
Out of the blue, three different people approached me yesterday to complain about the blue.
The blue screen of death on their Windows machines, that is.
One was my wife. The two others were acquaintances.
All were frustrated by PC's that kept crashing.
In conversation, without gloating, I told the two friends that I can not recall a single crash of either my G5 Mac desktop or my G4 notebook. Ever. I kept my mouth shut about this around my wife.
I told all three that their machines should be checked for a virus and be cleaned by one of the many tools that remove the adware and spyware that tend to clutter up and crash Windows boxes that are on the Net a lot these days. But before ending the separate conversations with the acquaintances, they both repeated, with a tone of amazement, something to the effect like, "no crashes on your Mac? Ever?"
My wife was a different matter. "Why do I have to use the PC and you get the Mac?" she asked.
She knows, because her desk is near mine, that I no longer have the technical difficulties that characterized my pure PC days.
But she should also know I can't afford a new Mac for her. I promised to spend the evening working on her HP machine.
But I see troubled waters ahead. She's wise to my non-crashing Mac.
Mike--
Not sure what your budget is, but I'm assuming you're familiar with the eMac, yes? You can get a brand-new CDRW/DVD model for $800 or a refurbished one for $700. If your wife doesn't need a DVD or CD burner, you can even get a CD-Rom-only model for $580.
Posted by: Charles Gaba at February 4, 2004 11:19 AMI second Mr. Gaba's position.
The eMac is one of the most overlooked devices that Apple has.
Yes, it is probably in need of some upgrades (FW800/G5) -- but for the money, it is hard to find a better value!
I see... ... I see another Mac in your future.
Posted by: Frederick Kincaid at February 4, 2004 12:12 PMThe best deals I've seen recently are on the refurbished units Apple sells online. Last week they had a G4 800 Mhz combo drive for $499. Plus free shipping.
I've only purchased refurbished for the last 5 years, and I've never had a lick of trouble with them. Unlike the new units, these are actually tested by a human being, and they come with a full warranty.
Posted by: Chip Winter at February 4, 2004 12:28 PMWell, If you cannot afford to get a new mac for her, get a new mac for yourself and let her use it:) Yeah, yeah! That's the ticket:)
Bill Carver
Amateur marriage counselor.
Don't try this at home:)
Posted by: supporttex at February 4, 2004 12:42 PMSpeaking of Macs not crashing, just before updating to Safari 1.2 & Java 1.4.2, I looked at my uptime:
25 days.
I'll take that over WinXP anyday :-)
PS: DEFINITELY get your wife her own Mac, Mike!
Mike,
To be honest, XP crashes far less than previous Microsoft OS's, thanks to a multi-threaded architecture similar to OS X's. Since the core memory is protected, application crashes can't bring the entire OS down. Most XP blue screens can be blamed on driver issues, which take place much closer to the machine's hardware... so I'd start there on your wife's machine.
Posted by: Seth Dimbert at February 4, 2004 02:14 PMSeth is Absolutely right. Buggy software has always caused problems for both PC's and Mac. I had an iMac that crashed quite often when I used Netscape. This was a few years back and I don't remember what version of Netscape it was, although it was the most current at the time.
As far as XP goes, never had a crash.. ever. I have XP on 5 of my computers, and WIN98 second edition on two others. Many crashes are due to not enough ram memory, especially for people that multi task a lot.
WIN XP has made a dummy out of me because it don't have problems. WIN98 is another story though. Win98 keeps me smart.
Posted by: geek at February 4, 2004 03:24 PMI agree with seth too
it is probably hardware
still windows software is nasty and not neat
I'll take XP for several reasons first Seth is correct. I have VERY few problems with XP. Second I do not want to pay top dollar to fix my computer. (Unable to upgrade hardware or purchase replacement parts) Third- I do not want to buy a new system to have the latest OS. Forth- When I shop for software, I do not want to "settle" for a program because that is the only thing available.
Apple's OS is very nice, but there are too many limits or restrictions for me.
My 2 cents
Of course Mike doesnt mention anything about the OS version crashing.
But thats not unexpected given the low quality of his journalism
Mac OS9 was notorious for frequent crashing.
Mike is the worst kind of Mac dilettante: a new one.
The only patch a Windows user needs is right here:
Posted by: Walt at February 4, 2004 08:42 PMKing,
I can't comment on XP's stability -- I'm a Mac user -- but I've heard it's a solid system. That said, the people I know who use XP and OS X prefer the latter. And the people I know who've switched have no regrets and are glad they did, despite having had the same misgivings about software etc. that you describe. The thing about Mac sofware is this -- yes, there's less of it, but there's enough to cover just about everything an average computer user wants to do, and tends to do it as well -- if not better -- than its more numerous Windows counterparts. The iApps are a great example of this. So next time you're in the market for a computer, give a Mac an honest look. It may be that a PC is still a better fit for your needs, but you may also decide that a Mac is just the ticket.
Posted by: scott at February 4, 2004 09:46 PMKing,
Your mention of "Unable to upgrade and buy replacement parts" is simply false and a Mac user or switcher looking for expandability would buy a tower. So regarding your comment, please remember - "You can expand a Mac with tons of ram, fardrive space, and AGP/PCI" as for prox=cessors? most are happy with the G4/G5 and it runs great. As for everything else, what comes standardon our Macs is usually what a pc needs to be upgraded to.
Thanks
Posted by: Sam at February 4, 2004 10:15 PMXP is a stable system, OS X is a stable system. There is a reason to keep a Windows machine around, and it's a good one. Remind your self what computing was like in the 1990's. OS X is 2004.
I wish I could get rid of MS Internet Explorer on my Mac, but alas, so many sites don't work with Safari (and never will), see MacInTouch. For Instance, Weather Channel Map in Motion does not work in Safari. Oops, off topic.
Anyway, Put a PayPal button on your site just for Mrs. W's Mac FUnd, and I'll put in $10.00.
John C,
Try using Firebird from www.mozilla.org. I find it handles most sites where Safari fails. It is also faster than Safari on my G3 and G4 towers.
Posted by: ctolgc at February 5, 2004 12:43 PMFor what it's worth, XP Professional is really a pretty good OS. Very stable. Not as good as OS X, but the best Windows I've used so far. XP Home, however, has problems, at least on the two computers in our house with it. If buying a new computer or upgrading, pay a little more and get the Pro flavor. My Thinkpad with XP Pro is not as stable as my iMac, but it's close.
Posted by: DC at February 5, 2004 02:54 PMIn regard to the weather channel maps, that's why I always go to Accu weather, all of their maps work with safari (and everyother browser that I've tried).
Posted by: Dick Lampe at February 5, 2004 05:09 PMNothing is more admirable than the fortitude with which millionaires
tolerate the disadvantages of their wealth.
-- Nero Wolfe
lipitor
Darth Vader sleeps with a Teddywookie.
lipitor
Hmmmmm interesting !!!
Posted by: polifoniczne dzwonki at June 11, 2004 08:53 PM
Look around for deals on some old G3's. There are lots of fruit-colored iMacs on Ebay for about $300. I have a 400 MHz DVD iMac. It's a little slow, but runs like a top. I love it. Spend a bit more to max out the RAM and your wife can run Jaguar and Safari and have a ball with it. Keep it until you can afford something better. They have decent resale value. Or, you could keep the iMac to dump files onto. As a side note, I visited the Novi Apple store last month. There were two customers there with old Indigo iMacs, being picked up after repair. It proves these old machines are still very much loved. If you go this route, make as sure as you can that the logic board and display are still good.
Posted by: Kel at February 4, 2004 11:03 AM