« Paper and pen approach is sometimes the best | Main | Interoperable communication woes for first responders »

September 09, 2004

Bloggers question credibility of CBS 60 Minute report

NEW NEW
CBS and Dan Rather, contrary to Drudge and the bloggers, stands by the documents and insists they are authentic.
RatherLogoYou gotta love The Comedian for quickly coming up with the logo at the right.
NEW
The AP, various newspapers and other networks are now pretty much repeating what the bloggers first reported. Drudge claims CBS is launching an internal investigation and that Dan Rather is "privately 'shell-shocked' by the increasing likelihood that the documents in question were fraudulent."
Initial post
It appears that CBS and 60 Minutes were seriously snookered on its big story this week questioning President Bush's National Guard service. Seems the documents they show were forged, claim a bunch of blogs like Power Line, which notes that:

...every single one of the memos to file regarding Bush's failure to attend a physical and meet other requirements is in a proportionally spaced font, probably Palatino or Times New Roman. In 1972 people used typewriters for this sort of thing (especially in the military), and typewriters used mono-spaced fonts
The use of proportionally spaced fonts did not come into common use for office memos until the introduction high-end word processing systems from Xerox and Wang, and later of laser printers, word processing software, and personal computers. They were not widespread until the mid to late 90's. Before then, you needed typesetting equipment, and that wasn't used for personal memos to file. Even the Wang and other systems that were dominant in the mid 80's used mono-spaced fonts. I doubt the TANG had typesetting or high-end 1st generation word processing systems... these documents are forgeries, run through a copier for 15 generations to make them look old. This should be pursued aggressively.
Indeed it is.
Other bloggers and Web journalists are all over this today, digging into the issue of what fonts were and were not in use back then. Traditional media doesn't seem to be picking this up as of yet.
Sites like Heroes from the Past and INDC Journal and RatherBiased and the Cybercast News Service are hammering away. Even Drudge has started to pick up on the Web stories.
CBS, meanwhile, apparently is standing by the story. It still claims in its Web version of the story that it "consulted a handwriting analyst and document expert who believes the material is authentic."
You got to you love it: Bloggers holding big media accountable.
But are they right? Or are the documents indeed real?
If the bloggers are right, it marks a whole new credibility phase of this blogging phenomenon that has been dubbed citizen journalism. But if they've been naively taken in, you can bet old media will breathe a big sigh of relief and feel vindicated that amateur fact checking hasn't bested their pros.


in Blogging | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I have no idea whether they're legit or not, but the "proportional spaced fonts" argument doesn't wash--that's been available since 1941:

http://www-1.ibm.com/ibm/history/history/year_1941.html

Next?

Posted by: Charles Gaba at September 9, 2004 06:09 PM

Hey Mike...ABCNEWS.com is digging in to it. They've even spoken to the widow of the officer who reportedly wrote the "memos". Interesting!

http://abcnews.go.com/sections/Politics/Vote2004/bush_documents_040909-1.html

Posted by: Kevin C. at September 10, 2004 12:19 AM

While I realize that credibility is an extremely important trait for leaders, I find it somewhere between incredible and absurd that so much emphasis is being placed, with regard to the ELECTION OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, on what did or did not happen over 30 years ago in the waterways of Vietnam or the Texas and Alabama National Guard.

Posted by: Mr Attitude at September 10, 2004 12:56 AM

Looks to me that those "pros" are pretty sloppy....

Posted by: Keith at September 10, 2004 12:24 PM

CBS had the original memos examined by pros who called them authentic. The bloggers in question (and the "experts" quoted in various articles) have been looking at pdf files, and questioning the legitimacy of the memos based on, essentially, photocopies.

Typewriters strike the paper, causing indentation. They also sometimes have letters above or below the baseline. It doesn't take a genius to tell whether a document was typed on a typewriter or printed on an ink jet or laser printer! One would think any document expert would have noticed a lack of indentation right away.

Any half-way competent typist (which I was during the 70s) could easily center a title; it was a Typing 101 level skill.

Also, "th" superscript keys were common on military (and other) typewriters of the time--or else all the documents that the Bush administration produced so far are also forgeries. Look at other TANG documents; "th" superscripts are ocmmon. (For more on military typewriters of the era, see Daily Kos).

And, for crying out loud, the man's widow is now the final source on memos he may or may not have typed at the office 30 years ago?

Posted by: michigander at September 10, 2004 02:52 PM

Here's a link to the file Michigander mentioned. It was released by the White House yet still bears the oh-so-suspicious superscript "th".

http://users.cis.net/coldfeet/doc10.gif

Posted by: Essfegy at September 10, 2004 03:43 PM

ABout focusing on events 30 years ago - this is a common tactic to prevent media and people from focusing on present day problems and even worse ( for the pols ) the future.

The less the public knows that there is a 37.7 Trillion dollar total debt of which roughly half is owed to foriegners, the better they like it.

Posted by: Tim West at September 10, 2004 05:41 PM

Actually, if you bother to check, the national debt is only about 7.3 trillion but that is still too much. And if we owe it to other countries, who do we owe and how much? And how does that balance against what we have done for them? If the debt is owed to the American people, why do I get taxed to pay it down? If the government owes us money, I forgive my portion of the debt if they will stop taxing me.

But my guess is that all politicians lie, so there it is.....

Posted by: Peter Trast at September 14, 2004 04:30 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits