« Broadband penetration nearing 50 percent of Net homes | Main | Beer is good for you? »

March 24, 2004

Don't do it, Apple

MacRumors has picked up on reports that Yahoo is presently in negotiations with Apple to replace the Google-driven Search box in the Safari Web browser with one powered by Yahoo's search engine.
The use of the Google box is apparently provided by Apple for convenience rather than any specific financial deal between the two companies. Presumably, any switch to Yahoo would involve money.
But Yahoo is Yahoo, a search service many feel is severely compromised by paid placements.
If Apple does this, it would be a slap in the face to its users and a boon to Mozilla's Firefox, which has the same upper right hand browser search box. But with Firefox, it can be configured to whatever search service the user want, be it Google or nine other search sites.


in Internet | TrackBack (1)

Comments

Firefox takes me a little getting used to, but I like it more and more. Safari is ok, but there are just some things that Firefox does better. I don't like Yahoo too much, Google is better. Apple seems to me to be getting a bit more like Microsoft, looking for ways to place it's brand. I guess that's business, but it seems strange for Apple.

Posted by: Kel at March 24, 2004 09:18 AM

Actually, Yahoo has a "google-like" search section itself, which is very easy to use (http://search.yahoo.com/). I believe it is their attempt to simplify the searching experience, much like Google (and probably ties into their engine somehow). That URL also has a nice image searching tool, similar to Google's, that I often use. Try it out...

Posted by: Howard Wright at March 24, 2004 09:23 AM

I have also done some searching with Yahoo's new, streamlined Google-like interface mentioned above in the past month or so since it was announced, and I like it.

Mike and others: I am curious what you think about some of the anti-Google crusaders' points brought out on sites such as http://google-watch.org/

Don't get me wrong, I use Google early and often, but I wonder if it's as baggage-free as it appears. I also like to see competition for our searches-- another search engine I like is http://www.metacrawler.com/

T

Posted by: toeknee at March 24, 2004 09:50 AM

You want to see how "Google-like" Yahoo is trying to be? Check this out: http://search.yahoo.com/web?qry=

Posted by: Josh at March 24, 2004 10:42 AM

Oops. Didn't realize the "streamlined" Yahoo search was posted just above...

Only thing I can add at this point is this: if Apple changes Safari's default search mechanism to Google, my gut tells me there will be a preference the user can change or a pulldown list... if not, you can get your bottom dollar a third-party hack will come out that'll allow you to change it.

Posted by: Josh at March 24, 2004 10:45 AM

There are already hacks to change the default search engine in Safari's toolbar, they are just rather technical to implement: see http://www.macosxhints.com/article.php?story=20030514035516436

Posted by: toeknee at March 24, 2004 10:54 AM

Please Apple, don't do it. Back when the web was new, I was a Yahoo! user, but it's matured a lot since and Google has really paved the way in ease of use and in how deep its database is. I just looked at Yahoo's new 'streamlined look' and it's like they're doing a cheap copy of Google. How sad.

As to hacks that allow the search site to be changed... if Yahoo became the permanent search engine, i'd bet that a very EASY TO USE hack will be created to change it - a hack that anybody can use vs. some of the more technical hacks nowadays. Market demand. :-)

Posted by: Steve at March 24, 2004 12:56 PM

Yeah, there will be a "Restore Google in Safari" hack within 3 minutes of a Safari/Yahoo release. :)

Posted by: baw at March 24, 2004 05:02 PM

I personally could care less who the search engine is. What would have me excited is a choice of search engines, or even perhaps multiple responses a-la-sherlock via that same search field.

Posted by: supportTEX at March 24, 2004 06:40 PM

Here's something interesting:
http://safarikeywords.sourceforge.net/

Posted by: Josh at March 24, 2004 06:44 PM

What would be nice is if Apple would give us a choice, or let us specify our preferred engine in the search box instead of locking us in to a choice made in Cupertino.

But that wouldn't be very Apple-like of them, would it?

Posted by: Rich at March 25, 2004 03:22 PM

digressions and tangents counterpointed accept credit card with what seemed like an endless merchant account loop of the almost entirely featureless las vegas hotel M25 as seen from a car windscreen--it caribbean cruise wasn't really a loop I don't think, hotel it was actually continuous footage, usa visa but how could you tell? This footage green card lottery

Posted by: cruise at May 9, 2004 09:25 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits