
Next time some high-stressed obnoxious lout is chatting away on his mobile phone next to you on an airplane after the doors are closed, turn him in to the flight attendants or scream at him to turn it off. Seems all those warnings the crew routinely mumbles are true. This Brit study says cell phone use can cause a compass to freeze or to overshoot its actual magnetic bearing. Also, flight deck and navigation equipment indicators can be rendered unstable and inaccurate, and transmissions can interfere with critical audio outputs.
Mostly baloney--
#1- the cell phone story has been going around for years-- see http://www.snopes.com/autos/hazards/gasvapor.asp for the debunking.
#2- I doubt the cell phone in the plane story, at least as it applies to the U.S. A friend of mine is an engineer for the FAA, and he told me that in order for a jetliner to become certified for flight, it has to endure a test in hangar where it is bombarded with radio interference many thousands of times as powerful as a cell phone, and if any of its instrumentation blips, it fails. So COULD it happen, I suppose yes, but the primary reason cell phones are banned are just to be sure, not because it likely to cause a problem, plus the airlines are all too willing to comply with it because the alternative for some people is the in-flight phones they make so much money from.
T
Posted by: Tony at May 5, 2003 09:23 PMAs a student pilot with enough experience to tell you about this, the cellular phone rule on airplanes has absolutely nothing to do with the FAA. It also produces no interference with any magnetic, electronic or other instruments in the plane. In fact, after an altitude of 2500 feet is achieved, you won't even get a signal. Why? Cellular phone transmitters transmit down, not up. When I'm out flying and want to make a phone call, I have to fly directly between two cell phone towers at less than 2500 feet and circle that area for the duration of the call. Also, part of the problem is that when I do fly, I'm flying in a pipe cheroee which puts a big hunk of sheet metal between me and the tower. It's called the wing.
Anyway, the reason for the no cellphone rule on planes comes from the fcc, not the faa. A cellular phone at altitude can be received by many cellular towers at one time, causing all kinds of digital havoc on the ground. So the towers generally spend a lot of time "handing you off" to each other at a very rapid rate. This causes problems with other people trying to make phone calls while firmly planted on solid ground. So out of courtesy to your fellow cellular-phone-toting citizens, refrain from using the phone in the air. By the way, you're perfectly legal to use it on the ground from the runway to the terminal and beyond because at that point, you're not at altitude.
Posted by: Bill Carver at May 5, 2003 10:25 PMThis issue is primarily concerned with passenger jetliners, but it is interesting to note your experience as a private pilot in a small aircraft. However, your statement:
"As a student pilot with enough experience to tell you about this, the cellular phone rule on airplanes has absolutely nothing to do with the FAA."
I would have to direct you to FAA advisory circular 91.21-1 at http://ntl.bts.gov/DOCS/91-21_1.html which in part states: "The FCC currently prohibits the use and operation of cellular telephones while airborne..." and "The FAA supports this airborne restriction for reasons of potential interference to critical aircraft systems." This leaves me with the strong impression that the FAA would restrict it even if the FCC had nothing to say, because reasons are different.
You also wrote: "By the way, you're perfectly legal to use it on the ground from the runway to the terminal and beyond because at that point, you're not at altitude." This is misleading. The FAA actually leaves it up to the airline's and/or captain's discretion, therefore their discretion is "the law." The carrier I fly most often (NWA) restricts cell phone use anytime the cabin door is closed, and they are legally allowed to do so. I don't know if their reasons are completely in the interest of safety. They know that while a phone is stranded on the ground waiting for a gate (all too common with NWA), many business folks with company credit cards will just swipe their cards through the in-flight phones; they have no problem having their company pay the $3-$5/min.
A few years back, my niece was on a plane waiting on the tarmac for two hours while waiting for weather at the destination airport. Problem was, we had driven an hour to drop her off, and she had a cranky newborn baby with her. She kept calling us to tell us not to leave the airport, while NWA would give us no information about the flight. After being threatened repeatedly by the flight attendants, she did her best to covertly call us with updates. The flight was eventually cancelled, and thank goodness we had waited, as it was the last flight of the night. The point being, there was no practical reason for the airline to restrict calls while the flight's status was in question and they waited on the tarmac, but they did. There is no evidence whatsoever that cell phones can affect an airliner sitting on the ground. I hope this issue is eventually clarified.
T
Posted by: Tony at May 6, 2003 10:17 AMThe letter of the law. Note three things.
The FAA has no regulation on cellular phones on aircraft, but they support the FCC regulations.
b. Portable electronic devices designed to transmit have
considerations in addition to paragraph 6a. There are certain
devices which, by their nature and design, transmit
intentionally. These include cellular telephones, citizens band
radios, remote control devices, etc. These devices are typically
licensed as land mobile devices by the Federal Communications
Commission (FCC). The FCC currently prohibits the use and
operation of cellular telephones while airborne. Its primary
concern is that a cellular telephone, while used airborne, would
have a much greater transmitting range than a land mobile unit.
This could result in serious interference to transmissions at
other cell locations since the system uses the same frequency
several times within a market. Since a cellular mobile
telephone unit is capable of operating on all assignable cellular
frequencies, serious interference may also occur to cellular
systems in adjacent markets. The FAA supports this airborne
restriction for reasons of potential interference to critical
aircraft systems. Currently, the FAA does not prohibit use of
cellular telephones in aircraft while on the ground if the
operator has determined that they will not cause interference
with the navigation or communication system of the aircraft on
which they are to be used. An example might be their use at the
gate or during an extended wait on the ground, while awaiting a
gate, when specifically authorized by the captain. A cellular
telephone must not be authorized for use while the aircraft is
being taxied for departure after leaving the gate. The unit
must be turned off and properly stowed, otherwise it is possible
that a signal from a ground cell could activate it. Whatever
procedures an operator elects to adopt should be clearly spelled
out in oral departure briefings and by written material provided
to each passenger to avoid passenger confusion.
on a personal note.....
Northwest airlines have never been on my list of people truly concerned with their customers. They just fly meat.
Also... no using your cell phones while filling your gas tank! Read artical in link below:
http://www.shadetreemechanic.com/cs%20mobile%20phone%20gas%20pump%20fires.htm
Posted by: Geek at May 4, 2003 10:20 AM