations contact, though, called Monday to say the demonstration had to be indefinitely postponed because the product, alas, needed further testing.
It isn't easy trying to be a Google-killer.
While we have to wait to see what Microsoft will bring to the search wars, continue reading for some Google alternatives that offer some interesting new takes on searching.
In my column in the Free Press, I forgot to mention Clusty (http://clusty.com)... one of the absolute coolest search sites ever. I have no idea how I forgot this but of all the ones I list below, Clusty is the closest one I've found to out-Googling Google.
Here's the sites from my column:
Yahoo (http://search.yahoo.com) Note the URL carefully. The familiar www.yahoo.com address still returns the crowded Web directory you may be familiar with. But the search.yahoo.com address is clean, crisp and streamlined. It's also constantly improving with features like local and personalized searching developed after Yahoo bought Inktomi this year and launched its own search technology.
Teoma (www.teoma.com) This very speedy search crawler site indexes fewer sites than Google or Yahoo, but fans praise it for consistently returning very relevant results. It has the familiar list of links, but then, off to the right, suggests ways to refine the search to drill down and look for more specific information arranged by topics.
AllTheWeb (www.alltheweb.com) I use this site, owned by a Yahoo subsidiary, probably once a day. It is really, really fast. Besides the general Web tab that looks at all Web sites, tabs for news, pictures, video and audio bring specialized information. Parents will like a content filter that greatly reduces listings from adult and sex-related sites.
Vivisimo (www.vivisimo.com): If you're searching for a term that brings back hundreds of links, this site automatically clusters the results by categories. Search "Detroit Lions," for example, and you'll get a list of 216 links organized into topics like NFL, tickets, fans, coach, statistics and so on. Click on a category and there are subfolders like injuries, roster, scores and news. Very cool.
SurfWax (www.surfwax.com This site brings results from lots of different search engines. A little magnifying glass icon opens a window that previews the page in which your search term appears so you can quickly see it in context and determine whether it's the information you want.
KartOO (www.kartoo.com):This UK-based site is what's known as a metasearch site, meaning it uses several different search engines to find your material. Its specialty is organizing the results visually, representing the material in a series of interconnected folders, maps and icons. I find it interesting but confusing. It's illustrative of a lot of research in searching that tries to link sites by connections, but it's not quite as user friendly as it needs to be.
One more resource is Danny Sullivan's http://searchenginewatch.com. Sullivan is probably the world's leading expert on search technology, and whenever a new search service emerges, his site quickly explains its best and worst features.
Sullivan's site has identified nearly 100 major search engines. As promising as some of them may be, the fact is that after using them all, I grudgingly have to say that Google remains my first choice in searching.
Google may be big and getting ominously bigger. But it's still the best.
Thank you so much for looking for alternatives to Google. As a student I never really liked using Google because I had to filter through many pages to find just what I needed. It's good to know that there are searches that will put the information into categories. Again, thank you!
Posted by: Danielle at November 2, 2004 11:14 PM