« Protecting Web privacy is complicated | Main | Removing spyware »

February 02, 2004

Jackson-Timberlake exposure talk of Net

The Net is filled with outrage and reaction over last night's Super Bowl halftime "show."
The pathetic Janet Jackson-Justin Timberlake act shows how degenerate our culture and society has become. The obviously intentional display of Jackson's breast - despite their feigned denial about the "wardrobe malfunction" - embarrassed the whole country.
Drudge claims top CBS execs approved it. Though MTV - which produced the show - denies it was planned, no one really believes them. Reuters quotes an Adweek exec saying "shocking as it was, it was not a mistake. It's really sad. How are we going to up the ante next?"
Kid Rock desecrating the American flag and singing about hookers was bad enough. So were the incessant sexual enhancement ads and junior high humor of some of the Budweiser spots.
But the pathetic no-talent Jackson-Timberlake display marks a new low for a culture that insists on making the most morally bankrupt among us "celebrities."


in News | TrackBack (0)

Comments

Agreed.

Posted by: baw at February 2, 2004 08:18 AM

For starters, if you're worried about morality, then don't hire rappers to do a halftime show...that's pretty much a no-brainer.

As for Janet and Justin, it's funny how televison can be filled with gratuitous violence day in and day out, but show 2 seconds of a woman's breast...give me a break, people.

Posted by: SD at February 2, 2004 09:37 AM

I was more outraged that Kid Rock was wearing an actual American flag as a poncho. He actually just cut a head hole in a flag and wore it on stage. Just a few minutes earlier I saw these giant football players choking up during the national anthem and the tribute to the Columbia astronauts and then that skinny freak desicrates (sp) the flag. I'd rather see more boobs and less flag destroying.

Posted by: CD at February 2, 2004 09:42 AM

I agree with BAW. If you did not want a controvertial show they should have not gotten rapers. The dirty dancing that Justin & Janet were doing, before the breast, where discracfull also. Then Nelly was singing about"take your clothes off". These are clear indications about what is to come. CBS is as bad as MTV. Pay Attention People!!!!

Posted by: Fawn at February 2, 2004 09:55 AM

Anything produced by MTV should be suspect. The NFL should have known better in the first place.

Posted by: Jeff at February 2, 2004 10:00 AM

I know there's millions to be made on the Super Bowl. But I wish that MTV and others who purposely put this stuff in a halftime show could be banned from participating, say for a few years. I also wish that the FCC would set up limits as to what is permissible. I know that won't happen, but with the way things are going, will tv viewing be only for adults?

Posted by: Kel at February 2, 2004 10:11 AM

They didn't want controvery by showing the MoveOn.org anti-Bush commercial but this is OK? Maybe it is karma?

Posted by: Kirk Tirakian at February 2, 2004 10:46 AM

Ya know, it's not that I'm some prude who's anti-bosoms, it's just that I don't want them in my face when I'm watching football with youngsters.

Then again, the fact that Janet Jackson exposed herself to kids should be of no surprise.

I do however think it a bit wierd and wasteful that that a vendor of adult beverages would pitch their product with high-school hijinx.

BTW, you've been blogged.

Posted by: Mean Dean at February 2, 2004 11:02 AM

Well, the FCC's beginning an investigation into last night's 'spectacle'. One spokesman said that he doubted MTV would be producing any more half-time shows.

Posted by: Kel at February 2, 2004 12:03 PM

just what does this have to do w/ technology? because you threw a few links in there? i enjoy your work mike but was this really the forum to voice your displeasure over a stupid half-time show?

Posted by: m. whyte at February 2, 2004 12:17 PM

To m. whyte...

I'm not sue why Mike put this on the Blog. However, I've notice that Mike covers the culture of technology as much as he does the izmos themselves.

I wonder if this story would have been as big as it is - had it not been for the Internet. The Internet which allows for unlimited publishing of a still photo that was viewable on TV for literally just a second or two.

Interesting how this device called the world wide web has changed us so much culturally.

Posted by: jra at February 2, 2004 01:08 PM

jra - That's a bit of a stretch. By your reasoning, just about any topic or story is 'tech related.'

Mike - Your Mac blog was good. This blog is a waste of time. If I wanted a daily dose of 'family values' moralizing, I'd tune into the 700 Club. Adios Amigo.

