
The video review I did on Apple's GarageBand fed this morning on the NBC-TV News Channel network to the affiliates and MSNBC. It starts airing today on stations across the country.
Here's a link to my newspaper review from the Freep earlier this week.
Too bad it is for Apple compatible machines. I was ready to buy it for my Gateway. Is there any program comparable to this for PC? Joe
Posted by: joe at January 29, 2004 09:54 AMToo bad it is for Apple compatible machines. I was ready to buy it for my Gateway. Is there any program comparable to this for PC? Joe
Posted by: joe at January 29, 2004 09:55 AMMike,
We have had "Garage Band" for a couple of weeks now. You are right, it is way cool and we have created some really great sounding loops with it. We have a G4 and a 17" iMac (all networked wireless with an Airport of course) and have lots of fun with it.
Apple has the market on cool stuff!
Terry
Joe:
The comparable program to Garage Band is called "ACID Pro", once made by Sonic Foundry, but now marketed by Sony. You'll find it to be nearly the equal to GarageBand if all you're doing is mixing loops. Where GB shines is in its ability to let you use a keyboard with its built-in virtual instruments, its superior editing capabilities, and (IMHO), better interface.
ACID Pro is also a $450 program (according to the SONY catalog in front of me). Figure THAT into your total cost when you're considering the Gateway.
ACID used to be the best reason to buy a PC. In fact, I once bought a cheap PC specifically to run it. Now, IMHO, GarageBand (and the rest of the iLife suite) may be the best reason to buy a Mac. Seriously, if you can find the dollars, you should consider the Mac. The iLife suite makes it a very compelling option.
Posted by: Rich at January 29, 2004 10:16 AMAcid pro and Cake walk may be the closest combination needed to come close to GB's abilities.
I've had GB for a week too and some recording pros I know were over the other day to see it and they are lost for words because of what it's able to do.
The ability to record/mix 48 tracks live and software instruments is amazing, and at $49 they figured it would be a cool $500 plus to do the same in a PC and even then some PC's built in core audio is not up there with what is standard on a Mac.
I'm feeling fortunate!
go to icompositions.com and listen to a track called "No Regrets" by liquidg3 (in the main Auditorium. The vocals were recorded on the little pinhole mic of a flat panel iMac, you won't believe it.
Posted by: Sam at January 29, 2004 11:10 AMSam, I listened to 'No Regrets' and WOW is all I can say!
I can't wait to get a new Mac and GB!
Kel
Posted by: Kel at January 29, 2004 01:26 PMFor the price of a comparable PC App and the hardware to support it. Go ahead and buy a eMac for between 700-799 (comes with 17" monitor). Or get an iBook for 999. Better prices for education customers.
You'll never look back, it comes with the iLife '04 sweet and so much more.
Posted by: stingerman at January 29, 2004 02:21 PMMike,
I hate Mac's. I also hate Garage Bands..... So I ask, why would I want a Garage Band on a Mac?
Posted by: Armejjedon! at January 29, 2004 08:09 PMStingerman,
If I may butt in and answer your question even before Mike gets around to it...
Since you hate Macs and you hate garage bands then you definitely should not buy Garage Band on a Mac. I guess it's just for the rest of us.
-Cyphierre
Posted by: Cyphierre at January 29, 2004 10:03 PMWOW!....great song
http://www.icompositions.com/auditorium1/data/502/216No_Regrets.mp3
Cyphierre,
You had the wrong person, Stingerman is for Macs, not against.
Armejjedon!
The answer is simple if you hate Macs (probably without experience using a Mac running OSX) then just leave it alone you don't need one.
None the less, if you want to make the most of a computing platform that integrates productivity software or creative software like iLife then you will be better off with Mac in the short and long.
All I'll say is if music/video/DVD authoring is your cup then a Mac is king of the hill.
If Office and extreme basic usage is your cup the Mac does it brilliantly and a PC will do it too.
Kel,
My mistake. Thanks for the correction.
Sorry, Stingerman.
-Cyphierre
Posted by: Cyphierre at January 30, 2004 09:44 AMWhy do you and others portray Dead's speech as a rant and that of a madman? It went over well with the croud that was there and I've seen speeches like that from many people trying to fire up a croud. What is it the media is afraid of should he get elected? He is the only current running canidate I could vote for as the rest are lackeys of the multinational coorperations that control the media and the government from Bush through both houses. Again, I feel the outcome of the election has already been picked.
Posted by: gnuorder at January 30, 2004 12:06 PM"Why do you and others portray Dead's speech as a rant and that of a madman?"
"Dead"? Was that a Freudian slip? ;-)
Posted by: Kent W at January 31, 2004 08:12 AMIf you are going to buy a Mac to get GarageBand, make sure you get one that is able to handle the processing demands. 48 tracks MIGHT require a bit more beef than an eMac offers. Check with Apple first before buying. Also, iLife 04 comes with current Macs, or it should. Make sure it does. Buy from the AppleStore and it will but may not with other vendors until the channel gets updated.
Posted by: PecosBill at February 2, 2004 01:08 PMThe professor makes the syllabus, not you.
i'm living so far beyond my income that we may almost be said to be
living apart.
-- e. e. cummings
lipitor
The mirror sees the man as beautiful, the mirror loves the man; another
mirror sees the man as frightful and hates him; and it is always the same
being who produces the impressions.
-- Marquis D.A.F. de Sade
lipitor
Never reveal your best argument.
lipitor
Hmmmmm interesting !!!
Posted by: dzwonki polifoniczne nokia at June 11, 2004 08:53 PM
Very nice Mike, very nice.
Posted by: Sam at January 29, 2004 09:42 AM