« Problems with Airport Extreme update? | Main | It's Webby Time again »

April 20, 2004

Sirius and XM Satellite radio - what's the difference?

Beats me.
After trying both, I can detect no difference in quality or coverage and very similar offerings.
I also am throughly hooked on satellite radio.
I don't care which one I have. But I'm hooked.
Here's my Free Press column from today.


in Mobile lifestyle | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Mike,

Andy Ihnatko has a nice write-up:

http://snipurl.com/5tmn

Posted by: Seth at April 20, 2004 08:14 AM

Have you checked out XM PCR?  It's XM radio for your PC.  It is awesome, it uses the computer as the tuner but it doesn't bog down your processor because it isn't internet.  You can hook it up using either the computer speakers or your stereo.  as I type this, I'm listening to Thomas Dolby (Airwaves) on Channel 44 (Fred).  Without a doubt, to me this is the best computer add-on I've ever used.  XM PCR is only available form XM Radio's web cite and at 50 bucks, it is also the cheapest way to use satellite radio!

Posted by: Robert at April 20, 2004 08:28 AM

I agree with your article on both XM and Sirius. I
have yet to buy one because of the current product
offerings from both.
I want something that I can carry around with me. The
"Plug and Play" radios are inadequate because you
can't listen with headphones and to take it from the
home to the office, I would have to buy two home kits
or carry around the "boombox" kit which is too big.
Ten years ago, the current product line would be okay.
Today, it makes no sense not to create a truly
portable unit given our mobile society. Until XM,
Sirius or a competitor designs a real mobile unit,
satellite radio will not get the widespread adoption
that each company is hoping for.

Posted by: Stacy at April 20, 2004 08:30 AM

Robert,

Unfortunately it's Windows only..

http://www.xmradio.com/xmpcr/

Posted by: Omni at April 20, 2004 08:50 AM

While the XM PCR isn't officially supported on the mac, someone has written a hack that works extremely well, check out
http://www.macxm.com/

Posted by: Mark at April 20, 2004 09:10 AM

My husband & I have Sirius radio in our home and truck.  I agree, we will never go back to regular radio.  My husband was listening to regular radio in the garage the other night, and it drove him nuts!!!  Satellite radio is here to stay.

Posted by: Julie N at April 20, 2004 09:59 AM

NASCAR on XM radio is great! It's like a horse race or a boxing match, but with cool sound effects. It's suprisingly easy to listyen to. You can often find me sitting in my F150 in the driveway sipping a cold one listening to NASCAR on XM.

Posted by: Ronny at April 20, 2004 10:10 AM

FWIW, you can use XM as a portable. myradiostore.com sells a portable kit. While it isn't perfect, I use it all the time. And you can listen with headphones. I'd suggest that you add an inline volume controller (available from Radio shack for $6) & set the output level on the XM to it's highest level.

Posted by: Mark at April 20, 2004 10:24 AM

Both are very similar, with very similar offerings. Sirius offers a much better sports package (NFL, NBA, NHL) while XM has a much better (in my opinion) news package (Foxnews, CNN, MSNBC). both offer similar musical packages. The other major difference is that XM uses 2 satellites that stay in the same position (roughly over the equator) all the time, while Sirius uses 3 satallites that continually rotate around the Western hemisphere. This results in some coverage differences. Up in the Northeast (maine, NH) Sirius tends to give the better signal as it's satellites are much higher in the sky, while XM can get clipped by trees. XM's stationary satellites give you the advantage that once the antennae is set, you always get the signal, with Sirius's rotating satellites, there is the potential to lose the signal (it doesn't happen all the time, but does from time to time) Both services have repeaters in the major cities to give you terrestrial coverage where buildings would impede coverage.

Posted by: Mark at April 20, 2004 10:34 AM

Very Good.
Sirius uses three satellites in elongated elliptical orbit over North
America, XM uses two in equatorial orbit (like satellite TV). If you're
not using either system's ground based transmitters, you have to have
direct line of sight to a satellite. Further north you go the lower on
the horizon the satellite appears with XM -- Sirius remains high in the
sky giving better sky coverage.
You might want to beat this to death a little more -- IMHO the Sirius
satellite delivery system is somewhat superior, however, it wouldn't make
a difference to most users.

