« Does this look okay? | Main | Anybody crying over Microsoft's Safari retaliation? »

June 14, 2003

Hoax debunking site stumbles on 8th grade test

During a long drive to Indiana the other day I caught San Diego radio host Roger Hedgecock subbing for Rush Limbaugh and talking about a final exam to 8th graders in Salina, KS in 1895.
Holey moley. What a test! It's been circulating around the Net for the last several years now as evidence of the dumbing down of American public education.
Is it for real, though? The place to check is the normally reliable Urban Legends page at Snopes.com, which chronicles and debunks many of the hoaxes and myths that circulate these days. And sure enough, Snopes has an entry on this supposed test. But if you casually look at the Snopes report, you're left with the clear impression there was no such test.
But read closer. What Snopes debunks is the premise of the test as offered in Net e-mails today - namely that it demonstrates a shocking decline in educational standards. That's what Snopes says is false.
It doesn't say the exam wasn't really given in 1895, it just argues against the decline in standards premise, going on and on and on and sounding awfully defensive of today's educrats.
I'm disappointed in the way Snopes handled this one, although it does also present a very challenging teacher's exam from even earlier that shows what teachers were expected to know more than a century ago.
But as to the 8th grade test, true or false is what people want to know when they get this in e-mail click over to Snopes to see if it's for real. They don't want Snopes' political view on the state of American education issue. They want to know did the test really exist?
It did. Hedgecock says he checked with Salina officials, who verified it.
Snopes could have done a better job making that clear, before launching into its take on the dumbing down issue.
I thought the Snopes guys were smarter than that.


in Internet | TrackBack (0)

Comments

I manage a medium-sized retail operation at an upscale mall in the Boston suburbs that hires a lot of kids right out of high school or in college. I can tell you that year after year, they are getting worse, not better. They can't add, can't write and are woefully deficient in grammar and basic conversational English.

Posted by: Martin V at June 14, 2003 08:24 AM

I agree about the real dumbing down of the education system.

In Texas they have a test called TAKS and they are all up in arms because of the high failure rate in public schools, claiming the test is unfair, especially as far as race is concerned, etc...

It is remarkable when they check on the failing scores at the local public schools, and, compare them with the scores being achieved at Lackland and Randolph Air Force Base Schools which had passing scores in the 90 percentile area.

All the families on the Air Bases know what education means and they value the achievement it can allow. If the child becomes a problem in the school the Commander will notify the parent to make them shape up. It is a parental responsibility

Many of the regular citizens do not push their children to achieve and in fact often don't put any effort into seeing that they do anything at all. The school accepts no responsibility and the parent does not either. So the child is totally without guidance.

The parent has also been dumbed down, during their time in the educational system, and they can offer little assistance to the Child academically since they know very little. Their lack of proper education is a large part of the problem. A pure case of the blind leading the blind because the stupid are teaching the stupid...

Being a retired Military person I can say that in the Service one continues to learn through-out their entire career.

As they say it is "Up or Out" since you must continue to improve or leave the system.

Lee Mensinger
New Braunfels, Texas

Posted by: Lee Mensinger at June 14, 2003 01:18 PM

I read the Snopes.com explanation completely, and I agree with their evaluation of the test as not being an accurate or substantive means to support "The Dumbing Down of American Education." I challenge anyone, including myself, to pass the World Geography portion of the SOL Test in Virginia right now this minute without having any time to "cram." The test of 1895 was not an example of what students learn today, which is much more inclusive and pertinent to the world as we live in it.

Posted by: Lynn V. at June 14, 2003 02:13 PM

This councilwoman in Sacremento has the best explanation yet (last line):

http://sacbee.com/content/news/columns/erwin/story/6837589p-7787711c.html

Posted by: gerry at June 14, 2003 09:02 PM

Quick Links


    mike!

Google

Web This site

Site Credits