
My Freep column today is on SBC's ambitious plans to increase DSL penetration by building out the network while offering aggressive price cuts that see first time residential users billed $26.95 a month for the first year.
Theoretically, cable is faster than DSL. But that's in an ideal world. The Net is never ideal. Depending on traffic congestion, real speeds vary from second to second. And cable Internet is networked, or shared, meaning that if your entire neighborhood logs on and starts downloading music at the same time, your connection speed could noticeably slow.
Here's a pretty good comparison of cable vs DSL speeds that cites a Keynote systems test that found that cable networking problem seriously degraded cable performance during the 5pm to 11pm Net primetime, giving DSL: a distinct advantage.
Like religion and politics, people and purists will argue about which is the best. Personally, I've had cable for close to three years now and have never noticed any slowing. DSL is unavailable in my area because of the big limitation of DSL - you need to be relatively close to a telephone company central office to get it. Although I live in one of the fastest growing communities in the nation, I can't even get an estimate of when DSL will be available here.
And at this point, I'm so pleased with my cable Internet service that I wouldn't even consider switching. But for those who balk at the generally stiffer rates of cable Net access, that $26.95 DSL price sounds pretty attractive.
If they can get it.
That's a very worrisome point indeed. I doubt it holds up legally speaking, but who's going to pursue a lawsuit against them?
I have SBC in the Lansing area, and the only reason I am going with them over cable is the dirt cheap rate and my poor student status. Otherwise cable is superior in every meaningful way in my experience. With cable you rarely get the dropped connections that are commond with finicky DSL connections. True, you may notice some cable slowdown at peak, but if you're not moving big files around I doubt it will affect you much.
SBC's biggest problem continues to be horrible customer service. You may get a nice cheap rate for 12 months, but you will pay for it in time spent on the phone. Prepare to be charged for equipment you never received, and spend countless hours talking to clueless reps. They'll give you a different case number after every conversation, but any one you call back will never ask for it, and they'll just proceed to ask you to re-explain the whole problem over again.
When my 12 months is up, the only way I would stay is if they renew my low rate (which I hear happens quite often) because they have to be kidding at $50/mo regular price.
Posted by: Douglas Santos at January 26, 2004 12:24 PMRemember that ability to get DSL and the maximum speed you can get on your line are dependent on your distance from the CO (phone company's Central Office.) Does anyone have any solid figures on what percentage of phone company customers are even within the reach of DSL?
Posted by: George at January 26, 2004 12:26 PMWith the negative experiences posted above, let me throw in my positive experience with SBC/ Yahoo. I have had the service since last July. so far my experience has been fantastic. I get a nice solid, relatively fast connection (around 540 Kbps) and I've not had any major problems. Occasionally I've had to reset the modem, but the service has always worked. I also get a dial-up account included for when I'm on the road (although the number of access points is significantly smaller than with earthlink, which I keep for a backup ISP.) My only complain is that I cannot get in on the $26.95 deal. I signed up at $29.95 & have been getting that rate for the last year and a half. All in all, I'm very pleased with them & have no plans on changing providers.
Posted by: Mark at January 26, 2004 03:22 PMI too have cable and wouldn't consider switching. I've heard all the stories above and more.
On the cable side, I noticed that I was paying $10 more per month to WOW than they advertise on their website. I called them and they cheerfully switched me to the lower rate, which is good for a year. That's WOW service.
Posted by: Liz Smith at January 26, 2004 03:44 PMI have had sbc yahoo DSL for about 6 months and too am pleased. $29.95 per month for me and works fine. Customer service for new accounts is great, tech is not so good. Always blaming it on your computer configuration when I have found that from 10:00 to 10:30 am they shut you off for some admin work on their end about once every month. As mysteriously as you are cut off it comes back on fine. Until I can afford a T1 at home it is the convenience of DSL for me.
Posted by: SurfinSteve at January 26, 2004 06:52 PMAs a SBC employee I'd like to comment on a few of the posts.
SBC wants you to sign a one year agreement because they are giving you a free modem or wireless home networking kit, along with free activation and a self installation kit, and in some cases other free promotions, along with a discounted monthly rate. I'm sure if you have your own modem ($70 to 100 at Best Buy, wireless is more) and your own filters (contained in the installation kit and $10.29 each at Radio Shack; one for each phone, computer modem, or answering machine; I have six at my home) and would like to pay for the activation and the full monthly rate; you wouldn't have to sign a one year agreement. There is nothing illegal or unethical about this. You are committing to a one year agreement in return for the free and discounted services. These one year agreements are very much like some cable companies use, to give their customers a free modem, free installation, and discounted monthly service; for both cable TV and internet service. Dish Network and Direct TV do the same kind of marketing.
