
Like, say, a penny per message? Maybe even a half-cent. That's not going to hit the average user too hard in the pocketbook but it sure would put a crimp in the budget of spammers who send out millions of junk messages a day.
What do you think? Is this a viable idea?
Does your attitude towards this suggestion change if I tell you that this is what Bill Gates is floating as the solution to spam?
Hmmm... yes, this would hit up the spammers, but somehow thinking that Bill Gates might be the, uh, "recipient" of some of that money makes me cringe.
Perhaps he has so much extra money that he'd like to fund this project to get it off the ground.
I'm just thinking how expensive this could get for business users. I work for a non-profit and send thousands of emails a year out and i'm only one of 12 on staff. I couldn't imagine how this would hit the bigger companies.
One saving grace, however, is that five of us are on Macs and Mail has such effective spam controls that we're perfectly satisfied. ESPECIALLY when using Mail combined with .Mac. In a year I haven't been spammed on that account. Wow.
Posted by: Steve at March 8, 2004 12:22 PMAbsolutely do not want to pay a cent to send email.
Absolutely do not want a cent to go to Gates or anyone else.
Why not find a way to charger known spam sources $$, besides I don't know how people get lots of spam, in 3 years I've only had maybe 5 spam mail messages come to my .mac or twmi account, in fact only one ever to my .mac
I think this misses the point. Spammers *already* fake return addresses, spoof servers, hijack PCs, etc. Who really thinks they would pay the penny per email? The more likely outcome is that some spammer will figure out how to forge the charges to *ME*.
This is a BAD idea...
Posted by: Robert at March 8, 2004 12:44 PMi'm already paying for my email! my ISP is getting money for hosting my email server. so i don't need no bill gates to tell me to pay more.
my mailbox is 97% spam (counted over the last couple of weeks) but i don't care because almost 99% is caught by mac os x mail's spam filter anyway. and with this one percent i can live.
would i prefer less spam? absolutely and i despise spammers but i also hate the marketing junk mails in my snail-mailbox.
the real problem imho: there must be some idiots out there who actually by the viagra or penis enlargement from spammers otherwise it would not make any sense to spammers to send out their emails. so let's educate those people before charging the rest of the world!
Posted by: joerg at March 8, 2004 12:59 PMAlready paying $45 + tax for internet access. Now I'll have to pay $$ to send an email?
Posted by: baw at March 8, 2004 01:33 PMNo way alreading paying too much for access and other features.
Posted by: Greg Vaniscak at March 8, 2004 02:00 PMI vote NO!
Sounds as though collection would be an accounting nightmare, particularly with most spammers not identifying themselves. Also, the collection database would be yet another possible source of personal info for hackers to raid.
Posted by: Bob Hawkes at March 8, 2004 02:16 PMIsn't that what I'm already paying $54.99 to Wide Open West a month for??? And it isn't Sally in Michigan that's flooding the world with spam, so charging her a penny a message isn't going to do anything. The people who are spamming are going to find a way to be anonymous or so hidden that "they" won't be able to tell who it is.
And with the ability of hackers to take over your computer, it would be only a short matter of time before Sally in Michigan got a bill for thousands of dollars because a spammer hijacked my system and used it to send spam.
This is a logistically silly idea, and shame on Bill Gates for suggesting it.
BTW... I get very very VERY little spam, even on my Win95 Outlook Express system, thanks to diligent privacy policy reading careful surfing. If you are getting spam, read the things you can do to protect yourself, set your system filters and parameters conservatively, and take the time to do the things to keep your info safe. It takes a little effort, but is worth it.
Posted by: Sally Black at March 8, 2004 02:31 PMNO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO! NO!
Just in case that's not clear, my answer is NO!
Another great idea from those innovative folks at Microsoft.
Posted by: Tim at March 8, 2004 03:30 PMI haven't seen an actual quote of Bill Gates saying anything about this, but if what the article at http://arstechnica.com/news/posts/1078688677.html is saying is true, then the media is REALLY twisting poor Bill's words around. He never mentioned anything about paying cash for sending emails.
I actually think his (actual) idea is pretty interesting, definitely something to be looked into. Although I can see it causing problems for legitimate mailing lists.
Posted by: Allen at March 8, 2004 03:37 PMNot in my back yard. NO!
Posted by: Pearl at March 8, 2004 03:56 PMNo way!!! This is the most rediculous idea.
Posted by: Chris at March 8, 2004 05:53 PMNO,NO,A THOUSAND TIMES NO!!!!!!