Posted by: chimpee at February 2, 2004 01:18 PM

Come on! What do you expect from a woman who sings "Got a nice package alright//guess I'm gonna have to ride it tonight"? It's not as though we expect someone like that to exhibit high moral fiber.

MTV put on a sex-laden halftime show with rappers who grab their crotches, rednecks who deface the American flag and wear it like a scarf, and an oversexed member of a dysfunctional family who bared her breast in a well-publicized "accident". Is anyone REALLY surprised here?

At least the pre-game show had some class.

Posted by: Anonymous at February 2, 2004 02:08 PM

Lighten up. There are many more important life and death issues out there besides whether or not Janet showed her breast.

Morality is relative.

Not to get too philosophical, but if you want to talk about immorality you should start with the fact that a thirty second commercial cost 1.9 million dollars, but there is not enough money in the country to provide a decent public education to millions of American children.

I think Janet's boob on National TV is the least of our worries.

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 2, 2004 02:23 PM

"Morality is relative?" Karl?

That means if I choose to kill someone for looking at me wrong and I think it's OK, that means it's morally right?

No, morality is not relative to the individual. It is, however, relative to the culture. Most Europeans probably think what Janet and Justin did is no big deal. Having lived in Europe, I'd probably agree. However, what they did is still against the prevailing Judeo/Christian-based morality that is prevalent in this country and is reflected in our system of broadcasting laws which will probably end up penalizing someone for what happened, particularly if they can prove it was intentional (sorry for the long sentence).

What disturbs me most about all this is that it is quite apparent that Mr. Timberlake knew what he was doing, yet he claims it was not planned. I don't know how high up the knowledge of this stunt went, but I am quite sure he knew what he was doing, and Ms. Jackson probably did as well.
If it comes out that they have been flat out lying about it, that would disturb me much more than having seen a breast, which I actually find quite pleasureable in most cases, but the silver star was a bit of a turnoff for me.

Overall, I think something is out of whack that more attention is being given the appearance of a breast on prime-time TV than what they were singing just moments before and how they were dancing.

T

Posted by: toeknee at February 2, 2004 03:37 PM

I do not think we disagree Toenee. We seem to agree that morality is relative. It is not that I do not think that ethics and morality should be discussed, because I do. I just think that everyone should relax and put this whole issue into some kind of perspective.

It is an oversimplification of an issue to compare someone exposing their breast on live television to murder. Murder is a whole different ball of wax that the American culture is also obsessed with, better discussed on other forums at other times.

To me, a boob on TV is just a boob on TV. I will admit however that it is quite cowardly and immature of Justin and Janet not to fess up. Accountability and ownership of what one does is a mark of virtue no matter what the subject matter is. (Sorry for the fortune cookie.)

That being said, it is still not the end of the world and in relative matters this is equal to...say...Elvis shaking his hips on Ed Sullivan.

It is by no means Galileo discovering that the Earth is not the center of the Universe.

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 2, 2004 04:35 PM

Solution.....
No more "professional entertainers" at the at the super bowl other than the teams. How about bringing something like the MacDonald's all-star marching band or another national respectable type of musicial recognition of achievement on the part of high school and/or college students in their field. It would be a far classier event than any multi million dollar halftime event.

Posted by: supporttex at February 2, 2004 05:13 PM

Is morality really relative? Are you really sure that it is? Because if we claim that morality is relative and nothing more than the byproduct of a socio-cultural or an evolutionary process, then really no person or culture can claim that their morality is “better” or “higher” than another. Using an extreme example, it would be difficult to logically condemn Nazism if no objective moral values exist; and that may very well prove dangerous.

To quote Victor Frankl, "If we present man with a concept of man which is not true, we may well corrupt him. When we present him as . . . a bundle of instincts, as a pawn of drive and reactions, as a mere product of heredity and environment, we feed the nihilism to which modern man is, in any case, prone.

"I became acquainted with the last stage of corruption in my second concentration camp, Auschwitz. The gas chambers of Auschwitz were the ultimate consequence of the theory that man is nothing but the product of heredity and environment . . . I am absolutely convinced that the gas chambers of Auschwitz, Treblinka, and Maidanek were ultimately prepared not in some ministry of defense or other in Berlin, but rather at the desks and in lecture halls of nihilistic scientists and philosophers."

