
Okay forgive me if I'm being dense here but if I'm reading this properly Apple is providing access to (if not actually supporting) software that allows users to convert songs from wma format to something Mac friendly. Why then all the hoo hah over RealNetworks' Harmony? Are RealAudio files not considered wma format (I don't pretend to be particularly knowledgeable in this area)? And even if they aren't, what's the difference between what RealNetworks is providing and what Apple is (implicitly) providing? Understand, I'm no fan of RealAudio but I'm thinking of buying a seat on the bandwagon that's becoming increasingly critical of Apple on this matter.
Somebody "'splain" it to me.
BTW, Real's store actually uses AAC. But yes, the difference is DRM. Apple is just adding WMA to the list of non-DRM formats they support (along with AAC, AIFF, WAV, and ALE).
Posted by: lavar78 at August 3, 2004 12:11 PM[Note - You have a few spam posts on the blog, July 11 thru 14. All dated 21 July 04] Tnx
Posted by: Tracer at August 3, 2004 12:13 PMApple is upset that Real has apparently reverse-engineered FairPlay, their DRM format. EasyWMA simply converts unprotected WMA files to MP3 -- sort of like iTunes can convert MP3 to AAC and back.
Posted by: MD at August 3, 2004 01:19 PMWorth mentioning too that EasyWMA is not an Apple product, they are merely linking to it on their "third party downloads" page. And they state: "Apple is providing links to these applications as a courtesy, and makes no representations regarding the applications or any information related thereto. Any questions, complaints or claims regarding the applications must be directed to the appropriate software vendor."
But that said, these are non-DRM'ed WMA files. And iTunes for Windows can do the same thing, converting non-DRM'ed WMA files to AAC files (for iPod compatibility.)
Posted by: Josh at August 3, 2004 02:30 PMThanks to all for the quick lesson in music formatting. And yeah I did pick up on the fact that easywma isn't an Apple product. It still seems a bit shortsighted to me that Apple is upset that Real "hacked" they're software. Allowing third parties (including customers) to play with the product is a longstanding practice. It makes the product more attractive. Else The Big Three would have sued every shade tree mechanic that ever tried to get a couple of extra horses fiddling with their powerplants. (I'm sure now that someone will post and say they did)
Posted by: Barry at August 3, 2004 02:39 PMYou have to read the fine gray print below the download. I'll darken it here.
Apple is providing links to these applications as a courtesy, and makes no representations regarding the applications or any information related thereto. Any questions, complaints or claims regarding the applications must be directed to the appropriate software vendor.
Posted by: Bill Carver at August 3, 2004 03:10 PMI think the point that everyone kinda glossed over is the fact that Real is taking away from the iTMS revenue. Currently only the iPod works with iTMS (one of the ways they can afford to actually keep the store running (sales of the ipod)) and because the record industry has Apple's nuts in a vice on the agreements of the iTMS sales, any kind of cut into their sales of songs on the store is going to be a big deal. That's the main reason Apple is pissed, it has nothing at all to do with format, and a little to do with DRM.
Posted by: James Cigler at August 3, 2004 08:30 PMMaybe I'M being dense, but I don't understand why anyone is being critical of Apple here. They sell one of the - if not the - most open player on the market. It supports more formats then all or most others. The only catch is that if you want to play copy-protected tunes on your iPod, you have to buy them from Apple.
If you have a large collection of music copy protected by another system, don't buy an iPod. If you buy an iPod and want to purchase songs online, shop at iTunes. If you are competing against the iTunes Store, give potential buyers a good reason why they should shop at your store and use another player other then the iPod.
Posted by: mgseeley at August 3, 2004 10:47 PM
Taking in WMAs is not directly the problem. The problem is that apple won't take in any DRM-protected material from anywhere but the iTunes store. That program they link to won't touch DRM-encoded items (follow link to creator's page and read the FAQ). So, you still can't take in any content from Real, or Napster, or Wal-Mart's music store, etc., etc., etc.
Posted by: zoocat at August 3, 2004 11:55 AM