Posted by: Ross Henry at March 8, 2004 06:29 PMWhile we all share a disdain for all things Microsoft, this idea does have some benefits.
First, there is absolutely no suggestion that the proceeds of this idea would go to Gates.
Second, spammers send out TONS of messages without needing many takers precisely because e-mail is free. Without having to absorb the costs of communicating, spammers are allowed to send more mail than any of us want.
Third, even if you are satisfied with your spam filter that only treats the symptoms rather than the disease. The amount of spam flooding the internet is choking servers and slowing down everything else for the rest of us.
Posted by: James Graber at March 8, 2004 06:36 PMI also dislike the idea.
But, who will recieve these micropayments? If people pay me to send me mail, and vice versa, then I might go for it. I get more mail than I send.
What about emailed newsheadlines and email newsletters? They would probably all go to RSS feeds. While I like the CONCEPT of RSS, the implementations of it are still lacking, IMO.
Realistically, though, I don't think this idea has much of a chance.
Here's an idea: Microsoft gives money back to each Windows user every time a new security hole is plugged.
Posted by: Brian Jones at March 8, 2004 07:24 PMNO WAY! First of all, if people would be just as conscious giving out their email address as they are giving out their home address- they would not recieve so much spam. Secondly, most email providers have the ability to put the mailbox to "exclusive" so that only those on your "safe list" get into your email box. And lastly, what would students do? I am a student who relies CONSTANTLY on email to keep in contact with people at school. And I am not just talking about "chatting" through my email box- I am in a program where we constantly work in groups and email is our main form of communication. I dunno what we would do without it!!!
Jessica
Posted by: Jessica Ibarra at March 8, 2004 08:27 PMMany of you MAC Folks are sooooo one way. The OP System has nothing to do with E-Mail. The word Gates gets mentioned, and you all spase out! LOL
Spam is Spam... we all get it.
G
Posted by: Geek at March 8, 2004 08:31 PMHere's the point--they want more money. Today it's 1 cent, next year it's 2, because--hey the cost of electricity went up or whatever. Get my point? If we start down that slippery slope, of allowing someone else to get into our pockets--it's only going to grow worse and cost us more money. The government has been trying to figure out how to tax the internet anyway, and I think this is one more step in that direction.
But there's also the effect this may have on the cost of business, or even the simple emails we all send. Granted a penny is still cheaper than snail mail, but still--it's the principle of the thing. I say "no!". They're already getting enough of my money--and I'm not giving up any more of what I work hard to obtain! I'll deal with the occasional spam that gets through my filters. It's as simple as pressing DELETE. Wallah--poof--it's gone. Problem solved. :-)
Posted by: Steve at March 8, 2004 09:00 PMI don't even want to pay one TENTH of one PERCENT of one CENT! Uhhh remember seeing any 6 cent stamps from years back? Now it's .37 cents and up. Filters are the best way for an individual to avoid spam AND, would it still be continued if NO ONE BOUGHT FROM SPAMMERS? I'd say, if you open a spam and the deal looks interesting, contact the SPammer and say, I'd go for this deal but I DETEST spam, so I will find the deal ELSEWHERE!
If it wasn't working for them, they wouldn't be doing it.
I think paying for e-mailing should be Compulsory suckers!
hello
Posted by: fdas at May 6, 2004 08:19 PMMake it your guiding principle to do your best for others and to be trustworthy in what you say. Do not accept as friend anyone who is not as good as you. When you make a mistake do not be afraid of mending your ways.
Did you know about the -o option of the fortune program? It makes a
selection from a set of offensive and/or obscene fortunes. Why not
try it, and see how offended you are? The -a ("all") option will
select a fortune at random from either the offensive or inoffensive
set, and it is suggested that "fortune -a" is the command that you
should have in your .profile or .cshrc. file.
lipitor
The introduction of a new kind of music must be shunned as imperiling the
whole state, for styles of music are never disturbed without affecting
the most important political institutions. ... The new style, gradually
gaining a lodgement, quitely insinuates itself into manners and customs,
and from it ... goes on to attack laws and constitutions, displaying the
utmost impudence, until it ends by overturning everything.
-- Plato, "Republic", 370 B.C.
lipitor
Hmmmmm interesting !!!
Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne at June 11, 2004 08:52 PM
Absolutely not. That is ridiculous. Who would get the money? Microsoft? PFFFFFTT.
Posted by: Derek at March 8, 2004 12:22 PM