I have had both cable and DSL and have not found DSL to be "finicky". I have even had my DSL work when I had a problem with my phone service. When I had a cable modem there were times in the evenings when I could "sense" a slow down, but I would have to agree, unless you are moving big files around it wouldn't affect you very much. The average person can only go so fast on the internet, and then you find you are waiting on the other end, because it's now slower than your end.
The ability to get DSL is not solely dependent on how far you are from the central office. Outside facilities need to be changed and upgraded for DSL the further you go from a central office. It's a money issue. Remember when you didn't have cable TV, but the neighbors on the other side of town did? New things take time, and money.
Dealing with problems about any service can sometimes be a problem. Just remember that your phone service and internet service are distinct and different (SBC Local Services / SBC Internet Services) and you need to talk to the right person about your problem.
My local cable company had start up problems when they first started installing cable modems, but now they are doing a fine job and are a worthy competitor. Everyone has a learning curve to go through during a start up of something new.
What do I like best about DSL? When the power goes out (about 3 or 4 times a year here) my DSL keeps working. No lights, no cable TV, but my computer and modem are plugged into a UPS and I just keep on playing, I mean working the internet. I also like the free dial tone access when I'm away from my DSL service. That was an extra cost option when I had cable access. I like the idea I'm not sharing my internet access with anyone else.
Posted by: Frederick Kincaid at January 26, 2004 08:26 PM"I like the idea I'm not sharing my internet access with anyone else."
But you are, Blanche! You are in that chair!
Posted by: spoonyfork at January 27, 2004 12:47 AMI think the 'SBC Employee' missed the point of the original thread. SBC refuses to refund or cancel the contract without a penalty - even if SBC acknowledges that they failed to provide any service! Anyone with the least bit knowledable of contract law knows that this is a total lack of consideration, and that the contract is void. This is of little concern to SBC who then continues to bill the helpless customer, and ruining their credit if they refuse to continue paying. It actually runs painfully close to racketeering.
That being said, I have no problem with the 12 month contract length, I was happy to sign it at the nice low rate provided they actually delivered service. I don't think that's asking too much.
And check a sight like dslreports.com and look at the big picture, its clear that describing DSL as 'finicky' is quite fair. In many cases, the service provider can't even give you a straight answer about whether or not the service will work until they hook it up. And even they they can't be sure. Often it will require a service visit from a technician (usually free) so they can test the line.
Anyway, I still have plenty of good things to say about the service. Its fast for me, with tested speeds north of 1000k. The startup kit is really excellent as stated, with software, line filters, all the cords, and even an extra NIC if you need it. Service was always friendly, if not particularly helpful. And the dial up access is good to have. I just think the regular price needs to come down for it to be competitive.
Posted by: Douglas Santos at January 28, 2004 08:23 PMWIthout experience I can't judge DSL vs Cable performance. BUt what riles me about SBC employee's post is the line:
"Remember when you didn't have cable TV, but the neighbors on the other side of town did? New things take time, and money."
The Phone Company/Companies have had YEARS to develop, deploy and market DSL, and prior to that failed to deploy ISDN, which could have, at that time, replaced POTS dialup service. The Phone Companies flat out failed to realize the interest and potential of broadband access to individual home customers, didn't want to take a long-term view (a familiar modern business practice), and also didn't want to have to provide access to ISP's, even though they've never been very good at the ISP business.
I follow your column and read today's article on SBC's DSL. It is important to know that SBC wants people and/or companies to sign a one to two year agreement that says they will have to pay a fee if they leave early for any reason including SBC's failure to perform.
Posted by: Ron at January 26, 2004 10:07 AMBefore signing any contract, I ask what it SBC fails to perform, such as the lines being down constantly or it taking days to fix a problem or problems week after week. The answer was that would never happen. When I pointed it has, I was told SBC would not allow any change to the contract requiring SBC's performance, or the right to leave SBC without a penalty, even if SBC failed to perform. I have talked to Management all the way up the line to Illinois, and although SBC wants a guarantee for a number of monthly payments, it will not guarantee the service customers will be paying for.
Ron