« Going mobile from the bike ride | Main | Apple's dizzying innovation »

June 25, 2003

Orrin Hatch scares me

I think unrestrained downloading of copyrighted music is wrong - digital shoplifting, if you will. But I think it's a problem that will solve itself. We now have an example of a reasonable model to get music into our computers and MP3 players with Apple's iTunes Music Store. As Apple expands that for Windows and rivals come on board with their own competing systems the problem will marginalize those hardcore thieves who insist on stealing.
Most people, I believe, are more than willing to pay a reasonable fee for downloaded music. And the music industry is finally responding and realizing they can make money from the Net if they provide a real service as Apple has pioneered.
But the much-circulated remarks of the Utah Republican that he wouldn't mind if a virus be sent to "destroy" the computers of those who ignore warnings to stop stealing music online scares me.
Because as far fetched as it sounds, the really frightening thing is that such a thing is actually possible right now. They even have a name for it: "Retribution technology."


in Piracy | TrackBack (0)

Comments

The recording industry, and many artists, are so wrapped up in their fear of getting screwed they can't see the reality in front of their face. I have three teenage daughters, two of whom are seriousely in to music. They both were users of Napster and now use Kazzaa alomst daily. They do download some of the radio hits, but mostly they are looking for new bands - Indies. When they find a band they like that isn't getting any radio play, which is frequent, they announce it to all their friends then look for the bands music releases and BUY the CD's as well as searching these bands out when they're on tour.

My kids will tell you they do this not because they want to rip-off music, but because the Radio and recording industry Suck. There is plenty of fresh quality music out there, but it is getting almost no attention from the commercial sector. So, kids like mine are looking for the music and using Shareware to do it.

As a side note, these indie bands are usually struggeling so they travel the country in cars and vans doing gigs where ever they can and the kids are flocking to nightclubs, brokedown theaters and even backyard parties to see them. Kinda sounds like the music scene before big money found it in the 60's.

Point being, companies like Columbia, BMG and Clearchannel are missing the boat. It's not that these kids don't want to spend the money on CD's. The problem is they don't want to spend it on what they're being offered by the mainstream recording industry. Rather than attack the users of these services the industry should be taking note and giving the kids what they want.

This is a message, not a theft.

After saying all that it is clear some who use the technology are doing it as a means of theft. It is most obvious in movie downloads. But they are far from all shareware users.

Posted by: Dietz at June 25, 2003 11:01 AM

The last that I checked, the Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, and Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution are still in place. One would think that the Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee would be aware of those.

If the basis for Senator Hatch's remarks is the defense of the rights of copyright holders, the following article from "wired" is quite interesting: http://wired.com/news/politics/0,1283,59305,00.html

As for the woes of the RIAA, I can see why their sales are down. Looking at the concerts coming up at DTE Energy Music Theatre and Comerica Park, I already have some of the best tunes produced by the majority of the performing artists - ON VINYL LPs!!!

Posted by: Mr Attitude at June 29, 2003 01:21 AM

Orrin Hatch is a little loopy. I've always sorta liked him, but boy he put his foot in it with this one.

Posted by: Dean Esmay at June 29, 2003 09:49 AM

Orrin Hatch is a little loopy. I've always sorta liked him, but boy he put his foot in it with this one.

Posted by: Dean Esmay at June 29, 2003 09:49 AM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits