
Here's the latest - and hopefully last - on my crashing Mac G5.
The good news: I think it's finally fixed.
The operative word is... think. I've been down this road before.
Anyway, for those interested...
I called AppleCare bright and early this morning. The phone tech had me run Disk Repair from the G5 install disk and, even though DiskWarrior repaired it last night, it was showing the same old catalog error.
Applecare told me to wipe the hard drive clean and reinstall the OS.
Dave Nanian, an Apple software developer who has been following my frustration, was suspicious and advised against that. He suggested I instead run Hardware Test to see if the RAM was trashed.
Several others suggested the same thing yesterday but, in the rush of confusion, I neglected to do it. I should have listened to the advice then.
For it turned out to be good advice. The test detected a faulty 256Mb memory bank. I took the machine to my local Apple store and swapped out the offending module and it's partner.
Back home, I ran DiskWarrior once more to correct any glitches on the main hard drive when the bad DIMM crashed the machine.
For whatever it's worth, the tech who did the swap said the bad DIMM module wasn't from the same manufacturer that Apple currently uses for the G5 RAM.
I really, really hope this is the end of this detour.
Thanks to the many readers who offered help and suggestions, in comment posts and by e-mail.
This really is a community.
In two calls to Apple... Sunday and this morning - talking to two different techs... that was the AppleCare advice.
It appears to have been flat out wrong and I would have been one stressed-out customer if I had followed it and erased everything I have worked for three months to build on this system and then had to go back and reload all those aps and get all those registration numbers again.
I told both techs that others suggested it was a RAM problem and asked if they absolutely sure that erasing and reformatting was my best option and they both almost laughed at me.
I'm glad I listened to you guys.
Whew! Glad things are up again.
As others said, reformatting is very, very rarely the way to go. It's one thing if you've got a drive that's going bad, and the entire "transparent remap" table has become full (a dangerous situation to begin with). It's another thing entirely to have kernel panics that are resulting in (frankly, expected) disk errors.
Fingers crossed that this is, truly, the happy ending we've all been hoping for!
Posted by: Dave Nanian at February 16, 2004 05:35 PMIt's too bad you don't have those tech's names so you could report them and suggest they be educated further. It's obvious they don't yet know enough to be support techs.
Posted by: Kel at February 16, 2004 05:44 PMMike,
It's worth calling Apple back and telling them your outcome. They won't tell you who the tech with the bad advice was - and, frankly, it's not your place to try to "re-educate" him - but they might check the call notes and have someone spend some time with that tech.
Imagine if you had followed their advice and still had the problem!
Before trying something that drastic, it's probably a good idea to get a 40gb hard drive and swap it in for the "bad" one then reinstall on that one.
Glad it worked out!
Posted by: Seth Dimbert at February 16, 2004 07:44 PMIt always amazes me when professional tech support fails in the most basic troubleshooting technique. Divide and conquer. The first thing they should have done is take steps to determine whether you had a hardware or software issue. It's even worse that they didn't have you run the basic diagnostic tools Apple supplies.
-Dan
Posted by: Photodan at February 16, 2004 08:02 PM"Being against torture ought to be sort of a multipartisan thing."
-- Karl Lehenbauer, as amended by Jeff Daiell, a Libertarian
lipitor
Hmmmmm interesting !!!
Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne at June 11, 2004 06:55 PMHmmmmm interesting
zapraszamy po czadowe gry java na gry java,
po dzwonki polifoniczne do dzwonki
polifoniczne lub dzwonki polifoniczne".Turnieje odbędą się w budynku Wyższej Szkoły Ekonomiczno-Informatycznej w Warszawie, znajdującej się na warszawskim Ursynowie, 50 metrów od stacji metra Stokłosy ." oraz po komputery laptopy notebooki
tanie laptopy.
You can find the best nokia ringtones and logo at
nokia ringtones, get the best melodies for your
nokia mobile phone ".The ultimate ringtone site, the place to download cool music ringtones. Feel free to browse through our extensive range of Nokia Polyphonic ." and get cool nokia logo at nokia logo and backgrounds now http://www.nokia-ringtone-logo.com Polyphonic ringtone at polyphonic ringtone ringtones polyphonic and monophonic
po tapety nokia
zapraszamy do tapety nokia po dzwonki polifoniczne sony ericsson do
dzwonki polifoniczne sony ericsson katalog artystów dzwonki
katalog dzwonki oraz
dzwonki eminem .
Hey
gamer, Get the coolest Java Game from
nokia java games and start
your java games now
For
polyphonic ringtones Go to
Polyphonic Ringtones
-
Polyphonic ringtones industry. We offer Ringtones
Monophonic Ringtones get
your ringtone today. Aslo
True Tones - true tone.
Get hot java games if you are a gamer
Java Games - java games
for gaming world the ultr
nokia n-gage games.
Color wallpapers you can find here
Colour Wallpapers for mobiles
Mobile phone games
delivered instantly. Simply choose a java game, pay for it using sms message.
We'll send you a WAP bookmark from where you download the game and play over and
over again! Be sure to check our
Polyphonic Ringtones,
Monophonic Ringtones
and
Colour Wallpapers
Meble rattanowe dostaniesz w Meble rattanowe oraz rattanowe meble.
nieruchomosci dostaniesz w nieruchomosci oraz nieruchomosci dla biznesu.
!!!
Yikes. Glad you're up and running, but whomever gave you the advice to "reformat and reinstall" should be hung from the highest tree.
Only once in over 15 years of running a Mac have I had to reformat and reinstall (and I've owned or worked on dozens). It's just not usually necessary. That kind of advice is really the easy way out for those who don't know how (or don't want) to troubleshoot.
FWIW, I've been given that advice on the Windows side, too. In fact, that's the usual response I get from Windows techs everywhere. Although I've had to do it much more often on Wintel systems I've owned or maintained, even there it's not always necessary, and a little digging can usually spot the culprit long before you have to take that radical step.
Posted by: Rich at February 16, 2004 04:16 PM