« Okay video games as a kid - get a good job as adult | Main | Fast, good, cheap: pick two »

April 02, 2004

Google Gmail creeps me out

The more we hear about Google's planned new Gmail service, the more I wish it had been an April Fool's Day joke.
It basically "reads" every word of your e-mail and then delivers ads targeted to the subject of your discussion.
Google claims no human actually reads you mail and that it's all done by bots. But is this creepy or what?


in Internet | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Well, like I said in the earlier Gmail post on this blog, this must be how Google is able to offer all that storage space for free.

In my book it's only slightly more creepy than the Google text ads that hawk products related to what you're reading about on a particular page. No one seems to be making a stink about those, including the ones on this blog.

I wouldn't ever use this service as my own personal email box, but it would be a good place to serve as my dumping ground - the address I use on forms that I fear will sell my address. Anyone that shops online or registers for message boards or other free services should have one.

Posted by: Matt at April 2, 2004 09:11 AM

I think it would interesting to test the service with an idea of mine which would to scramble your email message in javascript so bots can't read the content of your email. Since webmail is HTML it would not be a hard app to create. You'd open the javascript scrambling program, type your message, scramble your words, paste the scrambled message/code into the body of the gmail and push send! It would appear normal to you and me, but to the bots reading your email it will be nothing but code. Therefore no advertisements! It's only a matter of time until this idea becomes reality... Of course, only those in the know would pull such a stunt, because it's always fun to find flaws. My parents would never use such a program, because they wouldn't care enough, so the system may not be abused so much unless such acts were publicized on say... your tv show. =) I'd write the app, but I want to abuse the system for 100 accounts for 100 gigs.

Posted by: Evan at April 2, 2004 09:46 AM

It is definitely a change for what we're used to about email. But, I agree with Matt. It could still be useful.

Too bad it doesn't support Safari: https://gmail.google.com/gmail/browser_requirements.html

Posted by: Brian at April 2, 2004 09:49 AM

Those "Creepy" Google ads help pay for for this site (and 1000's of others) to stay online. Since no one wants to pay for content, what else is a web site owner suppose to do? Work for free? Bandwidth DOES cost bucks!

Posted by: Geek at April 2, 2004 09:50 AM

Well, isn't gmail just going to be another one of the several computers which "reads" your email? I mean every computer an email passes through is in some way "reading" it. Whether it just be to check if its spam or contains a virus.

Posted by: Nis Sarup at April 2, 2004 10:01 AM

Sheesh, take off the tinfoil hat! That's 1,000 MB of email space, *completely free* ! I mean, Yahoo fills 3/4 your Yahoo Mail page with some horrible flash ad, I think having some google text ads in the margin is a very reasonable price to pay. The other emailers could target ads at you as well, they just never thought of it or were able to implement it. Google has consistently proven that they are one of the rare companies that know how to treat their users right, and I doubt email will be any different. Look no further than their homepage.

Posted by: Doug Santos at April 2, 2004 10:14 AM

I think maybe my first comment didn't come out exactly right. I was not trying to complain about the google text ads on this site. Personally, I don't mind them one bit. They're much less annoying than most ads, since they don't draw attention to themselves, and, like Geek said, they help keep sites free. Speaking of which, Mike, I'm going to donate some money to you right now, since your site is so great!

My point was only that similar ads for gmail are only slightly more creepy than reading a webpage, then noticing that all the ads on the page are related to the same topic. I understand the point of the advertising, it's just a little unsettling at first.

I like Google as a company. Advertising is necessary to stay in business, and text ads are one of the best ways to not annoy anyone while doing so.

Posted by: Matt at April 2, 2004 10:47 AM

It doesn't seem so creepy to me. So it scans words and feeds adds to fit. Big deal. It's not like I'm going to do counter-espionage business in my web-based email.

Posted by: Mark Millard at April 2, 2004 03:01 PM

So if your Gmail is a bunch of mortgage , impotence solutions and porn spam, the bots will read this and give you similar ads. Right? Sounds like a win-win for spammers. ;-)

Posted by: Hans at April 2, 2004 03:06 PM

Matt said he had an idea to scramble his messages to the 'bot' couldn't read them. I know how to do this. Write any message in MS Word, choose File > Save As HTML. The resulting garbage is so full of XML crap, I have seen it put XML tags between every single word in a sentence, including between the word and the commas.
Try it. It's not pretty. it's not fun. it's MS Word. Uuurgh.

Posted by: Matt's Idea at April 2, 2004 08:42 PM

In case anyone is interested, here is a supposed screenshot of the Gmail beta:

https://adwords.google.com/select/images/gmail_screen.gif

via BoingBoing.

Posted by: Doug Santos at April 2, 2004 11:37 PM

I guess I lied, I wasn't quite done yet.

Doubt many people will actually see this comment, but I figured I'd add it anyway...

If you like the idea of 1GB of email storage, don't want to wait for Gmail, and think the TOS for Gmail sounds really creepy (I've come around, and now I agree it seems like a very bad idea), check out http://www.spymac.com

Spymac is now offering 1GB of email (POP3 only at this time, IMAP is in the works) in addition to free web hosting (100 MB) and a bunch of other cool stuff, ALL FREE! Their TOS are much better for the user, too.

Posted by: Matt at April 6, 2004 01:59 PM

A morsel of genuine history is a thing so rare as to be always valuable.
-- Thomas Jefferson
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 05:59 PM

Life's too short to dance with ugly women.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 08:00 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne at June 11, 2004 06:56 PM

Hmmmmm interesting

zapraszamy po czadowe gry java na gry java,
po dzwonki polifoniczne do dzwonki
polifoniczne lub dzwonki polifoniczne".Turnieje odbędą się w budynku Wyższej Szkoły Ekonomiczno-Informatycznej w Warszawie, znajdującej się na warszawskim Ursynowie, 50 metrów od stacji metra Stokłosy ." oraz po komputery laptopy notebooki
tanie laptopy.
You can find the best nokia ringtones and logo at
nokia ringtones, get the best melodies for your
nokia mobile phone ".The ultimate ringtone site, the place to download cool music ringtones. Feel free to browse through our extensive range of Nokia Polyphonic ." and get cool nokia logo at nokia logo and backgrounds now http://www.nokia-ringtone-logo.com Polyphonic ringtone at polyphonic ringtone ringtones polyphonic and monophonic
po tapety nokia
zapraszamy do tapety nokia po dzwonki polifoniczne sony ericsson do

dzwonki polifoniczne sony ericsson katalog artystów dzwonki
katalog dzwonki oraz
dzwonki eminem .
Hey
gamer, Get the coolest Java Game from
nokia java games and start
your java games now
For
polyphonic ringtones Go to

Polyphonic Ringtones
-
Polyphonic ringtones industry. We offer Ringtones

Monophonic Ringtones get
your ringtone today.  Aslo

True Tones - true tone.
Get hot java games if you are a gamer

Java Games - java games
for gaming world the ultr

nokia n-gage games.

Color wallpapers you can find here

Colour Wallpapers for mobiles
Mobile phone games
delivered instantly. Simply choose a java game, pay for it using sms message.
We'll send you a WAP bookmark from where you download the game and play over and
over again! Be sure to check our

Polyphonic Ringtones,

Monophonic Ringtones 
and

Colour Wallpapers 

Meble rattanowe dostaniesz w Meble rattanowe oraz rattanowe meble.
nieruchomosci dostaniesz w nieruchomosci oraz nieruchomosci dla biznesu.
!!!

Posted by: ringtones at June 24, 2004 03:48 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits