
DSL is quite developed in my area, but I dumped it last year in favor of cable.
We need competition, though, so even though I have high disregard for my local phone provider, Qwest, and I went from paying them over $150/month for cell/dsl/phone to $0/month by going to T-Mobile/Comcast Cable/Vonage, I hope Qwest continues to improve their DSL offerings, because Comcast charges too darn much, though their service is superior in every respect, so I will not complain too much.
As wide-area wireless technology continues to improve, I might be able to disable the cable, the wires, the whole shebang in the near future. And then we might not even care about DSL...
Posted by: Toeknee at December 12, 2003 04:39 PMIn places like Japan and South Korea, a person can get something like 10Mbps for the equivalent of $24/month, whereas over here (Santa Cruz, CA), I've had to deal with an SBC DSL connection squeaking by at 322kbps for $29.95 a month. BTW, I'm not singling out SBC - my parents are also subscribers, but because their house is literally ten minutes away from the main office, their signal is much stronger.
Posted by: elendial at December 12, 2003 09:43 PMI have to agree about the strange lack of service in some areas. It's really too bad since DSL is generally cheaper (although a bit slower) than cablemodem service. I have a friend who lives 15 minutes away who is desperate for DSL but can't get the SBC service in his area.
In my situation, DSL is the obvious winner. The local cable company (Buckeye) wants 50 -100% more than SBC is charging for what amounts to be the same service. Honestly, when you're using the web normally, will you notice the difference between 1.5 and 2 megabit?
As a side note, the distance from the phone company switch doesn't matter nearly as much as the line quality. I'm pushing a consistent 1.4 - 1.5Mb despite being far away from the station. (Admittedly, it did take a couple phone calls to SBC to get some line issues fixed, but even without that I was getting a solid 768k.)
Posted by: Daniel at December 13, 2003 11:51 AMMuch of the lack of availability of DSL in the Great Lakes States goes back to SBC putting Project Pronto on the shelf and holding DSL hostage during negotiations for favorable regulations and legislation. Now that SBC can offer long distance in Michigan, Illinois, Indiana, etc., the RTs are starting to sprout again. The big question will be how much of a market will be left once things are fully rolled out? At least it will give refugees from Comcast somewhere to go.
Posted by: Mr Attitude at December 13, 2003 05:14 PMDSL finally reached my neighborhood. By now, however, I not only have cable internet but also cable telephone service. With that being the case, DSL may be ten bucks cheaper, but going back to a baby bell would cost about $70 more than my current telephone bill. *sigh* Plus, the telephone company was completely stumped as to what they could offer me when I pointed out that my $40 cable internet service was 2 megabit -- they best they had was 1.5 megabit.
"So, are you ready to switch over today, sir?" said the rep... No, I don't think so.
Posted by: Timothy R. Butler at December 15, 2003 10:32 PMHere's a kicker. Last year I signed up for Comcast broadband. We're very happy with it - averaging 1.2-1.5 mb but have gone up to 3 in spurts (and that was amazing) but are getting killed on the price. We have to pay $60 per month because we're not cable subscribers. We have had DirecTV for 10 years and cable was already installed into our home, but we're getting a $20/month surcharge since we're not "cable tv" customers. We love the speed and the uptime, but the price is killing us.
Hopefully, Comcast will give us a break. I've been emailing them back and forth to cut us some slack and they agreed it needed to be done - but, as of today, it hasn't happened.
DSL is an option, but from what I understand in our area - the cable is much more reliable. Ugh!
Posted by: Stephen Taylor at December 29, 2003 10:40 AM
In my neck of the woods, DSL is available and somewhat competitive with Cable, but there's a confusing array of plans with different rates for different upload/download speeds, bandwidth usage, etc.
Bleh.
Cable gives me consistently fast access, single-plan (flat rate) pricing, and they give me a slight price break if I bundle my Internet access and Cable TV bill. That's why they get my business.
Posted by: Rich at December 12, 2003 10:17 AM