All ideas have consequences -- no matter how big or small. No matter if the ideas deal with the philosophy of Nazism or Janet Jackson breasts…

Posted by: Jess at February 2, 2004 09:39 PM

To put it in perspective, Channel 4 News (in the UK) showed the clip in its 7pm broadcast last night. How repressed is the US? Getting all worked up about a brief flash of breast, while not giving a damn that people the world over are living in hellish conditions of poverty and exploitation so that the Western world (read: mostly the US) can have an obscenely rich standard of living. Now *that's* worth getting outraged about, people.

Posted by: Tim at February 3, 2004 04:57 AM

Right.
And Britain, Europe in particular, is suppossed to be an example?
It's your totallty godless and immoral culture that we see America embracing and that's what offends us so.

Posted by: Ralph at February 3, 2004 07:09 AM

Ralph,

I don't mean to offend, but if you read your Bible you'll see that a lot more is said condemning society's treatment of the poor than about public nudity (though JJ's 'performance' could hardly be described as 'nudity')!

As a Christian, I think there's something wrong when more attention is given to 'outrages' like JJ than to what are, in my view, far more pressing matters, like poverty, unequal distribution of wealth and opportunity, the environment, health care etc.

Yours in Christ,

Posted by: Tim at February 3, 2004 08:44 AM

Once again, this issue remains about the relativity of morality.

As far as I am concerned, this issue is blown way out of proportion.

Two examples of how morality is relative.

First a smaller instance:

How much do you "value" a jar of peanut butter?

How much do you think a starving child in Rwanda would "value" a jar of peanut butter?

Second a couple larger issues of the relative morality.

If you are British in 1776 then the American "Savages" that we consider our Revolutionaries used "uncivilized" guerilla and terrorist warfare tactics to defeat them.

If you are an American in the mid-1800's then the "savages" or Native American's were "uncivilized" for fighting to try and keep their own land that we stole from them.

In laymen's terms, to the Indians we were the evil white men and to the white men, they were the evil savages.

So, who was right?

Those are just two examples and I could go on for days. However, the most important point in all of this is that it is awefully arrogant and presumptuous to think that any one man is more moral than his neighbor. Especially when the judged has done nothing to actually harm the judge.

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 3, 2004 09:53 AM

Ralph,

With all due respect, speak for yourself. You do not represent all of America's attitude.

Posted by: SD at February 3, 2004 10:26 AM

And one last thing on the issue.

It is a complete waste of taxpayer money to have the FCC investigate this incident.

Come on people! There are starving children out there! The greatest generation can't afford health insurance! Three million people don't have and can't get a job!

Who cares about Janet's Breast!!!??? The media is just playing right into her hands...or should I say bossum?

As far as I am concerned, Janet has won and the joke is on you!

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 3, 2004 11:31 AM

Karl,

I appreciate your opinion... I really do. My problem with your argument is that by using the words "arrogant" and "presuptious", you are in fact making a moral judgement. Didn't you just say that it is wrong for one man to say that he is more moral than another?

The problem with folks who believe that morality is relative is that they have no basis for making a moral pronouncement on someone else. Personally, I do believe in an OBJECTIVE moral values. I do believe that Nazism is wrong. I believe that child pornography is wrong. I believe that rape is evil. I believe in being faithful to my wife (who, by the way, has very nice looking breasts). AND I can defend my beliefs because I have an objective standard to base my moral values.

Since I believe in good and evil, I also believe that there is a MORAL LAW that help me to differentiate between what is good and evil. And since I believe there is a moral law, I also believe in a moral law GIVER who is loving, kind, compassionate, pure, and faultless. And from this moral law GIVER, I receive direction, purpose, wholeness, and tremendous joy in my life.

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 3, 2004 01:17 PM

If nothing else Jess, most of our opinion of what is moral is the same.

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 3, 2004 02:15 PM

My point of arrogance and presumption was that of a general human condition, not of a judgement of values or morality.

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 3, 2004 02:20 PM

Karl,

I glad that we share common moral values. And I hope that you did not think that I was labeling you as "immoral" because you believe that morality is relative. I have tons of friend who believe that morality is relative and are extremely good people.

I think that our point of difference is that you believe that morality is somewhat based on culture and "opinion", and I believe that there exists a standard for morals that is CONSTANT and UNCHANGING. For instance, even if every single person in this world believed that Nazism was right. It would still be OBJECTIVELY morally wrong DESPITE the fact that everyone thought the contrary (i.e. regardless of culture AND opinion).

Just more philosophical rambling that somehow started from Janet Jackson's boobs... Who would have ever thought?

Jess

BTW, what did you think about the quote from Victor Frankl? I'm interested in hearing your opinion.

Posted by: Jess at February 3, 2004 02:45 PM

I don't have too much time for an elaborate opinion on the Frank quote, so I have to keep it short.

I believe that Human Beings are extremely complicated. They are effected by everything from genetics to their environment to their instincts. If you took an exact replica of the same child and gave one child to Hitler to raise and you gave the other child to Ghandi to raise it is my opinion that you would have a completely different child with a completely different set of ethics.

Some things are completely instict. Just as a whale is born knowing how to swim, a human child is born knowing how to swallow and smile when they are happy.

So, therefore, I think that Frank is part right, just as most theories and quotes like that are. They are specific to the point they are trying to make and often very insightful.

I don't consider the baring of Janet's Breast as an issue of morality. Just a matter of poor judgement and a different set of values.

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 3, 2004 10:13 PM

In your example, you said, “If you took an exact replica of the same child and gave one child to Hitler to raise and you gave the other child to Gandhi to raise it is my opinion that you would have a completely different child with a completely different set of ethics.”

I agree… But whose ethic would be better? If you say that morality is relative, can you really claim that one ethic is superior to another?

My point is this – if we say that morality is simply the ebb and flux of cultural trends, genetic predispositions, and environmental influences, we travel on a VERY slippery slope. Why? Because now we're stuck! We can no longer say that rape is bad or murder is evil because it's all RELATIVE. Morality is then muddied down to a homogenized goo that is really useful for nothing...

Now where will this "slippery slope" lead us? Sometimes the slide will only take us to Janet Jackson flashing some skin (relatively harmless in the grand scheme of things). But other times, when things go really wrong, it leads to people like Dr. Josef Mengele who castrated poor Jewish boys as part of his experiments in the Nazi concentration camps.

I am of the Christian ethic, and personally I find that life is much more livable when I know that there is a morality that transcends my personal tastes and preferences.

Posted by: Jess at February 4, 2004 12:15 AM

She's clearly a terrorist. Rumsfeld should have her executed.

And it was just done to get some heat off Michael. She was being a good sister. Leave her alone.

Posted by: Craig Carmichael at February 4, 2004 01:26 AM

My goodness. There hasn't been this much attention given to a boob on TV since GW Bush's last state of the union address.

Posted by: Justin Thyme at February 4, 2004 08:15 AM

I agree Justin. This was not the ice capades. It was a football game.

Jess,

You said it exactly right. You are a Christian. And your set of morales are different than a Buddhist set of morales or an Islamic set of morales and the 130 or so recognized World Religions around the world sets of morales.

I think Plato said it best when he said, "Good people do not need laws to tell them to act responsibly, while bad people will find a way around the laws."

I think there is a general consensus on what is good and what is bad. The argument is on the levels of good and the levels of bad and what the consequences of those actions are.

For instance, some would even say that even closing your eyes and imagining sex before you are married is just as immoral as having sex before you are married. That is an interpretation and relative opinion of morality.

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 4, 2004 10:26 AM

Based on the volume of response to Mike's blog on this subject, I guess whoever said "There's no such thing as bad publicity" was right!

In public, the networks, sponsors, etc., are expressing outrage about the whole thing, but in private, you know there's a lot of celebrating going on.

Sad.

Posted by: Joe at February 4, 2004 12:13 PM

Karl, when you said that there is a “general" consensus on what is good and bad, I think you are ABSOLUTELY right. However, with so many different cultures, with evolution selecting out violence and aggression as the dominant trait, and with so many external influence acting on humanity, why should there be any “general" consensus for basic human morality at all?

One theory is that we were DESIGNED that way. C.S. Lewis discusses this topic eloquently in his book “Mere Christianity”. (In case you don’t know him… C.S. Lewis wrote The Chronicles of Narnia… The movie Shadowland was made as a bibliography of his life… I believe Anthony Hopkins plays Lewis). If you want to do something to get the images of Janet Jackson’s breasts out of your head, you might want to give “Mere Christianity” a try. It’s a good read with some really good intellectual thinking...

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 4, 2004 11:01 PM

Yes, I like C.S. Lewis. He was a very intelligent man; in my humble opinion.

"However, with so many different cultures, with evolution selecting out violence and aggression as the dominant trait, and with so many external influence acting on humanity, why should there be any “general" consensus for basic human morality at all?"

That is what makes us different from the monkeys and the elephants and the whales. It is our conscious and self-awareness that makes us a "civilized" society. The idea of civility however depends on your "place" in the class chain. Of course, that's a whole differnet story. :)

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 5, 2004 12:13 AM

I think the whole discussion is pathetic. First of all it was something not important. I thought this is the 21st century and not 200 years ago. But there are still people and this seems to me a lot of people who are very very prude. that is a shame. The thing is Janets breast got exposed so what and it was on television so what? One could not even see the whole of the breast. Stop putting to much into this. Something like that is not the end of the world.

Posted by: do at February 5, 2004 04:31 PM

do,

I think that the vast majority of poster (including me) believe that this booby issue has gotten more attention than neccessary.

If you actually read the posts, you would have noticed that most of the later posts have had NOTHING to do with Janet's breasts... Instead, the discussion has been focusing on "Where does human morality actually come from?" And honestly, I enjoyed the discussion and I've been having fun "chewing the cud".

Besides, as far as I know, nobody is really reading this thread anymore... Except for maybe me and Karl (well... maybe Karl has given up too... I know that my brain is tired...)

BTW, it was nice discussing the issues with you Karl... Best intellectual brainstorming that I've had in a long time... It was nice comparing notes without any name-calling or other ridiculous webisms...

I bet if we'd ever met, we'd have some interesting discussions (after a few Buds, of course)...

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 5, 2004 05:42 PM

Likewise Jess. :)

Posted by: Karl Frank at February 5, 2004 06:00 PM

Whew! This was one of the most spirited - and far ranging discussions - I've ever seen on this blog.
Thanks everyone.
Even though there was disagreement, it was pretty cordial and always interesting... even as we strayed far from technology.
Thanks again!

Posted by: Mike Wendland at February 5, 2004 06:53 PM

I agree Mike...

Now time to change some poopy diapers (literally)...

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 5, 2004 07:49 PM

One last thing... Thanks for putting together this blog Mike... I visit it every day!

And I love my mac...

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 5, 2004 08:41 PM

It's been said you can prove just about anything using the Bible. Apparently that includes relative morality.

One of the top ten rules says "thou shall not lie". But there's a story about a highly respected woman who hid God's people in her house to protect them from their enemies. When the enemies came to the door the woman told them God's people weren't there. The woman later received praise for this as I recall. The practical lesson I get from this is that when you need protection from your enemies be sure to hide in the house of friends who believe in moral relativity.

Posted by: david at February 7, 2004 10:24 PM

You can prove almost anything with ANY source if you misrepresent it...

"To try to explain truth to him who loves it not, is but to give him more plentiful material for misinterpretation."

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 9, 2004 01:16 PM

You can prove almost anything with ANY source if you misrepresent it...

"To try to explain truth to him who loves it not, is but to give him more plentiful material for misinterpretation."

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 9, 2004 01:16 PM

You can prove almost anything with ANY source if you misrepresent it...

To quote George Macdonald, "To try to explain truth to him who loves it not, is but to give him more plentiful material for misinterpretation."

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 9, 2004 01:17 PM

Sorry for the multiple posts... Something was messed up with my browser...

Jess

Posted by: Jess at February 9, 2004 01:19 PM

The wise programmer is told about the Tao and follows it. The average
programmer is told about the Tao and searches for it. The foolish programmer
is told about the Tao and laughs at it. If it were not for laughter, there
would be no Tao.
The highest sounds are the hardest to hear. Going forward is a way to
retreat. Greater talent shows itself late in life. Even a perfect program
still has bugs.
-- Geoffrey James, "The Tao of Programming"
lipitor

Posted by: lipitor at May 25, 2004 05:36 PM

Hmmmmm interesting !!!

Posted by: polifoniczne dzwonki at June 11, 2004 08:33 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits