
Whoa!!! I just heard HD radio, a new technology that allows regular AM and FM radio stations to broadcast in the equivalent of high definition. It is stunning. CD-quality for FM, FM-quality for AM. Receivers will cost about $300 and 100 stations around the country are planning or already broadcasting in this new mode. It's the biggest thing for radio since FM in the 1940's. Trust me, one listen and you'll want it.
yeah, ive heard it too. It's called XM Satellite Radio. ;-)
Posted by: afpilot at January 9, 2004 09:06 AMWell the technical info on their site is a little thin, but overall it seems like an interesting step forward for the radio stations. It appears to just be a digital format and high compression scheme using the existing bands? Backward compatibility is key, although the satellite providers offer a lot more benefits it seems - of course they aren't free unfortunately. Still their business case seems weak, this seems like a pricey upgrade for both broadcasters and users who aren't really gaining all that much.
I have seen many 'high def' audio formats come and go over the years in various forms. My take has always been that fidelity has yet to sell a new music format - only better content and more convenient access. Did CD's offer better fidelity than tape? Not really, but the track access sold it in the end. Super Audio CD, DVD Audio, etc, all superior fidelity sound theoreticaly, but consumers didn't care, they want features. Witness the popularity of MP3 and others, all very lossy low fidelity schemes but insanely popular with people.
Posted by: Douglas Santos at January 10, 2004 12:27 AM"Did CD's offer better fidelity than tape? Not really"
Huh? What are you smoking? The difference between CD and tape is like the difference between the view from a stained-glass window and a clear one.
Sometimes quality wins (think CDs versus cassettes or 8-tracks; DVD versus VHS). Sometimes it doesn't (think VHS vs.Beta, Windows vs. Mac OS). Be careful when you generalize.
Posted by: Rich at January 12, 2004 12:26 PMSheesh, where to begin. Be careful when you don't read the comment carefully. First of all I was talking strictly about audio fidelity, so your comments about windows vs mac are way off point, not to mention your comment presupposes that Mac is superior to Windows despite Microsofts dominance - this is a road no one should go down. Second CD never competed against 8-tracks, they were completely absent from the market when CD was out. Same goes for your VHS vs Beta comment, it is something of an urban legend that beta was a vastly superior format technically, but still lost. This is patently untrue, in any real world comparison the video/audio was close to indestinguishable. The real reason form VHS success was a market (non-product one) one, Beta failed to offer generic tapes and didn't properly enter the rental market.
But back to the main point. I am not smoking anything at the moment thanks. And CD and the common cassette tape are not as night and day as many hazily remember in the quality area. In fact analog auido tapes actually offer significant technical superiority to the lossy CD standard in many areas (superior dynamic range and headroom for one - which is also the reason many high volume applications such as discos cannot use CD, but resort to vinyl, tape, or high resolution digital such as MD, ATTRAC, etc). CD's advantage is that the digital format is superior for storing information, and never degraded over time the way tapes did. A good tape will sound just as good if not better than a CD. Much depends on the mastering process as well, there are good tapes and bad CDs and vice versa. In the early days of CDs many found the treble virtually unlistinable since studios still did not understand the proper equalization required for the format.
My point is still this, it was feature improvement, not audio quality that sold CD and other new formats, and continues to till this day.
Posted by: Douglas Santos at January 12, 2004 02:11 PM
If you think HD Radio is nice, you should check out XM or Sirius Satellite Radio. I'm an XM subscriber for over a year & it rocks! It's crystal clear & you have (in XM's case) 121 channels to choose from, all the news, sports, talk, & music you could want.
Posted by: Mark at January 8, 2004 09:44 PM