John K

Posted by: John K at April 20, 2004 11:20 AM

GREAT column on the 2 satcasters Mike!
I have BOTH too.  I'm more hooked than you.  I even transmit the sat-service over my FM transmitter so I can hear it on any FM radio in my house...but the whole subdivision gets it too and that's about 600 homes!
ART

Posted by: Art V at April 20, 2004 02:50 PM

Thanks for the positive article on satrad.  I've been an investor in both companies for several years now, and an owner of a Sirius (Audiovox PnP) system since last November.  Like you, I love it and there's no going back to "free" radio!  Check out Sirius' "Classic Rewind" stream if you haven't done so yet ... it's one of my favorites ... uh what am I saying ... I love them all!

Mark

Posted by: mark at April 20, 2004 02:51 PM

I subscribe to both XM and Sirius.  I share your conclusion that their services are more similar than different at present. I have driven over all of North America with both XM and Sirius.  They are often available in Canada and in some places in Alaska.  The services are far superior to any AM/FM offering. The geostationary satellites of XM make it the choice for most home and office applications as the signal, once found is always there.  I think XM is showing more technical prowess that will be evident in the ability to download information and entertainment other than radio.  Look at the announcement about Digital Fountain for the key to this.

Posted by: Bob Richards at April 20, 2004 02:52 PM

I just read your article regarding satellite radio and I couldn’t agree more about not missing local radio stations and those annoying commercials!! We have only had Sirius for about 10 days and we love it!!! It is great to be able to choose the music that we want to listen to and not the music that some suit has chosen for me! Hooray!!! Actually “It’s the best thing since sliced bread!”

Posted by: Anne at April 20, 2004 10:41 PM

I enjoyed your reviews of XM and Sirius.  I work in the automotive sector in car entertainment technologies.  I thought I would share a couple of other points with you that you might find interesting.
I find that XM's programming content tends to target a younger demographic with more alternative rock and less album rock channels, as an example.  Perhaps at 40 years of age, this is why I slightly prefer Sirius.
It seems to me that landing the NFL, NHL, and NBA was a huge coo for Sirius, if they can afford the hundreds of millions of $$$ they paid for it.
Insiders I know in the OEM radio manuf. communitee that once predicted Sirius' demise, now believe both will co-exist.
Lastly, there is another digital format coming down the road, HD Radio, a digital broadcast for the local broadcasters.  A discriminating ear will note that HD Radio sounds better than Satellite, with less compression artifacts.   Reason? 96 kbps verses < 60 kbps.   You can now buy HD Radio receivers, see www.crutchfield.com.  Currently 4 local HD radio stations, with another on the way:  102.7 FM, 105.1 FM,  WEMU (87.?) FM, and AM 1200.
By the way, AM HD Radio is FM quality, so a huge improvement over current AM.  AM can start playing music again!

Posted by: Brad at April 20, 2004 10:42 PM

You got it right about XM and Sirius.  I have had the XM now for at least two years. One in each car and one unit in my home library. I pay by the two year plan and get the second and third radio receivers for about $6 a month and then get a substantial discount because of the two year prepay.  Driving to and from Chicago to Bay City last week was a better ride because of the XM Radio and the Weather and Traffic Reports from XM Radio for Chicago - made the trip even better.

Posted by: Michael at April 20, 2004 10:44 PM

The streets were dark with something more than night.
-- Raymond Chandler
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 23, 2004 05:50 PM

Where there is much light there is also much shadow.
-- Goethe
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 23, 2004 07:28 PM

It has long been an article of our folklore that too much knowledge or skill,
or especially consummate expertise, is a bad thing. It dehumanizes those who
achieve it, and makes difficult their commerce with just plain folks, in whom
good old common sense has not been obliterated by mere book learning or fancy
notions. This popular delusion flourishes now more than ever, for we are all
infected with it in the schools, where educationists have elevated it from
folklore to Article of Belief. It enhances their self-esteem and lightens
their labors by providing theoretical justification for deciding that
appreciation, or even simple awareness, is more to be prized than knowledge,
and relating (to self and others), more than skill, in which minimum
competence will be quite enough.
-- The Underground Grammarian
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 24, 2004 08:13 PM

"Absolutely nothing should be concluded from these figures except that
no conclusion can be drawn from them."
(By Joseph L. Brothers, Linux/PowerPC Project)
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 06:35 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne nokia at June 11, 2004 08:52 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits