
I hit Las Vegas late Tuesday and was able to catch the Innovations Showcase design and engineering awards party for the 2004 Consumer Electronics Show last night.
Cool products that I'll be writing about in the newspaper and here on Tech-knowledge all week aside - think plasma and LCD TV's, DVD audio, multimedia players and even satellite TV for cars - there was lots of talk about MacWorld over in San Francisco by the early-arriving and freeloading journalists who were filling up on the lavish food and drinks at the pre-show party.
Main reaction to all the Steve Jobs MacWorld announcements: At $249, the new iPod mini is still way too much money. One woman journalist from LA said her son had wanted an iPod for Christmas but she held out buying one because it would have broken her budget. She says the mini is still too much.
A Mac-using New York City journalist pal of mine said the same thing. "It had to be $200 or less to get us excited," he said of his outfit. A reporter for one of the tech magazines who caught Jobs keynote this morning and then flew here afterwards said he thought the price was high but that the iPod had such a strong buzz going that the mini will probably still do well. But not as well as if it was under $200, he added.
Those were the sentiments I heard at the first big pre-CES gathering tonight.
Don't shoot the messenger, I'm just passing along what seems to be the media buzz among the CES press. I think they're right. Apple would have made a huge splash at $199. I bet that's what it goes for within six months. Several other digital music player makers - Rio, Archos and Creative Labs - will be showing off units at CES with competitive pricing that can hold more songs. Microsoft and Archos players can even playback video.
CES, BTW, starts Thursday. It's expected to be the biggest ever. There's 110,000 attendees already registered and 4,000 more reporters who've applied for credentials. The Vegas cabbies say every room in town is sold out, every airplane flight here over the next two days is filled and they've been unofficially told to expect 125,000. Or more.
I'm doing a photo blog of some of the things I come across. More later.
Rio Chiba-256MB, 120 WMA songs, $199.99.
The specs for the iPod mini far exceed those of this $200 player. Everyone always wants lower prices, but to say the iPod mini is too expensive implies that Apple is making an unreasonable profit at $249 per unit. The price does not seem out of line given the storage capacity, the ability to function as a FireWire or USB 2.0 hard drive, support of vCalendar and iCal files, etc. Sometimes quality items cost a little more, and the buyers will decide whether it is worth it. Steve Jobs said that Apple was going after the high-end flash market, and the mini seems well positioned for that market.
Posted by: ctolgc at January 7, 2004 10:21 AMThe real story at MWSF wasn't the mini iPod, but rather the unbelievable upgrades to the iLife suite, and the G5 XServe and XServe RAID upgrades. The pre-show mini iPod rumor mill was in full swing, and probably created unreasonable expectations about the pricing structure. As others have pointed out, the MiniPod compares very favorably to the competition, although at $199, they probably couldn't have made the things fast enough.
At any rate, the iLife suite was, for most of us, the star of the show. The rest is just icing. It's going to be a great year.
Posted by: Rich at January 7, 2004 10:58 AMLike Rich, I think the iLife '04 package was the show stopper of the keynote (the G5 Xserve and the Xserve RAID while very cool, aren't that exciting to the home user or the non-IT crowd). The improvements to the existing iApps look great and I really can't wait to get my hands on GarageBand!
The iPod mini at $249 would actually make me consider the 15GB iPod - hey, 50 bucks more gets you 3x the capacity and access to accessories that don't work with the mini, like the memeory card reader for storing digital photos. For now though, I'll remain 'Pod-less'. I'm hinging my bets on a 6GB mini hitting the market this summer at $249 and the 4GB dropping to $199. In that 6 months, all of the same cool gizmos that are available for the iPod should also work with the mini.
Posted by: Tim S. at January 7, 2004 12:49 PMI agree with Rich. I can't wait to play with GarageBand. I have already put my order in for the new iLife and an adapter that let's you plug your guitar in to the Mac's mini line in jack.
I was a little disappointed to see the $249 price tag, but remember that the iPods are usually more expensive than other (although lower end) players, but that sure hasn't hurt Apple at all. You charge what the Market will bare, and the Market hasn't given Apple much reason to lower prices. That being said, I also agree it will be $199 in the Summer (they'll lower it in time to catch those back-to-school purchases) and we should even see an even smaller 2GB model for $99. At that pricing Apple will have a monopoly for the first time ever. Exciting, isn't it?
I really like the look of the new wheel/button combo and can't wait to see one in person. I would expect it becomes the new standard for the "big" iPods allowing them to save a little space as they transition from 1.8" drives to the new 1" drives.
My first blog post!
Posted by: Mike at January 7, 2004 12:53 PMHi Mike,
For the record, the official capilalization is "Macworld".
Cheers,
Mark
Posted by: Mark Millard at January 7, 2004 07:02 PMLet's remember the iPod history get some insight into the mini pricing strategy.
The first 5 GB iPod debute at $399. "Too expensive!" naysayers said. But surprising nearly everyone, the iPod went on to sell more than 100,000 units in its debut quarter.
Mere months later, Apple debuted 3 updated models at $299, $399, and $499. Since then, they've held the line on pricing, but upgrade each model with more capacity and updated designs.
The same thing will happen to the mini, so I don't understand all the "nashing of teeth" occuring about the $249 price. Seems like evidence of serious iPod envy more than anything else.
I really believe that had Apple introduced the mini at $199, it would have basically wiped out the market for the higher capacity siblings. After all, the mini has all the features of its bigger sibling, just in a smaller package with less storage. There's nothing you can do on a mini that you can't do on a regular ol' iPod. As a result, from a business perspective, would it make sense for Apple to purposely undermine the sales of an extraordinary product line? It'd be like BMW coming out with a sexy new 3 series sedan for just $15,000 just because "we can sell them profitably at that price." What do you think would happen to sales of the 5 series and 7 series cars then? Sure, they'd sell a heck of a lot of new $15,000 3-series, but not nearly enough to make back the revenue loss from people no longer buying a 5 or 7 series.
Just wait another 3-6 months when Apple will introduce the 4th gen iPods. Now those iPods will have features that the iPod mini won't have, and at that point, Apple can safely reduce the price of the 4 GB unit to $199 while upgrading the $249 unit to 8 GB. The $299 will still probably be at 15 GB BUT WILL HAVE FEATURES THAT CAN'T BE HAD IN A MINI (hint - video and photos. Can anyone say, "auto sync with iMovie and iPhoto?").
At that point, a $199 4 GB iPod mini makes business sense. The problem is that right now, people are looking at the $249 price from a consumer sense with considering how such a product would affect sales of the full-size iPod.
Posted by: Paul at January 7, 2004 07:41 PMHere's my idea... with the purchase of an iPod Mini, customers should also receive a Gift Certificate for $100 at the iTunes Music Store. Or $75. Hell, make it $50. That way it "feels" less expensive than $250, and you'll get another customer hooked on the iTMS. Yes, I know those songs cost Apple money, but not $0.99 each. There's gotta be wiggle room here... and at $249 for the hardware alone, it ain't gonna sell.
Posted by: Josh at January 8, 2004 11:20 PMI really don't think the mini was intended to be the cheep iPod. It's the sports car to the iPod luxury sedan. It's a BMW Z4, not a Civic. (Nothing against the Civic, my GF has a Civic)
Japan/asia is the obvious target market here - Hello Kitty Pink is a dead giveaway here folks...
Think of this iPod mini as the PowerBook 2400 (Orig. available in asia only) People complained about the 2400 not being available in the US, so after awhile the little beauty became available here in the US.. Heh, and many complained that the KB was too small and it was too expensive etc... But it was the best sub notebook Apple made before the dual-usb iBook.
All Apple has done here is make the iPod mini available worldwide from the get-go to avoid the *itching about it only being available in asia, the mini's obvious target market. It's the size of a business card for Christ's sakes!!! Take a business card and try to imagine what Apple's design team (Ive) did to design the mini.
Yes, $249 is prob too expensive to make it a runaway hit here in the States... As an Apple shareholder, sure I’m alittle concerned... a 2GB mini for $199 may have been a better bet. But I'm positive the 4GB mini will go like crazy in asian markets, and I agree that the price will drop in 6mo or so. This will be fun to watch :-)
Take deep breaths.. relax.
Posted by: Hello, again at January 9, 2004 11:48 PMiPods do photos? Not until they put a color screen in.
Posted by: Jayson at January 10, 2004 12:20 AMI think the pricing was just about right. It protects the pricing of the other iPods and it gives Apple room for price adjustment. I agree with others that supplies are probably tight right now so the slightly high price is OK. Once supplies improve and Apple wants to move more product we will start seeing special student pricing, special bundles and such. Recall last fall when students could buy a 10GB iPod for something like $65 if they bought a new Mac at the same time.
Posted by: John Konopka at January 10, 2004 04:22 AMHello, again, was right on. This wasn't the "mini" price iPod, but the "mini" size iPod, and like any electronics, when you super size, or micro size, a product, it gets very expensive. The iPod "mini", is a premium iPod but just supersmall. The pre-release hype spoiled the intro, due to unreasonable expectations for "mini" size and "mini" price. THAT, was never going to happen with a 4 Gig Microdrive. With a 2 Gig Microdrive we could have seen the $200 price point, but not with the 4 Gig model. However, given Steve's whole point for the iPod that it could carry your whole music library, 4 Gig was probably as small as he could stomach, seeing as the first iPod was 5 Gig.
Posted by: KenCheng at January 10, 2004 07:15 PMI think too that a color screen on the regular iPods will be the next upgrade that will diferenciate them from the minis. But for now, don't expect video capabilities (yet). Adding video to an iPod would require a faster processor and a decent active matrix color LCD screen, both would reduce battery life by a large amount. For now I think we could see before '05 an iPod with a small low-power passive LCD color screen like those on cellphones and a revamped color interface. Maybe some iTunes-like visuals while playing songs, and iPhoto syncing abilities and being able to export slideshows that would run on the iPod.
Posted by: BuzyBeetle at January 11, 2004 10:00 PM
someone commented, and I thought it held merit, that the iPod mini will sell fine at $249, but will soon be dropped to $199. The speculation is that Apple is short on supplies/inventory for the product and didn't want to face the bad press for immediate backorders it would have gotten at $199. It is a really cool product, and I will probably be getting a pink one for my fiancee in the near future. She has no need for 10GB or 15GB anyway, and this ultra small form factor (essentially a half-inch thick stack of business cards) is worth the extra price.
Posted by: toeknee at January 7, 2004 09:38 AM