
Just look at the gripes in the links candidly provided by Movable Type co-founder Mena Trot on the company's Six Apart Web Page.
Seems like nobody's happy with the company's new version, which slaps some pretty hefty fees for power users and commercial operations, while limiting features in the free version of the blogging tool.
Come on people. They're trying to make a living here.
Web developers, like newspapers and ezines, can not continue giving their product away.
Lord knows, online newspapers have been patient. They've watched people cancel print subscriptions because they can get it free online. They've seen their stories and reports ripped off and posted as an excerpt on blogs, or synopsized in someone else's RSS feed. They are not happy.
No one is suggesting we stop the free flow of information. But that doesn't mean the information itself is free.
Some sort of viable financial model has to be found for those who create the content that is collected, linked to, recycled, reposted and washed through the Web's blogs and aggregators.
Advertising on the mother site, for all except a handful of the Net's biggest players, just doesn't cut it. While there are some campaigns that do work, the good ones demand salespeople and creative ad designers who know the Net and how to do interactive ads. You won't find those people at most old media places.
I know from conversations with several newsroom execs around the country over the past few months that their corporate bosses have lost their patience with Web site costs. So they're going to try another old media tactic. We're going to see many more newspapers tack on a Web subscription fee to access their most popular featurest
Will that work? The early results, except for outfits like the Wall Street Journal, have not been very encouraging.
But If the Web has truly become the mass media of our time, it's going to start costing. And if people won't pay, a lot of content is going to start going away.
So don't get mad at Mena. She's just a little ahead of the curve.
You're missing the point... No one is saying that Six Apart (or newspapers) shouldn't charge - they're just complaining about the terms. In this case, people were encouraged to do a lot with their MT for free - and are now being told they need to pay hundreds of dollars if they want to continue to do so. To many people, this feels like bait and switch.
If you're in a competitive business you need to recognize standard rules of pricing - and suddenly tossing fees into something that was given out free (and which encouraged people to do more for free) is especially a slap in the face.
The decision to release this product with very few observable features (what people are willing to pay for) and much higher than expected pricing is a PR nightmare.
Meanwhile, your point about newspapers is also missing the point.
No one has the *right* to profit off their work. That's what the market is for. If everyone had the right to profit off of what they did, they could do anything they wanted - even if no one valued it - and wait for the profits to come rolling in. Everyone has the right to *try* to profit off of their work - which is quite different. Six Apart is doing that, as are newspapers... However, the points made by most of those criticizing the decision isn't that they shouldn't be allowed to profit, but on the methods by which they're trying to do so. They're pointing out that the market will not support them.
If the market is saying that content, by itself, is free, then it's very difficult for others to charge in that market. The competition and the market are saying the price is free. That doesn't mean that you can't profit however - but it becomes a business model issue. A smart business person figures out how to use that free content and create a business model that allows them to profit.
Posted by: Mike at May 17, 2004 08:00 PMI think things will work out in the end. Think about it....most blog software is free. The reason MT gained such a chare of the market was because it was so good.
I think the pricing is more than reasonable. Sure it might sting for a few weeks, but it's still the best product out there. People always have the option of sticking with the previous version. I'm hoping the superior product wins in this case.
Posted by: Charlie Jones at May 17, 2004 09:11 PM
I'm on the fence about this one. I totally understand the point about needing to make a living but when you start out free it is extremely hard to go upward in price. They got the marketshare they do by being the FREE product it was... now to jump to significant cost with significant limitions on even the entry level paid licenses seems a bit far. I expect many people to begin to look at the open source alternatives.
Love MT but the pricing is too steep for my needs.
Posted by: Randy at May 17, 2004 10:52 AM-Randy