« In-ear headphones and the iPod | Main | Yankee or Dixie test »

February 25, 2004

"Grey Tuesday" protest takes on music industry

Organizers of "Grey Tuesday" say yesterday's 24-hour online protest over the music industry's efforts to stop online file swapping of copyrighted songs involved more than 170 Websites and has escalated the fight for what file swappers are calling their digital rights..
It all involves the downloading of an immensely popular underground remix of music from The Beatles' White Album and rapper Jay-Z's Black Album called, fittingly enough, the Grey Album.
Problem is, the music is copyrighted and the recording industry has been vigorously trying to stop the downloading of the remix, done by a Los Angeles DJ called Danger Mouse. Warning letters were sent many of the sites demanding that they stop distributing the music.
" This first-of-its-kind protest signals a refusal to let major label lawyers control what musicians can create and what the public can hear," claim organizers of the protest.
With the protest over, the next step is likely to come from the music industry but, clearly, file swappers are not giving up in their fight against what they say is the music industry's "copyright cartel."


in Music | TrackBack (1)

Comments

Mike:

This quote sickens me: "This first-of-its-kind protest signals a refusal to let major label lawyers control what musicians can create and what the public can hear"

It's not about that. It's about fairly compensating artists for their work. The labels represent the interests of the artists (and yes, "themselves", although "themselves" is a bit vague, since "the label" is not an individual entity in and of itsef).

Besides which, in the age of the Internet, there have never been more ways to disseminate music and other product. "The public can hear" more music from more sources than at any time in history.

Mike, I'm really interested in your take on all this. I think most folks would understand this better if it were personalized, instead of directed towards "The Big Record Companies".

For instance, should TV stations be allowed to record your Tech Talk segments and rebroadcast them without compensating you? What if I re-edit some of your pieces interspersed with, say, clips from the Democratic National Committee to make it look like you're a major supporter? (Heh...that's an idea: Howard Dean talks about raising taxes, then we have a Mike clip: "It's an amazing concept")

For all of you who create content, should you be creating it for free without compensation? Or should you just be allowed to make a predetermined amount, above which it's "not fair", and you're clearly greedy?

This is all a smokescreen for folks to justify their thieving ways. To all of you who feel persecuted by "the man" for stealing music: I guarantee you--if YOUR work were being widely distributed and you weren't getting paid for it, you'd feel differently.

Posted by: Rich at February 25, 2004 10:54 AM

As I wriote the other day, I've toughened my attitude on it over the months. I used to call the RIAA thugs and goons.
Now, with 99-cent downloadable songs easily and legally available, it's pretty hard to condemn the industry for going after those who refuse to pay even that. The RIAA tactics are indeed desperate... but then so is the problem of people ripping off music because they want something for nothing.

Posted by: Mike Wendland at February 25, 2004 11:30 AM

Rich,

In this particular rebellion against the recording industry, it isn't the issue of being able to download music against the wishes of the artist and without the artist being paid. In this particular case, the artist who created the music did so by sampling songs from the Beatles' White Album and some hip-hop artist's Black Album, hence the name Grey Album. He did creates an indie CD of his work, but only about 3,000 copies. He also placed his work on the Internet for anyone to download (I did, huge Beatles fan, not a hip-hop fan, interesting album in some ways, but not what I would listen to much).

In other words, the artist that created this work is, of his own free will, giving away access to the work.

The label that represents the Beatles works issued him a cease and desist letter, which he complied with, not having the resources to fight such a thing. However, others on the Internet have, properly, I think, pointed out that the recording industry, which claims to protect the rights of artists, thereby guaranteeing innovation in music, is in this case stifling innovation, and many consider what the creator of the Grey Album to have done to fall under the heading of fair use. In protest, many put the music he had made available on their own web sites and gave their web sites a grey look in honor of the album.

Now, I don't personally download music I don't own. I do, however, download music I do own. For instance, I have an audio cassette of Abbey Rd., not a CD, and I'm not really interested in hooking up a tape player to my PowerBook and getting sub-par quality of the music I already own so that I can listen to it while at work. So I downloaded music from this album and feel no guilt about it since I bought it.

However, I agree that most of the time, downloading music for free is just stealing. I don't think that piracy costs nearly as much as publishers of content claim, but I do think it's wrong.

And, BTW, I do create content, in the form of software, articles and books. Honestly, I would rather someone pirate my work and read or use it than not use it at all. And if someone finds enough value in what I've done to incorporate it in their own work, I have no problem with that. I consider that fair use.

Chuck

Posted by: Chuck at February 25, 2004 01:20 PM

A good traveler has no fixed plans, and is not intent on arriving.

Posted by: Brown Jess at May 21, 2004 12:08 AM

Interesting poll results reported in today's New York Post: people on the
street in midtown Manhattan were asked whether they approved of the US
invasion of Grenada. Fifty-three percent said yes; 39 percent said no;
and 8 percent said "Gimme a quarter?"
-- David Letterman
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 07:25 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: polifoniczne dzwonki at June 12, 2004 11:34 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits