« 10.2.8 upgrade and PB battery life | Main | Coming tomorrow: A dream system »

September 30, 2003

Internet taxes are pretty much a given

I remain firmly opposed to an Internet sales tax on out-of-state companies that have no physical presence in a state and don't draw on any governmental resources. But big business and big retailers hold so much clout that they've pushed mandatory sales tax legislation pretty much through all the states and now, apparently, even Congress. I just don't think this "even playing field" analogy that the brick and mortar whiners keep spouting holds water. Online companies aren't even on a field, for crying out loud. They're virtual, requiring no police and fire protection, causing no traffic congestion, no utility usage or any of the other governmental service demands imposed by traditional brick and mortar retailers.
in Internet | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I don't see how they are a given based on the article you linked to. That article seems to say it is unlikely to pass congress. So, you think it is given based on state legislation or what?

We need to have a conversation in this country about when taxes are appropriate. Our current system is predicated on the idea that anytime money changes hands, some of that money belongs to the government. This leads to an unjust system. For instance, It is unjust, in my view, to tax earnings and property while someone is alive, then tax that person's heirs upon his or her death. Why is death a taxable event?

If we add internet taxes, I will pay a tax to California when I buy my next Powerbook from Apple, then if I sell it on eBay, someone else may have to pay taxes again on the same item. Where is the justice in that?

BTW: Some items online ARE taxed. I distinctly remember paying a California tax on my Ti-Book G4 purchased online from Apple. So, when is an online item taxable or non-taxable? We need a more consistent approach to taxation.

Posted by: Davis at September 30, 2003 03:53 PM

As far as the tax goes, Michigan has had a "use" tax on purchases made from out of state via mail or phone for years. Internet is the same thing, just using a different means for ordering. The tax is supposed to be collected when one files their state income tax forms. For whatever reason, many people "forget" to account for these purchases and don't pay the tax (essentially a form of tax evasion, but rarely prosecuted). One of the intents of the proposed federal law is to collect the appropriate tax at the time of sale and forward it to the appropriate states. Is it another tax? Not really - it is more of a means to actually collect on an existing tax.

In answer to Davis' question regarding when online items are directly taxed, historically if the seller has a presence in the state that the buyer resides, the seller is required to collect sales tax for the buyer's state at the time of sale. For example, prior to Cabela's opening their store in Dundee, they never collected sales tax on my mail order or internet purchases. They do now, since they have a presence in Michigan. While this may sound like wordsmithing, online purchases are all taxable (with the exception of food and other sales tax exempt items) - it is more of a case of whether taxes are collected by the seller at the time of sale or if the buyer is "supposed" to account for it on their annual tax forms.

Posted by: Mr Attitude at October 1, 2003 12:13 AM

I know this is the wrong place to post but do you know a website that compares different scanners?

Posted by: Kala at October 1, 2003 06:39 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits