« Visual Music Search Engine | Main | YouManInIndia: Outsourcing Parental Care »

August 02, 2004

Orange pixel splotch on Treo 600

IMGP0167Two weeks after I received a replacement Treo 600 from Sprint, it has suddenly developed a splotch of orange pixels on the screen. They are growing a little more each day.
I've seen similar complaints on some of the Treo/smartphone discussion forums but no solution.
Two bad units in nine month's time is making me wonder about the reliability of this phone.


in Mobile lifestyle | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I've read mixed things about the Treos in numerous forums (including mytreo, sprintusers, sprintpcsinfo, wirelessadvisor,treocentral, just to name a few). It seems that there are several common problems.

There was a large batch of units that develop the dreaded Network Search error. Apparently this is a hardware issue and someone actually got the range of ESN's that had this glitch.

There also seems to be an issue where the speakerphone goes bad after awhile. From what I have gathered, this is an engineering problem that can potentially effect all models. Word has it that the speakerphone is not soldered to the PCB.. rather it is held in place (and in contact with the PCB) via springs. Not a wide decision, IMHO.

The third I hear about is the orange splotches. No one seems to have any conclusions as to how or why this occurs. It seems far less common than the two aforementioned problems, but ALL of these are a conern to me as I just bought a Treo 600 2.5 weeks ago.

Thus far, my unit has been fine (knock on wood).. but I have 1.5 more weeks to decide if I want to keep it or not.

The Treo 610 is tempting, but I have a feeling that we won't see it released until Mid-October at best. And chances are that it will be tough to get due to the fact that volume buyers (i.e. large companies) typically get first dibs.. combined with the approaching holiday season.

My biggest gripe with the Treo is that the speakerphone isn't loud enough. I would go with a "normal" phone (i'm with Sprint BTW), but all the Sprint speakerphones, while nice and loud, are only half-duplex...

Posted by: Mike at August 2, 2004 04:20 PM

I have Sprint PCS Vision and a Samsung VGA1000 phone (not too useful for web browsing), but am trying something out... I just bought a refurbished Dell Axim X5 Advanced Pocket PC from its online outlet store for $150. It has MS Pocket PC 2003, speedy 400 MHZ processor, 64 MB RAM/48 MB ROM, and (here's the reason I bought it) slots for both a SD card and Type II CF card. This way, I can get Sprint's wireless Internet access at 50 to 70 Kbps, peak of 144 Kbps, from anywhere within its digital network with a PCS connection card (although the card -- details at http://www.sprint.com/pcsbusiness/devices/wireless_cards/cf2031.html -- and data plans are rather pricy). Since I'm about to try this beginning tonight, if I find Sprint's access is not working out well, I can still get Wi-Fi at hotspots if I wish with a Sandisk SD Wi-Fi card. The total cost comes to about the same as a Treo at full price (can't switch at the discounted price anyway since I'm less than 15 months in). The Axim X30 is even better if you want a smaller device and Wi-Fi/Bluetooth (it doesn't have the Type II CF slot, so no cell-provider wireless service on this one, yet). Both the X5 and X30 have received good reviews. The only cons I see with the X5 are it's a larger device and I still have to use the VGA 1000 for calls.

Posted by: Bill Young at August 2, 2004 07:05 PM

Hey Mike. I finally recieved my second replacement Treo 600 (GSM) because my last one would hard crash (battery disconnect reset) on average of 2 times a day. The phone I just received not only does not crash, but it also gets better reception as well as has a better camera. It works much better in low light. I would say keep trying and you will get a good one.

Posted by: James Cigler at August 2, 2004 09:06 PM

Why should you have to "keep trying" when you're paying that kind of money. For people like me that want gadgets but can't go out and buy the next "cool thing", forking out that kind of cash seems silly against not having it all the time due to you having to return it.

Posted by: Ray J. Bilyk at August 3, 2004 08:51 AM

Got a new one - my third in 10 months. Working well so far.
I'm sure glad I bought the insurance.

Posted by: Mike Wendland at August 7, 2004 11:13 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits