
The move towards some sort of federal anti-spam legislation continues to pick up speed. But what concerns a growing number of anti-spam activists is that so many bills are pending that whatever compromise ends up getting passed will be so watered down that it may result in more spam, not less. I recount all the current proposals pending in Congress in my column today in the Free Press. The bottom line is a growing coalition of anti-spam groups say the solution is an opt-in list, not the opt-out list which unfairly puts the burden on the consumer.
One of the problems with "Opt-Out" that I've never seen described in spam articles has to do with identifying repeated spam messages. You think, gosh, seems like I've seen and deleted this message before, but don't remember which of the last hundred or so messages it was. During the time I was tracking spam I found most messages were repeated every two weeks to a month and it was obvious nearly all came from the same set of spammers. I recall forwarding about forty of one variety, having to do with "j u d i c i a l j u d g e m e n t s" to the FTC over a period of about six months (I like to think some judicial judgement will, or has, put that spammer in the slammer). In the "Opt-out" scenario, the recipient would have to start keeping a record of all spam messages received to determine whether or not the "opt-out" request was being honored. The degree of difficulty in this task is would be magnified if the sender or advertiser changed its E-mail or website address. "Opt-out hardly seems like a solution at all to controlling spam.
Posted by: Tracer at June 6, 2003 06:19 PM
I agree with "opt-in" only. Internet users can probably find any goods or services they desire through internet search engines. "Opt-out" just recreates the contents of telephone yellow pages in our in-boxes. It's not as if e-mail was the only communications channel available to advertisers, though it is one of the few in which the end-user is forced to pay for the commercials.
Posted by: Tracer at May 29, 2003 11:18 AM