
There's a new service that tells the sender whether your e-mail was read, where it was read, for how long, who it was forwarded to and how many times it was read.
Critics think that's a bit intrusive.
The site is called... DidTheyreadIt.com.
I've been using readnotify.com for years. It works great and one of the fun byproducts: when it notifies you that the e-mail has been read, it provides a map (city) of the location where the person reads the e-mail. If the person is traveling, it has the correct location. Way cool!
Posted by: Ken Leebow at May 24, 2004 10:43 AMI checked into ReadNotify, and it appears this service is over three years old - see http://www.urlwire.com/news/050101.html
It doesn't appear substantially different from DidTheyReadIt.
And, I cannot figure out how either service can claim to tell how long and e-mail was read - it must rely on the service receiving a call for another image indicating another e-mail had been opened, but in many cases, that does not mean the reader has closed the first one-- Eudora is one e-mail client in which you can have as many e-mails open and visible at the same time as you want. Also, since the images may then be cached in the client, it will not make an additional call if the reader opens the e-mail again and again and reads it additional time. It will not work at all if the recipient's e-mail client does not or is set not to show images, and by their own admission, location info is unreliable, since people can be using proxy servers, authorized SMTP servers, long-distance dialup, or just AOL to circumvent that service.
So, while interesting, I do not see the value in such as service, especially considering the privacy concerns it raises. It seems too unreliable, not that any service could be more reliable-- much like the hoax of Bill Gates being able to track e-mails and pay for each one of them, it's not technically possible for any system to do what this promises in a reliable manner.
T
Posted by: ToeKnee at May 24, 2004 12:28 PMIt seems like almost anyone is trying to make money one way or another these days. This just seems like a tool that nobody really needs yet many will probably buy. To each their own...
However, I must say that if I found out that someone I knew was trying to track my e-mails this extensively I'd probably blacklist them using my anti-spam software. I normally read e-mail one of two ways. I use a program called ChoiceMail One which has its own interface. This program drops all spam and keeps just the legitimate e-mail which then is downloaded into Outlook. It's not an e-mail client, but a spam blocking program. However, it allows me to view the e-mail as well. If I choose to read the e-mail first in ChoiceMail One before I download it to Outlook, all the images, HTML, etc. are blocked. Even for those people that are trusted. This helps to prevent many malicious things from running. If I do have it download to Outlook before reading the messages, I mostly read e-mail via the preview pane. And a lot of the extras still don't show up. Most of what I get are jokes and other nonsense and even though I don't mind getting them from those I trust, once I've read it, I usually delete it. So this product would tell them I've deleted their message since it didn't have a chance to track it. Not very useful since the information the person would get back is false and would make it look like I don't read their messages. And if they called me on it, then I'd want to know why they were so worried about tracking such messages.
Posted by: Mark Blair at May 24, 2004 03:06 PM
This is kind of a scam-- it works by embedding a reference to an image file on their servers which is then supposed to indicate when the e-mail was viewed by when the image file was 'called for."
This would not work for e-mail sent to me, or most of my clients, because I have my e-mail client block the display of images unless I want to see them. You can set this in most e-mail clients, I use Eudora.
It is a good anti-spam practice to block images, because spammers have been using these "tracking images" for some time - if you have html or image loading activated in your client, and you open or preview a spam mail, it makes a call for a non-existent 1x1 graphic file on the spammers' servers- the server log tracks the name of the file (usually some code such as "01sa13a.gif) and matches it to your e-mail address, and then they know you viewed the e-mail. Your e-mail address is now worth more money when the resell their list.
In any case, this DidTheyReadIt will probably make a bunch of money, and it will contribute to a bunch of arguments and bad feelings, as people think it's foolproof, and someone is "not reading" their e-mails, when in fact, they just have their image-loading turned off, as they should.
T
Posted by: ToeKnee at May 24, 2004 09:04 AM