« Comcast goes with DVR | Main | Spammers try to capitalize on high cost of gas »

May 26, 2004

Wireless confusion

The competing standards and formats used in the U.S. by wireless phone providers is confusing enough to give the best-versed geek a headache.
It's all about speed... making mobile phones have the connectivity that consumers are used to with broadband services at home and work.
We're not there yet, but U.S. wireless companies are getting closer all the time. What we need, though, is a standard - a single platform that everyone will settle on, like VHS video tapes won out over beta.
GSM, CDMA, 1XRTT, 1X EV-DO, EDGE technologies create not just acronym gibberish but limit development of that near-broadband efficiency consumers need and deserve.
The Daily Wireless is a blog that I check frequently to keep up on wireless developments. Today's lead piece called Cellular at the Races does an excellent job chronicling the confusion.


in Mobile lifestyle | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Mike,

These competing standards can be confusing.. but remember, most are bound to fail.

Some have advantages over others, but a "universal" cellphone standard is not necessarily a good thing.

It wasn't long ago that people were wishing for a "universal" operating system standard for computers. We got it.. it's called Windows and we know how you feel about THAT OS. ;)

Europe and most of the Middle East settled on the GSM standard long ago and it has been pretty successful. However, I would argue that the transmission standard has limited choices in terms of providers as there is little to differentiate one provider from another. The provider with the deepest pockets can run little guys out of business and charge whatever they like.

Most of the US carriers are going toward GSM, with the exception of Nextel and Sprint, which use iDEN (which is actually GSM with a special wrapper and low-latency technology) and CDMA respectively.

One thing I have to note is that, technically speaking, CDMA is superior in terms of efficiency and transmission capabilities.

Bottom line for most consumers is that they don't care what protocol or standard they are using.. AS LONG AS IT WORKS FOR THEM! :)

Posted by: Mike at May 26, 2004 12:16 PM

Right on, except that you forgot to add Verizon into the post. They, along with Sprint use CDMA.

Posted by: Mark at May 26, 2004 03:52 PM

As a consumer, I don't care if they use ESP, PMS, STD, or IUD, I want my phone to work when I need it where the provider says it's supposed to work. I don't care that the phone can take pictures if I can get a better connection with a piece of string and two tin cans. Mbps data connections from a cell phone are supposed to be l33t (I guess). I suppose that if the audio connection sux0r one can always use it to email. Any way you slice it, the consumer is 0wn3d by the providers...

Posted by: Mr Attitude at May 26, 2004 10:04 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits