« Zudfunck returns! | Main | How's my font? »

July 08, 2003

T-Mobile outages

The T-Mobile Sidekick is a great device but the T-Mobile network is - hands down - the most unreliable and erratic network I have ever tried to use. It seems to be out more than it is operational - at least with the Sidekick. I've heard some say the fault is more with theSidekick and a crummy antenna but even no antenna would connect more than the unit I'm using does on a halfway decent network.
in | TrackBack (0)

Comments

You think T-Mobile is bad? Try Sprint's PCS "not-work." Truth be told, none of the cellcos are 100% reliable, nor are any of them upfront about. Yeah, sure, they post their coverage maps right in their stores and on the Web, but you're never told about network overloads and outages...never mind imcompatibilities between networks or the endless upgrades they force upon hapless consumers.

And, as for Sprint, they go as far as to put stores in neighborhoods they know damn well lack adequate coverage (they get around not having in-store signals by installing high-powered repeaters on their rooftops...gee, must be nice).

Anyway, good luck with your Sidekick. Personally, I give it a few more years before it vanishes into vaporware, but I've eaten my own words before.

Posted by: Dino Baskovic at July 8, 2003 01:43 PM

I hear people bitch and moan about how one provider is better than another.. but it really comes down to two things: 1) Quality of the handset, and 2) Quality of coverage where you LIVE and WORK.

I've met people who say that XXXX network sucks.. but it really just sucks in their area.

Case and point, I was a T-Mobile customer and I had quality service.. until I got an Ericsson T68. This unit, like many Nokias, lacks an external antenna. As such, the reception quality in spotty areas will be worse than a similar phone equipped with an external antenna. But the kicker of it is that the quality in my area (metro-Atlanta) actually DEGRADED. I had several other friends in the same area with different handsets and they all noticed the same symptoms.

i.e... more dropped calls, garbled conversations, etc. A lot of this stems from OVERSELLING in a specific area. When the systems powering these towers are overloaded, you either get busy signals (or call not completed msgs), or garbled convos.

I switched to Sprint and have had nothing but positive experiences in the areas where I live and work. No busy signals, very few dropped calls, etc. So like I said, it all depends....

Posted by: Mike at July 8, 2003 02:07 PM

Agreed, Mike, though you are giving the common consumer way too much credit for being patient with or even aware of such issues pre-purchase. And in the end, it's costing us all a lot more money than we'd like to admit.

Posted by: Dino Baskovic at July 8, 2003 04:08 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits