
My column today is about a Michigan neuroscientist who thinks he's found a high-tech way to fight obesity: make people exercise before they can watch television.
Using stopwatch-like timing devices, wireless Bluetooth networking technology and software controls that can block access to a TV set, cell phone or other electronic equipment, the system creates time credits based on the amount of exercise a person does in terms of time and intensity.
Those credits can then be cashed in, for example, to watch an hour's worth of television.
Who watches TV anymore???
Posted by: Geek at March 22, 2004 10:09 AMWouldn't punishment work, too? Like if you didn't exercise, you'd have to read a book! (Remember books? That's how people used to be entertained before TV!!!)
Posted by: Joe at March 22, 2004 10:23 AMUgh, no thanks. I actually like having freedom to choose and think for myself. Besides, wouldn't this be harmful to people who actually have exercise induced asthma or even heart problems or what have you? Unless there's a way to truly make it personal. Still, I wouldn't want such a system in my home.
Posted by: Kim at March 22, 2004 10:31 PMI think this will fail flat on its face. It's the punishment side of motivation.
I remember reading a very interesting article a while back (dang, can't remember the source!!!) in which the author took part in a research study to help people get motivated about exercising regularly.
In the study, a software AI program was installed on his computer. Instead of boring stats and spreadsheets, the program represented itself as a rendered face of a human being (you could choose between several, I think, male or female).
The author being male, he chose a female AI to be his "trainer."
Every time he used the computer, the AI would pop-up and have a simulated conversation with him. "She" would ask him questions like, "How do you feel today? Are you tired?" and "Did you exercise?"
In the course of the conversation, which was scripted but intelligent enough to simulate some amount of natural quality, the AI would record how the author was performing.
But most importantly, the AI would provide feedback and encouragement based on whether the author was sticking to his exercise routine or not. If he did, the AI would show "pleasure" and smile and laugh - essentially encouraging him through a mix of flattery, flirting, and actual assement.
As the weeks went on, the author noted that he became quite attached to his AI and every day, he would look forward to chatting with her to let her know he accomplished this or that. When he skipped exercising, the very slight disappointment (but not negativity) that the AI expressed was powerful enough to motivate him to get right back into routine. After a while, he noted that his real life wife began ignoring the program completely and he sensed she started feeling threatened because he was looking forward to the "conversations" so much.
At the end of a few months, the study was over and he was no longer able to converse with the program. He noted that throughout the study, he actually kept a strict exercise routine, lost weight, and generally felt morose and unmotivated now that he no longer had his AI companion analyzing his performance and providing naturalistic feedback.
Seems like such a program would be a real hit, especially if the AI personality can be projected onto your TV via a wireless set-up. And naturally, you'd be able to customize the look and sound of your AI. :-)
Mike, you should try to research this and do an article on it!
Posted by: Paul at March 23, 2004 06:34 PMPaul, I know exactly what you're talking about! Unfortunately I can't recall the source but I would think this would be the way to go. Yes, it's cliche'd to say people usually do better with positive motivation but I'm inclined to agree with it. Punishments often can easily have a much more detrimental affect than positive encouragement but again depends on the individual I suppose. I'm more likely to want to work towards something if I'm excited about it, not if someone's hanging a black cloud over me.
Posted by: Kim at March 23, 2004 08:28 PMWatson's Law:
The reliability of machinery is inversely proportional to the
number and significance of any persons watching it.
lipitor
Hmmmmm interesting !!!
Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne nokia at June 11, 2004 06:44 PM
Just wait. Soon enough they'll figure out a way to make sure kids do their homework first too. And brush their teeth for good measure. Crazy stuff :)
Posted by: Adam at March 22, 2004 09:45 AM