« Have a nice virtual day | Main | My books are on e-Bay »

March 01, 2004

Michigan's laptop program for kids largest in nation

Michigan's Freedom to Learn wireless laptop giveaway for sixth graders may have been scaled down from it's once lofty goals but it is still the largest such program in the nation, potentially providing as many as 44,000 students an with a wi-fi-equipped HP laptop. The first computers get distributed at the end of the month.
The state originally wanted all 160,000 sixth graders to get one but a budget crunch and public opposition pulled the plug on state funding. The $68 million now being spent is from federal funds that require the computers to go to under-achieving schools.
Dell and Apple had also vied for the $68 million contract but lost out to HP's promise to provide an HP nx9010 notebook computer with a 2.4 GHz processor, a 30GB hard drive, 256MB of RAM and an 802.11g wireless card for $250 per student. The deal also involves software and teacher training. Here's a link to the full package provided by HP.
Here's my column on this from today's newspaper.


in Computers | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Aside from a waste of taxpayers' money, the computer program will fail for the following reasons.
Computers will not improve students' reading and/or math skills;
Lack of money for maintenance/repair;
Lack of money for replacement due to accidental or deliberate loss;
Lack of computers beyond grade six;
Insufficient number of trained/knowledgeable teachers.
Sterling

Posted by: Sterling at March 1, 2004 12:55 PM

Sterling--you're partially correct, partially incorrect.

Check out the Maine laptop program, and you'll discover that it's being heralded as a HUGE success across the board, even by those who were it's harshest critics in it's early stages.

Unfortunately, much of the REASON for this success is that they're using Apple iBooks (which are far more intuitive, far more durable, far easier to learn with, and require far less maintenance than typical PC laptops). Most of the concerns you express are made far worse by the decision to go with Wintel machines.

In addition, in Maine, they didn't simply toss the laptops at the kids like candy and expect it to be a success; they took the time & care to do proper training of students, teachers *and* parents, and so on. There are a *lot* of factors which have to be dealt with properly for this sort of program to be successful on a widescale basis, but it can be done--though it's FAR more likely to be successful using Macs!

Posted by: Charles Gaba at March 1, 2004 01:54 PM

I cannot see a way where any manufacturer would be able to compete with that pricepoint. Apple's costs per iBook are likely twice $250 or more. I can't imagine what kind of crap quality computers they'll be getting for $250, but there must be some other major profit built into the deal, or HP is trying to "dump" to gain market share and drive away competition, much like exporters do.

I manage a gradeschool lab of 26 cheap crap Compaq Evos, and I am amazed how much plastic goes into these things. The exterior components are obviously cheap, though the most common problem are sound card issues, not the broken keyboards and mice I was expecting. These kids are pretty good.

However, I agree that giving them cheap Windows-based laptops with inadequate training is a recipe for disaster. I am also distressed they will not have CD/RW drives, as without adequate backup, there will certainly be a lot of kids who lose their work when their computer is stolen or splattered to bits out the bus window. I hope they have a wireless network backup solution ready. I think the majority of the kids (50%+) will be able to care for the computers properly, but there will be a lot of mishaps.

T

Posted by: ToeKnee at March 1, 2004 02:25 PM

can not believe that those idiots are going to spend 70 million of our tax dollars on 1500 dollar laptops. Who are they kidding. We are in a budget crunch, they just jacked up the price of cigarettes to help with this. I haven't checked lately what the gas tax is now, but it's gone up to pay for this crap they call roads.  All of this and they blow 70 MILLION on things that WILL get destroyed shortly after they receive them. This is like making a decision to go gamble instead of paying the heating bill in January.   70 mill could make one nice road....
You and I went to school without these things, if you listen to Freedom to Learn Project it amazing we turned out.

Posted by: Marc at March 1, 2004 02:54 PM

What ticks me off by this is that my taxes is going toward something that even I can't afford to buy right now....

Posted by: Ray at March 6, 2004 09:47 PM

I worked for over 7 years for one of the leading educational software companies in the world. I've seen "laptop take home" programs meet with GREAT success using BOTH Mac's and WinTel machines. The kids on the whole were great with these machines. The biggest problems I saw were lack of training and appropriate software for the computers. I've watched schools spend many thousands of dollars on hardware only to find they have nothing to run on the machines once they get them. This could be a wonderful program but NOT without proper strategic planning before hand.

Posted by: Roger C Henderson at March 22, 2004 07:37 AM

You buttered your bread, now lie in it.
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 05:49 PM

"Don't drop acid, take it pass-fail!"
-- Bryan Michael Wendt
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 06:27 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne at June 10, 2004 07:26 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne nokia at June 12, 2004 11:41 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits