« eBay didn't like my Safari | Main | Storm Chasers put extreme weather video online »

September 22, 2003

Download limits set for broadband users

Comcast Cable and Cox Communications are among big cable broadband providers setting caps, or limits, to how much a subscriber can download from the Internet, though the companies are reluctant to talk about it, according to this CNET piece.
What is too much use? Cox says its 2 gigabytes a day--the equivalent of about two compressed feature-length movies or about 400 MP3 songs.
Comcast wouldn't release the formula it uses but says one percent of its subscribers have been sent warning letters over the past couple of months for collectively using about 28 percent of the company's bandwidth. A Comcast spokesperson was quoted saying that worked out to each of them downloading the equivalent of 90 movies in a given month.
The folks over at Slashdot aren't going to like this.
in Broadband | TrackBack (1)

Comments

A friend recently told me about WOW: http://www1.wowway.com

WOW lets you choose how much bandwidth you'd like to pay for. It offers four packages from 112 Kbps all the way to 3 Mbps.

As a Comcast customer, I'd rather see them throttle bandwidth up or down based on price, as WOW does. Personally, I'd like to pay less and would accept a slower bandwidth speed, but I'm given no choice.

Of course, WOW is not available in my area, so that brings us to the other touchy subject of competition in broadband....

Posted by: Davis at September 22, 2003 03:36 PM

Looks like I am not going to be able to download that new version of Mandrake .... it's absolutly rediculas....

Posted by: Dennis at September 22, 2003 05:28 PM

One significant difference between the Cox approach and the Comcast approach is that Cox is willing to define set limits. Comcast continues to take a "we'll know it when we see it" approach, in that there are no hard limits. From a marketing perspective, this is great - no one can use a "X GB per month" limit against Comcast. From a customer perspective, there is no way to effectly meter one's usage to prevent going afoul of the nebulous AUP.

There is no clear indication what criteria Comcast Abuse uses to generate warning letters or suspend service. As noted in the CNET article, users that have received warning letters in reference to their monthly use and inquired regarding what level of use is acceptable have received responses that can be described as evasive (at best). I also found Comcast trying to steer residential customers to Comcast commercial accounts to be an additional cute twist to the tale (based on the closing text of letters sent to "offenders").

Imagine getting a speeding ticket on a road with no posted speed limit. Since you had no idea that you were speeding, you ask how fast you can go down that road without getting another ticket. Imagine being told that there is no speed limit on the road, but you need to slow down with no further indication of how fast is too fast.

The circular argument in the Comcast case is almost humorous. "Why did I get a letter?" "Because you exceeded your monthly bandwidth limit." "What is the limit?" "There is no established limit." "Then why did I get the letter?"...

It would be interesting to find out if Comcast's intent is to selectively remove specific customers from their network in order to make room for the much touted increase in download speeds later this year (without incurring costly network upgrades to support the higher speeds).

Posted by: Mr. Attitude at September 25, 2003 10:14 AM

In response to the post by Davis, since WOW isn't available in your area, have you taken a look at SBC Yahoo! DSL? They have packages ranging from 384 to 6M.

Posted by: Mr. Attitude at September 26, 2003 03:57 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits