
There's a whole bunch of new software tools that parents are using to monitor the computer activities of their children. Here's my NBC-TV High Tech Talk report for this week that shows several of them.
While I agree with Alida to a point, I think these devices are practically necessary for those that have children. It seems just about everyday we hear of some child that runs off with a much older person they met in chat rooms or through IM sessions.
Blocking access to those sites for children is certainly necessary in my mind. Children are trusting, and the trust grows when they hear/read things they like. There are tons of sickos out there that prey on the trust of kids too young to think they might be anything other than what they say they are.
On the other hand, these devices can certainly be used for the wrong reasons, such as the students that used one to steal the password of a teacher and access the answers to a test.
The sword cuts both ways, and nothing is ever perfect, but for parents with younger children, I feel they are absolutely necessary; not really to snoop and spy, but more to make sure your children aren't getting themselves into trouble.
Posted by: Matt at February 17, 2004 12:03 PM"Infraction of Law?" I don't think so.
As long as I'm responsible for the actions of my child--and I am until s/he is 18--I have the right and the responsibility to parent as I see fit. Going through mail, using keystroke programs, heck, searching his/her room--they're all draconian measures to a greater or lesser degree, but they're all part of a parent's toolkit.
Posted by: Rich at February 17, 2004 03:14 PMi agree with matt..having the program myself. if we lived on perfect street with prefect children then no i quess we do not need it. well we don-t live in perfect world and no matter how much you think they know or understand children still think they know everything and that will not happen to them. with the software i found out a 22 year old has been sneaking in my house in the night drugs etc. so if i needed that software oh well it was time to move off perfect street
Posted by: evelyn at February 18, 2004 08:37 AMParents should be parents - not spies.
Would you want your child reading your personal mail? Then why read his/hers?
Become involved in your child's life. By that I don't mean that you just enroll them in every possible activity and provide taxi service! Being involved means sharing time with them - making time for them. Your child will trust you if you're an involved parent and there will be no need to invade his/her privacy.
Be aware that children learn from what they see their "role models" doing - You, the parents, are their role model.
It seems that Americans are much too eager to surrender privacy to all comers - in the case of key-loggers these parents surrender their child's privacy because the parent is too uninvolved to know their child.
Posted by: Bill at February 18, 2004 06:13 PMIn response to your article regarding key loggers and monitoring children's activities.... I have to support it. As an IT Manager and as a parent of a 7 year old daughter... I have to be prepared for what may lie ahead. I trust my daughter and will continue to do so until given reason not to. My concern is the rest of the lurking world behind the screen. Do a search on Barbie... You'll be surprised at the results. Type in whitehouse.com VS .Gov as most every adult KNOWS but cildren don't. I can then at least know what I need to filter out and know where she is going as she learns the ways of the PC and Internet. That doesn't even TOUCH the world of email and IM. She has her own computer which is situated right next to mine and she is currently only allowed to "play" when I am next to her with one excpetion. She has MANY educational programs she likes to "play". We allow that without DIRECT supervision only when the interenet is cut off from her computer. Her email address does not contain her name in anyway and does not indicate if she is male or female. I open her email before she is even allowed in the room currently. It is amazing just how fast SPAM creeps in and I don't think she needs to worry about enlarging anything, or Hot chics with ... You know the stuff. As she gets older.. The chains will loosen a bit as to what she is allowed to access and do. But I will have records of it until the day she turns 18 and is out of the house. I am not condoning nor stating I will SHELTER her from EVERYTHING but I will know what is going on. Whether I react or not will be a parenting choice between her mother and I. What is funny is how the attention is only on kids and computers.. What about what goes on at school? What abot when she starts driving? The same rules will apply then as they do now. I WILL know what is going on at all costs. How we respond to what goes on becomes a prenting issue between her mother and I. I want her to experience life and what is out there, but only in controlled doses and with safety measures in place. It is sad.. But necessary.. I was a teen boy not all that long ago... I know what they are thinking and doing too...
Posted by: Jays at February 19, 2004 07:53 AMOk....wow...no wonder kids are rebelling so much these days! Thank goodness my parents don't invade my privacy! I'm 18 years old and I'm one of the "good kids". I give my parents no reason to spy on me let alone monitor my email and anything else I may do or say online! It's PATHETIC that parents do that to their children. I'd understand, however, if they thought their child were in danger. That's understandable and acceptable although the child in question wouldn't like it, intervention would be neccesary. For the most part though, to have software that recorded EVERYTHING their child did on the computer is ridiculous! Although minors, they still have rights. Trust your children more for goodness sake! If you raised them correctly then they know the difference between right and wrong, they will choose to do right. Pushing them and controlling them only causes rebellion and shunning of everything they have been taught. Try talking to your children (a concept that has seem to have been forgotten) and instead of placing so many restrictions on them allow them to have a few freedoms while telling them what you expect of them while they are online or the computer(or in life in general). It might surprise you how well behaved your child may be if you'd give them a little freedom and show that you trust them. I can't guarentee that your child won't abuse the priveledges, and if he/she does, by all means take action, but don't overreact. I for one haven't been a parent yet (being 18 and all), but I have been a child my entire life, so far, and although I am legally an adult, I still live in my parents house and I am still in high school which makes me under their rules which I respect. I communicate with my parents and respect them because of the values they have instilled in me. They have no reason not to trust me. I mess up sometimes and there are consequences occassionally, but I have never given them a reason not to trust me. Maybe instead of a software to monitor children, we need parents to start parenting and stop dictating.
Posted by: Angela at February 23, 2004 08:24 PMHmmmmm interesting !!!
Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne nokia at June 11, 2004 08:35 PM
I think it is highly offensive that there are so many logging devices available.
Recording all keystrokes, e-mail, IM's, it's an invasion of privacy. No different than listening in on a phone conversation or reading someone's diary.
Like it or not, kids have the right to reserve some of themselves for themselves. This should not be taken away. There are some things kids shouldn't have their parents prying into.
I do understand the features that allow one to block certain programs and things from being opened, or things such as 'Nanny Net.' Some control is a good thing, but reading their e-mail? No different than taking a snail mail envelope addressed to the child and ripping it open. Infraction of law.
Some may argue that they may do whatever they wish because the child is theirs and it is for their own protection. Treat others how you wish to be treated, and the fact that the child came from inside of you or part of you is irrelevant. They aren't something to be owned, but guided.
Of course, some children are less mature than others, it does definitely depend on the child. Ultimately, the decision rests with the parents.
Posted by: Alida at February 17, 2004 11:29 AM